(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Interview] Yun Suk-myung: “100 Trillion Won of National Pension Money for Public Investment? — Recovery of the Principal Cannot Be Guaranteed” (Posted June 10, 2016, 12:05 a.m.)
* Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on PBC Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today! This Is Yoon Jae-seon>
[Key Remarks]
“The National Pension public investment policy may be necessary, but it is worrying”
“It may run up against the liquidity principle, and recovering the principal may become difficult”
“The National Pension public investment policy is hard to see as forward-looking”
“To manage the rate of return of the National Pension fund, the business return on rental housing would also have to rise”
“The rate of return may conflict with the policy goal of housing stability for ordinary people”
“If it undermines the National Pension’s financial stability, legal controversy may arise”
“The National Pension’s rate of return varies depending on the point in time”
“The National Pension should move toward raising its rate of return while guaranteeing the principal”
“Japan’s financial instability in pensions deepened with population aging... it abandoned investment in welfare projects”
“Japan put priority on the profitability of fund management... and switched to an operating system centered on financial markets”
[Full Transcript]
The Democratic Party of Korea has put forward a National Pension public investment policy as its No. 1 economic democratization pledge.
The core is to build and supply public rental housing and childcare facilities with funds raised by issuing “National Peace-of-Mind Bonds” for public investment.
However, the National Pension is a fund created to guarantee people’s livelihood in old age,
and voices of concern are being raised over whether investing it in public projects is really appropriate.
Let us connect with Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, and hear his views.
▷ Hello, Committee Member Yun.
▶ Yes, hello.
▷ First, setting aside whether one is for or against it. What the Democratic Party of Korea has proposed is to use the National Pension fund to build and supply public rental housing and childcare facilities. Could you explain what exactly they intend to pursue and how?
▶ It has not yet come out as a bill, so it is difficult to speak in great detail.
According to the Democratic Party of Korea’s press release, the idea is to take 10 trillion won a year from the National Pension fund and invest a total of 100 trillion won over 10 years. It would be invested in long-term public rental housing and childcare facilities.
Housing problems for ordinary people and low fertility are emerging as major social problems right now, are they not? Their position seems to be that they will try to solve these problems through this plan.
▷ Thank you for the detailed explanation. What is your position, Committee Member Yun Suk-myung?
▶ As for using a substantial share of the National Pension fund for a public investment policy, there may of course be a need for it, but I am very concerned.
Because the purpose of introducing the National Pension is to be the minimum, the last safety net for old-age income security, is it not? If that is its purpose, every effort should be made to keep to the National Pension system’s original intent of old-age income security, and I am concerned that, because our circumstances are difficult, there is talk of using this money for various purposes, with public investment being discussed as part of that.
Above all, if you look at the principles of National Pension fund management in Article 101 of the National Pension Act, the first is profitability, the second is stability, followed by the principles of liquidity, independence, and so on. Even if we now attach various conditions and make public investments, there may be a part that runs up against the liquidity principle as to whether the principal can be recovered later when the money is needed.
▷ The Democratic Party expects that the risk is low and that a return at least on par with investing in government bonds can be achieved. Its position is that it is desirable to see this as a means of securing a stable and forward-looking investment destination.
▶ I will talk about the return issue in a moment. We also need to consider the point about forward-looking investment. The National Pension is a system operated over an ultra-long period. What is often mentioned these days is the era of 100-year lives, is it not?
A pension system is one in which people enter the labor market, pay contributions until retirement, and then receive benefits in old age, and how many things will happen over that long period? Yet if a large sum of as much as 100 trillion won is invested for a specific purpose and cannot respond flexibly when circumstances change suddenly, that would be hard to see as forward-looking.
The yield on government bonds is a little over 2%, whereas the business return on rental housing seems to be expected at around 4%. So they seem to be saying it is a good project because it yields a sufficient return.
But what we also need to examine here is that since the 2008 financial crisis, interest rates have been ultra-low worldwide. Rates are low now, but no one can guarantee that ultra-low rates will last for the next several decades.
If interest rates rise worldwide, government bond rates will inevitably rise as well. In that case, to manage the rate of return of the National Pension fund, the business return on rental housing would also have to rise.
If it is pursued this way, there is a possibility that the original purpose, housing stability for ordinary people through rental housing, will be undermined.
So, whichever way you look at it, the policy goals may conflict, and in that sense it is hard to say it is necessarily forward-looking.
▷ Government bonds, as you said, are yielding a little over 2%, are they not? So you also think the expectation of a return at least on par with investing in government bonds will not hold?
