Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(KBS Radio) [KBS Empathy Debate] “Issues in the Controversy over National Pension Public Investment and Options for Overhauling the Fund Management System” (June 23, 2017)

2026.11.21

Panel (in Korean alphabetical order) ▒

Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow: Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs
Lee Jun-haeng, Professor: Department of Economics, Seoul Women’s University
Lee Chan-jin, attorney
Jeong Sung-hoon, Professor: School of Economics and Trade, Daegu Catholic University



□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Hello, everyone. This is Baek Un-gi of KBS <Empathy Debate>. Today’s topic on <Empathy Debate> is the controversy over public investment by the National Pension. The current administration’s idea is to invest the National Pension Fund in the public sector and use it as a source of funding for the welfare of ordinary people. It was also one of President Moon Jae-in’s election pledges. But there are problems with it. One is whether profitability can really be guaranteed. Another is the argument that, because the pension is “savings-type insurance” for future generations, drawing on it in advance for the welfare of the current generation should be decided with some caution; these positions are sharply opposed. What do you think, listeners? Today on KBS <Empathy Debate>, we will discuss this in depth. Issues worth the name! Debate worth the name! KBS <Empathy Debate> begins now!

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Let me introduce the panelists joining today’s debate. Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, is here. How are you, Dr. Yun?

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, hello.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
It has been a while. You have been well, I trust?

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, I have been well.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Professor Lee Jun-haeng of the Department of Economics at Seoul Women’s University has joined us. How are you?

□ Lee Jun-haeng
How are you?

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Nice to meet you. He once served as Chair of the Social Welfare Committee of People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy. We have Attorney Lee Chan-jin with us. How are you?

□ Lee Chan-jin
Yes, hello.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon of the School of Economics and Trade at Daegu Catholic University has joined us. How are you?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, hello.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Did you come from Daegu?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Did you take the KTX?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, I came by train.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
You have come all this way to be with us. Thank you. Shall the four of you say hello together before we begin?

□ Panel
Hello.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
What we will debate today is how the National Pension should go about public investment. Before the debate, I would like us to first find out how large the National Pension is now, and how it is proposed to invest and use it. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, could you explain?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes. Among Korea’s public pensions, the National Pension accounts for a very large share.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
How large is it?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Roughly speaking, Korea’s GDP is about 1,500 trillion won. Against that GDP, the fund currently stands at about 600 trillion won, roughly. To give a sense of the scale, relative to GDP the National Pension is first in the world. And in sheer quantity, too, it is third in the world,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
600 trillion won.

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, with the United States in first place. So it already accounts for a very large share, and if we project to 2040, it will grow to 2,500 trillion won, increasing more steeply than the pace at which the National Pension Fund has grown so far. If we look at the composition of the current roughly 600 trillion won, bonds account for about 40%, around 250 trillion won. Then stocks are roughly 100 trillion won, and alternative investments 50 trillion won; alternative investments means real estate, SOC projects, and the like. In addition, there are overseas investments, whether overseas real estate or overseas stocks, at roughly 100 trillion won, and so on; that is how it can be seen to be composed.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Hearing that, the scale is truly enormous. So how is it proposed to invest this now?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Currently, a headquarters within the National Pension, the Fund Management Headquarters, draws up its own asset allocation. This is called a portfolio. A portfolio means allocating assets appropriately to reduce risk; that asset allocation is simulated every year, and based on the amounts it produces, each year an appropriate amount is set, so many trillion won in bonds, so many trillion won in stocks, and invested accordingly.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Then as for the public investment now in dispute, how does the government intend to carry it out?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
What people misunderstand is that they think the National Pension, the pension contributions they paid, will be invested directly in public projects. That is absolutely not the method; the National Pension takes up bonds issued by the state. Because it takes them up, it can receive fixed interest and the principal, so there is no risk of loss to the fund. And since it may even be paid the interest rate plus an alpha, it can be assured of higher returns than from its existing investment in government bonds, so you can think of it as simply continuing under the current system. However, whether or not the National Pension makes public investments, it has no choice but to buy bonds under its asset allocation strategy. In that sense, they named them the “National Peace-of-Mind Bonds,” to be issued by the state, and the fund’s role is to buy them; since the National Peace-of-Mind Bonds are strongly in the nature of government bonds, I can say there is no chance whatsoever of a loss.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. The National Pension is the public’s retirement savings, is it not? Attorney Lee Chan-jin, I am curious about the legal side: what kinds of projects is the National Pension permitted to carry out?

