Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(KBS Radio, Hello! This Is Yoon Jun-ho) [Interview] Dr. Yun Suk-myung (Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs): “An Overhaul That Reduces the Weight of Property and Automobiles for Individually Insured Contributors” (January 10, 2017)

2026.11.21
(KBS Radio, Hello! This Is Yoon Jun-ho) [Interview] Dr. Yun Suk-myung (Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs): “An Overhaul That Reduces the Weight of Property and Automobiles for Individually Insured Contributors” (January 10, 2017)

□ Air date: Tuesday, January 10, 2017
□ Guest: Dr. Yun Suk-myung (Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs)



“An Overhaul That Reduces the Weight of Property and Automobiles for Individually Insured Contributors”

[Yoon Jun-ho] The plan to overhaul the health insurance contribution assessment system, over which equity concerns have been raised again and again. Yesterday, in announcing its 2017 work plan, the Ministry of Health and Welfare set out the direction for overhauling the health insurance contribution assessment system. Will the health insurance contribution burden on individually insured contributors be eased somewhat, and can the controversy over the unfairness of health insurance contributions be laid to rest? We will look at the details with Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Research Fellow Yun, hello.

[Yun Suk-myung] Yes, hello.

[Yoon Jun-ho] In January 2015, then-Minister of Health and Welfare Moon Hyung-pyo said he would announce the government’s plan to overhaul health insurance contributions, then canceled it a day before. Now, a little over three years after the government said it would push ahead, the overhaul plan has come out. What is the most important reason it took so long to relaunch the effort?

[Yun Suk-myung] We use the difficult term “contribution assessment system” for this. If contributions are assessed under the current system, there are groups that gain relatively and groups that lose. Since circumstances have changed a great deal, if the system were properly fixed in a good direction, the groups that have gained relatively a great deal until now would see their contribution burden rise, so there would be a lot of pushback against that. On the other hand, when the groups that relatively gain, having usually lost before, start to gain, they do not usually raise their political voices about it, do they? Because the level of the monthly contribution burden could change greatly, there was concern that the political backlash over this would be very large, and I think that burden is why the discussion was halted midway. Let me add one point for reference: the political landscape is now changing a great deal, and until now the opposition parties—the Democratic Party, the Justice Party, and the People’s Party—had been very vocal about the contribution assessment system. With these things coinciding, I think discussion of the overhaul plan is now getting into full swing.

[Yoon Jun-ho] Then what is the most important core of the direction for overhauling the assessment system that the Ministry of Health and Welfare included in its 2017 New Year work plan?

[Yun Suk-myung] As you have probably heard many times, workplace-insured contributors at present basically pay on their monthly wages, and if their comprehensive income exceeds 72 million won a year, they pay additional contributions only on that portion. For the so-called individually insured, however—people who do not receive a monthly wage—income is hard to identify, so even when they had no income at all, contributions were assessed by estimating their income from housing, automobiles, and the like, as well as from various factors such as their economic activity participation rate. As a result, people who had a home to live in but in fact no income ended up with fairly high contributions, and there was a great deal of dissatisfaction about this. So this time, in response to the criticism that the individually insured bore a relatively heavy contribution burden, the direction appears to have been set toward reducing the weight of property and of items such as automobiles.

[Yoon Jun-ho] So the weight of property will be reduced and shifted toward income, but rather than all at once, they intend to proceed in stages?

[Yun Suk-myung] The opposition argues that the change has to be made properly in one go for it to be done right, but as I said earlier, the stakeholders are so complex that there are likely to be many difficult problems no one has anticipated. From the government’s standpoint, it seems to be thinking of a gradual transition over a period of about five years.

[Yoon Jun-ho] You will remember the case of the Songpa mother and two daughters, which became a major issue some time ago. Their entire assets were a 5 million won jeonse deposit, yet on the grounds that this counted as property, they were told to pay 50,000 won in health insurance contributions. That is what caused the controversy.