▶ Government bond rates are low now because we are in a period of ultra-low interest rates, but if rates rise, they will go up along with them.
▷ Is using the National Pension fund for public investment legally problematic?
▶ This, too, could be controversial. Article 100(2) of the National Pension Act contains such a provision. There is a provision on investment in the public sector for public projects. If one follows this provision and interprets it simply, there may be no particular legal problem.
But Article 102 contains a proviso. There is a provision that investment in projects to promote welfare must be made within limits that do not undermine the financial stability of the National Pension. If major controversy arises over whether this will really not undermine the National Pension’s financial stability, legal problems could emerge.
▷ Have there been cases in the past of it being used for public investment purposes?
▶ There have. In the 1990s, under what was commonly called the Public Fund Act, there was a precedent in which the government wrote out paper certificates called deposit certificates and took National Pension money for its own use.
The problem was that while the government used this money, it paid interest lower than market rates, which caused considerable losses to the National Pension.
During the 1997 financial crisis, as part of restructuring, international organizations recommended that diverting the National Pension fund in this way was not right and that this arrangement be abolished, and it was abolished after the 2000s began.
▷ I am curious how Sweden, regarded as a leading welfare state, is shaping its public pension reform and the direction of its operation.
▶ We look a great deal at Sweden’s case in all welfare policies. In Sweden, too, there were attempts in the past to achieve social policy goals through public pensions.
There also seem to have been cases of investing in housing through the purchase of government bonds. Sweden, too, with low growth and population aging darkening the sustainability and future of its pension system, carried out pension reform in 1998 after much discussion.
After the pension reform, the basic direction of policy changed altogether, excluding social policy elements such as public investment and remaining faithful to the pension system’s original purpose of old-age income security.
▷ A point repeatedly raised as a problem is that the National Pension fund’s investment returns fall far short of those of other countries’ pension funds. What do you think about this?
▶ This is a matter of considerable debate. Because our National Pension is managed very conservatively and stably compared with other pension funds, its returns are low in boom times and relatively high in recessions. So there is no small amount of controversy over whether it did well or badly, depending on which point in time one uses as the basis.
Linking this to public investment, I think the National Pension, too, should move toward raising its returns above the current level while keeping the last safeguard of guaranteeing the principal. In this situation, tying up a considerable share of the National Pension fund in public investment would also run counter to the direction of National Pension fund management.
▷ So how much has accumulated in the National Pension fund now?
▶ As of the end of last year, 512 trillion won, and it now exceeds 520 trillion won.
▷ So from what you are saying, it sounds as though the fund should be able to be put in and taken out flexibly depending on market conditions.
▶ Yes. The National Pension does not always keep accumulating; at some point, when the number of recipients grows, it has to spend a great deal, does it not? And it should move back and forth to places that yield somewhat higher and more stable returns depending on market conditions, but there may be cases where its hands are tied.
▷ I hear that even now there is a provision in the National Pension law allowing investment in welfare projects. What is the current rate of return?
▶ When it invested in welfare projects during periods of high interest rates, that is, up to 2006, it showed a return of about 3%. But in 2007 it fell to the 1% range.
As of the end of last year, 160 billion won is invested in the welfare sector, and the return for 2014 was minus 1.68%. And the average return over the five years from 2010 to 2014 was also negative. As a result, even though the provision exists, it does not invest actively in this area.
▷ If we consider that our social structure tends to resemble Japan’s, I would like us to look at Japan’s case as well. What is Japan’s public investment policy using public pensions like?
▶ I think Japan’s case offers us a great many lessons. In 1961 Japan established the so-called Pension Welfare Service Corporation and invested very heavily in welfare projects and the public sector.
As of 1998, pension reserves at the time were 140 trillion yen. Of this, about 10 trillion yen, about 7%, was invested in welfare projects. As you know, the Japanese real estate bubble collapsed in the 1990s, and with falling demand for welfare facilities, under what was called the Greenpia project, the balance of the Pension Welfare Service Corporation deteriorated badly.
And in this situation, as population aging deepened the financial instability of the pensions, Japan completely abandoned investment in welfare projects.
From 2001 to 2006, it completely switched to an operating system centered on financial markets, putting priority on the profitability of fund management.
In light of Japan’s case, approaching this on the basis of today’s optimistic outlook does not seem appropriate.
▷ It makes me think that more active discussion and debate will be needed.
Thank you for your insights today.
That was Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.