□ Lee Chan-jin
Under current law, fund management is set up in three areas: public investment projects, welfare projects, and financial operations. In practice, most of the fund, the overwhelming share, is now in finance, that is, in financial management operations in the form of profit-making projects, while public investment is in practice hardly being carried out at all. The law compels it to purchase government bonds. As for welfare projects, as a welfare project for older people, a very small loan program secured by pension benefits is under way, covering shortfalls in older people’s jeonse and monthly-rent deposits.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
So legally, the National Pension can be managed this way.

□ Lee Chan-jin
It can be managed that way. So regarding the public infrastructure investment now under discussion, Professor Jeong here described it as public investment in the form of government bonds, but it can be approached in various ways. That is, public investment could be made by purchasing government bonds, or, as an investment in the financial sector, it could be managed by purchasing domestic bonds in the form of special bonds; the model can take various forms.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Dr. Yun Suk-myung, the government has not yet made a final decision, but what does it see as the most effective way of handling the National Pension?

□ Yun Suk-myung
As you well know, the National Pension is an important pillar of the old-age income security system, intended to let our people spend their old age securely after they have worked hard during their economically active years and retired, is it not? So above all, the most important thing seems to be that the state, as a very sound manager, manages the National Pension Fund stably so that people can be confident of their old-age security without worry. From that perspective, the overarching principles of National Pension Fund management today are stability, public interest, and profitability, and these principles coexist side by side. Private pension funds put profitability first, but the National Pension is money on which the old age of the entire population depends, so stability matters; and also, as Professor Jeong Sung-hoon mentioned earlier, if this enormous sum, now about 600 trillion won, pursued profitability alone just to look after the National Pension itself, it would cause a great deal of turmoil across Korea’s entire financial market, would it not? So it does not seem to be a principle that can be viewed as simply as one might think. But from my standpoint, among the three principles, stability seems the most important, first of all.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Of course.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Next, I think public interest and profitability should be approached so that they go together. Now, what the two panelists have said seems to be that, since the current National Pension portfolio’s asset allocation is very heavily concentrated in financial assets, investing more in things that better serve public purposes, such as building childcare facilities or long-term care hospitals, would help strengthen national competitiveness and raise the fertility rate in the long run; that is the perspective from which they mention the need for this topic.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Professor Lee Jun-haeng, the public’s perception of the National Pension does not seem very favorable right now. That is because what heightened public interest in the National Pension was the revelation, during the Choi Soon-sil scandal of meddling in state affairs, that the National Pension Fund Management Committee had approved the merger of Samsung C&T and Cheil Industries even at the cost of losses, was it not? That led people to ask whether the National Pension is the government’s piggy bank, and so on.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
That is right. So there is a lot of negativity in the public’s view of the National Pension, and in fact, with regard to public investment too, it seems that in the past there was much consideration of plans to have the National Pension make public investments directly. Then, as many negative opinions arose, such as what would happen if it invested there and suffered losses, a somewhat different approach emerged, and so talk of non-marketable bonds came up. Special bonds are also being discussed. So proposals are emerging that the fund should help such projects by taking up these bonds. We will discuss this part further as we go, but if this is possible in a way that does not burden the management of the National Pension Fund, then from that standpoint I could speak in favor; the key point at issue will be exactly how that is to be done.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
All right. Then let us get into the debate. Yes, Attorney Lee Chan-jin, what would you

□ Lee Chan-jin
Yes, I want to raise this because part of what the host just said could be misleading. In the scandal of meddling in state affairs involving the Samsung C&T merger, the Fund Management Committee in fact never gave any consent or approval on that matter. Rather, even though the Fund Management Committee voiced strong opposition during the deliberations, it was carried out unilaterally by those who have now been indicted, the President and the person who was serving as Minister of Health and Welfare; I want to point out first that it was not done by the Fund Management Committee.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Yes, today’s debate issues can be divided broadly into two. The first is how you view using the National Pension, which is money for the future, now; the other is whether it can really guarantee stable returns. Then first, I would like to hear your positions on using the National Pension to increase returns somewhat. Dr. Yun Suk-myung, what is your position?