[Yun Suk-myung] To explain that a little further, the case of the Songpa mother and two daughters you just mentioned was a truly tragic event, was it not? They were living in a single basement room in a detached house on a 36 million won jeonse, and the mother could not work because, among other things, she had hurt her back. With no income, they had to pay 44,000 won in health insurance contributions under the 2015 assessment standard, which caused them economic hardship. Let me give one more example: take an elderly couple aged 70 who live in a modest 80 million won apartment and collect wastepaper. People like them are also classified as individually insured, and our reality is that property points and economic activity points are assigned to them and contributions of about 90,000 won a month are levied. So there is a fairly broad social consensus that, although health insurance is social insurance and we should all pay health insurance contributions fairly and evenly, in many respects that is not the case.

[Yoon Jun-ho] That is exactly why this overhaul direction has come out. Then, if the contributions assessed on property and automobiles are reduced and the weight placed on income is raised instead, how much could that help low-income individually insured contributors? Please explain in concrete terms.

[Yun Suk-myung] This is not simple. The government says it will finalize the overhaul plan on the basis of the various opinions raised through the National Assembly and the public hearing on the 23rd. But I think I can explain it the other way around. A moment ago I briefly mentioned the case of the Songpa mother and two daughters and the elderly couple who collect wastepaper; these are cases where people actually had no income but contributions were assessed by converting things such as property into income. For people like these, what the government and the opposition propose is basically to assess contributions on the basis of income flows, so in such cases contributions are likely to fall sharply. That does not seem to mean they would pay no contributions at all, though. Take the opposition’s plan as an example—since this has to be settled through political compromise—under the Democratic Party of Korea’s plan announced last year, a minimum contribution of 3,000 to 4,000 won a month would be levied where there is no income. So, as I see it, for low-income households paying from 50,000 won up to 70,000 or 80,000 won, or for groups that have only property and no income, the final decision will depend on the outcome, but the conclusion could go as far as their paying contributions at a largely nominal level.

[Yoon Jun-ho] Baby boomers and the retired generation in particular seem likely to find themselves in that situation. Another problem now is that there have been cases where parents with considerable wealth and a lot of real estate were still registered as dependents of their children who work at a company, have there not? This has been called free-riding on health insurance—will this be improved as well?

[Yun Suk-myung] It seems they intend to make substantial changes here. Looking at the period from 2003 to last year, the number of people registered under employed children and others—this, of course, includes not only parents but also students and adolescents—rose sharply to close to 20 million. From 2003 to last year it surged from 25% to 30%. Quite a few of these people are economically well off. So it looks likely that the system will change so that at least 1.5 million to 2.5 million of them pay contributions, as we tighten the eligibility criteria for dependent status.

[Yoon Jun-ho] About 1.5 million to 2 million people, then.

[Yun Suk-myung] That differs depending on how high the threshold is set. Because the number of people changes greatly depending on where the cutoff is set, I think I have to put it this way.

[Yoon Jun-ho] For the workplace-insured, contributions are currently assessed mostly on wages alone. But there are people who, although workplace-insured, have a building inherited from their parents, own several shops, or have large financial income, and so earn a lot of interest or rental income, are there not? Should not all of that be included for such people as well?

[Yun Suk-myung] At present, among salaried workers there are—I am not sure I should use this expression—people born with golden or silver spoons, are there not? There seem to be quite a few people who, though they hold a job, have more income from other sources than from their wages. Among salaried workers, those whose comprehensive taxable income exceeds 72 million won a year numbered about 36,000 as of the year before last. For them, comprehensive taxable income is added to their wages when contributions are assessed. The problem, however, is that there is something of a trap here. A limit of 40 million won is set for each type of income. As a result, there are extreme cases in which, adding up financial income and other income, a person can avoid paying contributions on as much as 120 million won. So although comprehensive taxable income is applied to those above the 72 million won threshold, people with annual income of, for example, 20 million won or more, 30 million won or more, or 50 million won or more are not paying. The direction seems to be turning toward having them pay additional contributions on this. What the government is currently considering seems to be lowering the threshold to about 20 million won and expanding coverage.

[Yoon Jun-ho] When this contribution assessment system is finalized smoothly in the National Assembly after the public hearing on the 23rd, we naturally hope there will be no further controversy over equity. Thank you for speaking with us today.

[Yun Suk-myung] Yes, thank you.

[Yoon Jun-ho] That was Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.

https://news.kbs.co.kr/news/mobile/view/view.do?ncd=3408609

Related Posts