□ Yun Suk-myung
First, I would like to rephrase slightly what the host said. The proposal now in dispute to expand public investment is not so much about raising returns through the National Pension. As I said earlier, the main targets of public investment are these: we are facing low fertility and an aging society; the fertility rate is very low because housing costs so much that young people hesitate to marry; there are a great many older people, and the number of dementia patients has also grown a great deal, yet there are not enough suitable long-term care hospitals. So we need to build many of the facilities our society requires, but it is not easy for the state to raise the funds, and the essence of this, as I understand it, is for the National Pension to invest indirectly in that fundraising by buying the bonds issued. Here, since such projects usually do not generate much return, many are concerned about that, and as an alternative, the position seems to be that even if the fund invests there, even in areas that do not generate much return, the government will guarantee at least a minimum return so that no loss occurs. From that perspective, it seems to be approached not so much as raising returns but as never doing anything that harms the National Pension Fund’s investment returns, even while investing in nationally important projects. So from that angle, as Professor Lee Jun-haeng also said earlier, I think it will be very important what the appropriate range is, what percentage of the entire National Pension Fund is appropriate, how it is allocated appropriately over time, and how it will later be appropriately recovered. For example, even if the National Pension Fund purchases government and public bonds issued by the government, in the end they are the state’s debt, and when the National Pension’s finances later become difficult and the state of the nation’s overall public finances becomes difficult, that itself becomes a burden; so we need to approach this carefully from the perspective of timing and of appropriate asset allocation. That is what I would like to say.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
There is a need to be careful. Attorney Lee Chan-jin, what is your view?

□ Lee Chan-jin
Regarding profitability as well, I have been serving as a member of the Working Evaluation Committee for fund management for about ten years now. And the point is this. When we allocate assets, the areas verified as most profitable are stocks and alternative investments; alternative investments are popular lately as a new asset class. Nevertheless, we have to consider why the law and the Fund Management Guidelines classify assets in various ways and require diversified investment. That is, five asset classes are defined and managed as investment assets: domestic stocks, domestic bonds, overseas stocks, overseas bonds, and alternatives, and as of April 2017, about 50% is invested in domestic bonds. The reason so much is invested in domestic bonds is, in a word, the overall stability of the fund and liquidity once the fund matures. That is, when you hold stocks or other real assets, you have to sell them in the market to pay benefits once the fund matures. Because the shock to the market when selling is large, the liquidation risk becomes very great. By diversifying into bonds, the fund secures its stability over the long term. So from that perspective, whether public infrastructure investment takes the form of government bonds or of special bonds, I do not know, but as long as it does not go beyond the bounds of the current fund portfolio, I can say it would at least not undermine the stability of fund management. So emphasizing public infrastructure investment and the like over and over may itself, given how the fund is actually managed today, not be an issue worth highlighting that much. However, because this is an investment by the current generation in future generations, or, from the standpoint of future generations, has the character of a deferred debt, there may be social controversy over why investment that should be made through general tax revenue, through the general account budget, is deferred into an investment with the character of national debt passed on to future generations; so I can say this is something that should proceed through social consensus.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
You seem to have taken us nearly all the way to the conclusion. If you were to sum up your position in a word, Attorney Lee Chan-jin, are you for it or against it?

□ Lee Chan-jin
From the standpoint of the fund management body, the executing organization, we see no particular problem with regard to domestic bond management.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
No problem, then.

□ Lee Chan-jin
Yes, I think there would be none.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Lee Jun-haeng.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes, the point here, to help ordinary listeners understand, is that if managing the fund and investing in the public sector can actually be kept separate, then there is no reason for this to be controversial. What I mean is that in the past, when there were plans to make public investments, I opposed them very strongly. The reason was that the returns were actually poor, and if the National Pension’s money were invested on instruction and losses occurred, the National Pension Fund would bear the loss for projects the budget should fund; the National Pension is not something the entire population has joined, as there are both the insured and the uninsured. So I said it made no sense to take the National Pension’s money like a piggy bank and order it invested like this. But the method of taking up bonds is, in fact, something I myself had proposed. I said it would be good, if possible, to create something like a new non-marketable bond for this. This should be done through the budget, but funding is difficult and National Assembly consent is required, so there could also be the method of issuing special bonds and having the fund take them up; but then the question is whether only the National Pension would participate and buy them, and if they were simply issued in the general market, they would circulate and have various effects on the capital market. In the sense of separating them somewhat from all that, there are cases abroad, including American pensions, of investing by purchasing non-marketable bonds.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
In simple terms, what is a non-marketable bond?

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes, it works like this. When a bond is issued normally in the market and many people want to buy it, the bond price rises. That is what determines the interest rate. Separately from that, a bond is created specifically and taken up at a set interest rate, after the market rate has been determined; “non-marketable” means it cannot be traded in the market. It is simply held, whereas other bonds, such as government bonds, are bought and sold in the market even after the National Pension buys them, so their prices keep fluctuating. So they are marked to market, and in the annual performance evaluation of the National Pension, an investment in government bonds does not rise steadily with interest the way ordinary people’s savings do. When interest rates rise, it can even lose value, but if the bond is non-marketable, returns can proceed consistently at book value, which helps reduce volatility for the National Pension and for the fund. So I actually proposed that this be considered. Whatever form it takes, the National Pension’s usual share in the government bonds it would have invested in anyway is quite large. So if issuing bonds and having the fund take them up stays within that share, and within a range that does not restrict its ability to trade freely, I think doing this is not itself a problem; so if it is done this way, I think this part is actually not a matter for dispute.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, let us first hear all four of you. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, what do you think of the plan to use the National Pension for public investment?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, since that part was explained well already, I will skip it. Let me talk about why this idea came up. Why do you think low fertility and aging have become so severe? In surveys, housing comes up as the reason about 50% of the time. That is, people cannot marry because of housing. There are young people and others in that position. Yet Korea’s stock of rental housing is around 6%. The OECD average is about 10%. So Korea’s current rental housing stock is about 1 million units of the total housing stock, and another 1 million or so units must be built and supplied as rental housing to reach the OECD average. That comes to roughly 90 trillion won. Only with cheap housing can housing be stabilized, and only then can low fertility and aging be addressed. Another point is that public infrastructure such as childcare facilities, daycare centers, and long-term care hospitals falls far short of that in advanced countries. So the National Pension public investment came about not to strengthen the public sector excessively but to raise it to about the OECD average. It came about to address low fertility and aging, then to solve problems such as hospitals for our older people in their old age, and then childcare facilities. The misunderstanding arose because people think public investment by the National Pension means the National Pension will directly build houses and do everything itself. Then it runs deficits, and so people say, “Is this not just squandering my money?” But as the professor and the others said earlier, the National Pension does not make public investments directly; it buys bonds, and bonds guarantee stable interest and repayment of principal. So, as I said earlier, it poses no problem at all in terms of the National Pension Fund’s portfolio. In the end, as Professor Lee Jun-haeng said earlier, government bonds or special bonds are issued, so the projects are carried out with government fiscal resources; it is a question of the profitability of government finances, and I can say there is no instability whatsoever for the National Pension Fund.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Dr. Yun Suk-myung, the government’s policy seems to be roughly this. About 2 trillion won of the National Pension — there are currently 17 metropolitan and provincial governments — would be invested indirectly in Social Service Corporations set up in each of them, is that right?

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, that is my understanding, but whether this has been finalized — I also know it was discussed that way in the State Affairs Planning Advisory Committee, but I do not know whether it has been 100% finalized. To add some explanation: as recently as the general election last year, they said they would invest about 10 trillion won in the public sector every year, but what is being discussed now, though I do not know whether it is final, has been reduced greatly, to about 2 trillion won. It has been cut to about one-fifth, and in that respect I think much of the concern has eased. As you said, the Moon Jae-in administration in particular seems to regard the Social Service Corporations as very important. Since Korea has become a low-fertility, aging society, there is a shortage of facilities essential for caring for children and older people, and the state has to provide such facilities anyway; the idea seems to be that if an entity called the Social Service Corporation takes charge of them, the work can be done more effectively, so they would be set up as hubs nationwide and these resources, these funds, allocated to them. I agree with that basic intent itself. But what I am most concerned about, unlike the other three panelists, is this. Of course, if the fund buys government and public bonds indirectly, there is no immediate burden on the National Pension itself. But I think we also need to consider why, despite these projects being so necessary, investment in them has not been made at the national or societal level until now. Looking at the figures, as of 2014 the return on welfare project investment was –1.68%. For the five years through 2014, welfare project investment recorded negative returns on the National Pension side. What that suggests is that this is not an area that generates returns. So what someone like me worries about is this. There is a need to expand public sector investment. If it is invested at an appropriate level, at key hubs, to a significant and symbolic degree, that is fine; but if, once the floodgates have been opened, it keeps expanding as administrations change, then although the National Pension is said to be guaranteed its returns for now, as I said, the losses have to be covered from the national treasury one way or another. That ultimately comes back as a burden on the public, so we need to look at this comprehensively. For now, it is said that the National Pension need not suffer losses because the state guarantees payment and guarantees a certain level of returns, but the reality of the National Pension is that over the long term, although it has about 600 trillion won now, it enters a very difficult phase by 2040. From that perspective, if we invest this way for 10 or 20 years and later, at the recovery stage, there is no appropriate way to recover the funds, there could also be problems at the national level, so I think we need to approach this more carefully.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Attorney Lee Chan-jin, what is your position on Dr. Yun Suk-myung’s view?

□ Lee Chan-jin
First, there is a point that could cause a misunderstanding, and I need to point it out. The figure of minus one-point-something percent for the return on the National Pension’s welfare projects refers to a hotel called Cheongpung Resort that the National Pension runs directly. It is in Jecheon. Losses arise there, an annual loss rate of one-point-something percent, and that loss comes from a hotel in which about 30 billion won has been invested. The size of our pension fund as a whole is said to be 600 trillion won; as of the end of April it was about 587 trillion won. Against that, this is a portion of less than 0.01%. In fact, to say that we are running welfare projects at all hardly even rises to the level of wordplay. So saying that this is being done because of welfare projects may not be an appropriate description at all under the present reality of fund management. However, the point Dr. Yun Suk-myung made can be understood as a concern of this kind: if the government floats bonds through the fund and the like to carry out projects of a public-works character, projects that could be done from the general-account budget, it has the effect of each keeping a separate purse, and so does it not open the floodgates to irresponsibly spending beyond the fiscal resources available to the current generation?

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Dr. Yun Suk-myung, it seems you have a rebuttal.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, I would like to say a few words. I understand the point Attorney Lee Chan-jin made. Cheongpung Resort was, in a place quite far from Seoul,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, it is in Jecheon.

□ Yun Suk-myung
built there, so accessibility is inevitably poor, and as a result its profitability is somewhat low. I agree on many points, and I am not unconditionally opposing a project that the current administration has launched so ambitiously. There are parts where I sympathize with the need, but there is one thing I think I need to explain. As recently as 2009, we were already running similar projects among the welfare projects: childcare facility loans, elderly welfare loans, and livelihood stabilization funds. Looking at these projects, they have been shrinking continuously. For example, as of the end of December 2009, childcare facility loans stood at 55.6 billion won and elderly welfare loans at about 8.5 billion won, but as of 2016 they are all gone. So what I want to say is that the problem is not just Cheongpung Resort; projects such as childcare facilities and elderly welfare facilities do not generate much profit. Even so, I am not opposed to investing the National Pension Fund to some degree in childcare facilities or elderly care facilities as such. But this is the plain reality, and if we approach it on the basis that, right after we invest, the government will guarantee the difference in returns, and that the National Pension therefore has no chance of losing money, the Moon Jae-in administration may approach it very carefully and do it well through hub regions, but if the next administration, and the one after that, run it somewhat loosely because the floodgates have been opened once, there could be a situation that is hard to recover from. So I am not unconditionally opposed; it is that this actually shows up in the data, so I think we need to consider it more carefully. That is my position.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon. Yes, Attorney Lee Chan-jin, what would you like to say,

□ Lee Chan-jin
On that point, the past data on welfare projects you just mentioned probably runs up to 2006. Such projects do not exist now. So,

□ Yun Suk-myung
Through 2014.

□ Lee Chan-jin
The part directly related to childcare was something done back in the 1990s, a project that lent directly to private childcare facilities. There were issues with managing those loans, and because the loans could not be recovered, losses occurred and that caused a great deal of trouble; that is something that happened in the past. After that, some support projects related to elderly livelihood stabilization and care facilities were carried out, but those are almost finished, and the elderly livelihood stabilization support project is now at an extremely marginal level, probably in the range of a few tens of billions of won. We have been monitoring it until recently, too. Those were direct projects, and the current public infrastructure project is not from the perspective of such welfare projects at all; it is not a direct project but, as I said earlier, takes the form of buying bonds, a financial product,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Right. If special bonds are issued, the National Pension buys them, and

□ Lee Chan-jin
I want to say that it is not a welfare project of the kind the National Pension carries out while bearing direct responsibility.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, you said earlier, did you not, that for this to work properly in the long run the economically active population must keep being produced, so the idea is to use it for that purpose? From that standpoint, what do you think of the two views just presented?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes. First, it seems that no one strongly opposes the bond approach. However, this is a project into which the state puts fiscal money anyway, right? The point being made is that if the profitability of that fiscal spending falls, it is the public’s taxes anyway. So, in fact, over the past few months we researched a great deal. What we researched is this: in the past, investment went only into welfare facilities, right? But in this public investment, the share invested in rental housing is actually about 90%. Then the remaining roughly 10% or so is invested in long-term care hospitals, childcare facilities, and the like. So when people hear about investing in rental housing, the public widely perceives it as a deficit operation, and in the case of permanent rental or national rental housing, that is, rentals of 30 years or more or permanent rentals, there is no sale anyway, no sale of the apartments or of the land, so they are very likely to run a deficit. But there are cases of conversion to sale. For example, with Bogeumjari Housing or rental housing, people live there as renters and then it is converted to sale after five years, or converted to sale after ten years, and in the case of the New Stay project, it is rented for eight years and then sold right after the eight years. Rental housing projects of this sale-conversion type are in fact profitable. They are shown to be in surplus. So after reviewing these points, since public investment by the National Pension has to match the life cycle, five or ten years is too short, right? So a standard is set for residence in sale-type rental housing with a maturity of about 20 or 30 years, and the conversion to sale takes place after 20 to 30 years. In that case, when we closely simulated past housing price growth rates and the like and analyzed the business feasibility economically, it was shown in actual past cases that, depending on the conditions, that is, the terms, the floor area ratio, and the location, sufficient profitability can emerge. And since profits also appeared in the simulations we ran, my hope is that people will not worry too much about profitability either.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Lee Jun-haeng.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes. Let me add just one word. With public projects of this kind, whatever form they take, if they are actually profitable, the private sector participates. In the end, the state saying it will do something like this means that, in whatever form, it will put in resources reflecting a reality that is somewhat difficult, and that is indeed what the state should do. So it may lose money. Then of course this should have been done through the budget, since it would be enough to collect taxes to the same effect. But here is the thing: if this is done by collecting taxes, oversight and the like are very thorough, so the efficiency of the project—that is, it is hard to run it loosely. But if it is done this way, then depending on the case, something like what happens at loosely managed public enterprises could occur. That concern can exist.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
There is that concern. Attorney Lee Chan-jin, what do you think about that concern?

□ Lee Chan-jin
Yes, on that point, when the scope of the budget or of the investment assets is set, a mechanism is clearly needed that institutionalizes and gives real substance to a system of ex post supervision and management and the like. On that point, apart from the dimension of fund management, whichever department of the executive branch, of the government, may be in charge, it is right that responsibility for it must be made clear.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. We need to think a bit about returns. Yes, Professor Jeong Sung-hoon.

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, in general, when private construction companies get involved in rental housing projects, here is what happens: rents are high. The reason is that they have no choice but to do so in order to take a large margin. Then one can ask in return how rents can be lowered while still making a profit, right? The answer is that when the public sector, a public enterprise, carries it out, rents can be lowered while breaking even. There is no need to take a large margin. It is a public enterprise established for the public interest, after all. In that respect, it is a matter in which profitability can be secured while rents are kept lower than when private construction companies build rental housing.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Today on KBS <Empathy Debate>, we are debating how to view public investment by the National Pension. With us are Dr. Yun Suk-myung of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, Professor Lee Jun-haeng of Seoul Women’s University, Professor Jeong Sung-hoon of Daegu Catholic University, and Attorney Lee Chan-jin.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Let me introduce some text messages our listeners have sent, and then we will continue the debate.
This is from the listener with the number ending in 2563: “I think what matters is using it only for its original purpose. Once a principle begins to collapse, no one will invest for the future. I hope you realize that the public is already anxious that, because of fund depletion, it will be changed toward paying more and receiving less.”
From the listener with the number ending in 5545: “There are not enough jobs for young people. Beyond welfare, National Pension investment should also go boldly into future growth engines. If it invests in young talent while also creating good jobs, the money will come back as tax revenue and jobs will increase. Of course, I do think it would be good if the principal were preserved.”
From the listener with the number ending in 3387: “Absolutely not. It may be because I am young that I see no need to take on needless risk. Above all, it seems many people currently think of the nation’s money as money no one is watching. With the moral damage from the earlier Samsung takeover affair still unresolved, this discussion seems inappropriate. It seems like a debate that should come after the National Pension Service has been reformed.”
From the listener with the number ending in 4196: “As for how the fund is managed, experts can set principles that do not depart from common sense, and the most important thing is that, as long as internal management is transparent enough that no one talks about the ‘iron rice bowl’ of public enterprises, I think investing in social overhead capital is fine.”
Let me introduce one more. From the listener with the number ending in 3991: “Above all, it seems most important that the National Pension, which is invested with the public’s precious money, be invested as safely as possible. Rather than investing in high-risk stocks or projects with an uncertain future, it would be better to invest with a large share in domestic and foreign bonds, even if the returns are somewhat lower.”
Yes, thank you to all the listeners who sent us messages.
Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, looking through the messages our listeners have sent, it seems that, fundamentally, there is an underlying sense of anxiety. That is, there seems to be a lot of worry about what will happen if the National Pension is used in some way now and something goes wrong, and there also seems to be distrust of the government and of the departments that manage the National Pension. I think that only if we lay out the controversy over public investment by the National Pension that we are now debating accurately for the public can the public’s distrust be eased somewhat. What do you think about the way the public sees this?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Well, there have been some incidents and accidents involving the National Pension, right? I think that because distrust about those runs underneath, the public holds that perception. As I see it, there is nothing like that in the asset allocation of the National Pension’s Fund Management Headquarters itself. I do not see anything like that. Another thing is that, because talk of the National Pension investing in bonds and so on is financial terminology, it may be somewhat hard for the public to grasp, so the very fact that this has become an issue is somewhat burdensome, and people think, “Is this not risky?” But in fact, anyone who knows the financial structure can quickly see that there is no risk in it.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Dr. Yun Suk-myung.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, as I said at the outset, I think a more careful approach is needed. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon said earlier that in the case of rental housing, when private operators carry out the project, rents are high, so it does not really play its role as rental housing well, and that it would therefore be good if the National Pension stepped in and did it well. I agree on that need. But one of the things we must regard as very important here is this: I agree 100% with investing in SOC or key industries to secure our society’s competitiveness. But if you look at what has been done in our country so far, many regional airports have turned into ghost airports. Also, many private investment projects were said to be profitable, but in the end they are riddled with deficits, so government fiscal money is being put into them. So the important point I want to make here is this: when the feasibility of a project is analyzed, at that point everyone assesses that the project will generate enough profit. I do not know how that was done. But looking back after five years, after ten years, many of them have turned into huge tax-eating hippos. Our society has already experienced a great deal of that. Another thing I worry about is this: I too agree in principle with investing in such important public sectors in a highly symbolic sense, but once the floodgates are opened, the political sphere, which already likes very much to push particular projects in the regions at every election, with lawmakers from each region and so on saying that there is a lot of business potential in their area, so why can there not be public investment there, could expand it more than necessary. So, judging from what our society has experienced so far, it does not seem possible to guarantee that this will not happen as public investment is expanded. From that perspective, I keep repeating that a careful approach is needed. Let me add one more thing. The National Pension now has 580 trillion won, which will be about 600 trillion won as of the end of June, and that seems like a great deal of money, but in reality there is an amount we need on top of it to match. To that end, the work starts this year and the fourth financial projection has to be done next year; the National Pension’s fiscal condition has to be assessed and its long-term fiscal condition checked, and as I see it, contributions have not been raised for ten years. A financial projection result will probably come out saying contributions should be raised or something like that, and if the government later, next year or the year after, says out of necessity that contributions must be raised to achieve fiscal stabilization of the National Pension, people may quite often say, “You mismanaged the National Pension Fund and are ultimately shifting the burden onto the insured, are you not?” That is not the case. So I think it would be good for us to approach this together while thoroughly reviewing the feasibility of the project, taking comprehensive account of that as well, including the insured’s distrust of the National Pension.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Let us hear views once more on the messages our listeners sent. Professor Lee Jun-haeng, what do you think?

□ Lee Jun-haeng
It seems the listeners who sent messages share the same concern. That is, there were several messages saying that they sympathize with investing in such areas as such, but that if it goes wrong, the harm must not fall on the National Pension. In fact, regarding issuing bonds and having them taken up, the burden of the money the National Pension Fund puts up separately is relatively very small; I think we can reassure people on this point. But the efficiency of the public projects themselves cannot be guaranteed.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Attorney Lee Chan-jin.

□ Lee Chan-jin
Yes, I also agree with what Professor Lee Jun-haeng said. Investments of this kind have empirical precedents, having already been made by Japan’s Pension Welfare Service Public Corporation and in Sweden, Singapore, and elsewhere. Their investment effects have also already been verified. In particular, from the standpoint of us in civil society, it is commonly said that, in public pensions such as the National Pension, the most important investment, such as youth rental housing, is investment in the population. What that means is that, rather than raising the contributions of the current generation, keeping the present level of the economically active population sustained, or growing it beyond that, is commonly said to be the investment with the best guaranteed return, and we have reached a demographic cliff. In a reality where the economically active population is already shrinking, the demographic cliff will proceed at a very steep pace. Then it seems clear that, in terms of the fiscal stability of the pension system, things are heading toward a very precarious situation. So whether population investment is effective is a matter on which a great deal of discussion and agreement can take place, but if there are things that can give hope to the young generation, to this generation that has entered the economically active population, things that are hard to achieve with the current general-account budget, and if intensive investment over a short period can have an effect, that is, if there is something that can give hope to their dreams and lives, and if it is an investment in which the safety of our fund is guaranteed, then I think it is an investment of a kind on which our society can agree to a certain extent.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Let us debate returns a little more and then think about how the National Pension Fund should best be used. First, the problem of rising national debt is probably the biggest concern. Also, it is said that the money will be invested in places such as rental housing and elderly care facilities, but there is a concern that these may already be oversupplied and that, in that sense, they may not generate returns. And another thing is that it is said this is being done to raise the fertility rate, but there are also voices of concern asking how effective doing this can be in raising the fertility rate. Let us hear your opinion on this. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon.

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes. A lot has been said earlier, but if I were a listener, the first thing I would wonder about, and I think this would be the issue, is why this kind of investment has to be made with the National Pension of all things. So I think I should explain that part before moving on,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Please do.

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes. More than 60 trillion won in new money flows into the National Pension every year. Fund depletion of the National Pension is projected for around 2060, which is 42 years from now. Until 2040, it will grow exponentially.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Given the current population distribution, you mean?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes. That is why that much new money flows into the National Pension, and of that, the National Pension has to put more than about 10 trillion won a year into bond investment, that is, into government bonds, regardless of public investment. Because there is no other institution that invests such an enormous amount of money in government bonds, the idea is to carry out public investment with the National Pension Fund; if it were done elsewhere, the money of various institutions would have to be pooled, which is inconvenient. The maturities all differ, too. In that respect, public investment by the National Pension has now come up. Another point is the fiscal problem you mentioned earlier. The expectation is that, although the safety of the National Pension Fund is guaranteed, this is done with state finances anyway, so will national debt not increase as a result? But by the OECD standard, Korea’s national debt is in the 40% range. And I understand the OECD average for national debt is about 70%. The OECD average, that is. So Korea’s national debt is now considerably low compared with the OECD.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
It is on the low side, then.

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Even so, if government bonds are issued to carry out these public investment projects, national debt becomes unavoidable. So if such an increase in national debt is a burden, there are public corporation bonds issued by public enterprises; public corporation bonds are included in national debt in the broad sense, but by the OECD standard they are not included in national debt. So if bond issuance is expanded somewhat and the projects are carried out by issuing public corporation bonds, national debt will not increase. Of course, if increasing the debt of public enterprises leaves a hole, that ends up being covered by the public’s taxes. That is why, as Dr. Yun also said earlier, there must be supervision and oversight so that public investment is executed efficiently, while the business viability and profitability of things like rental housing, childcare facilities, and long-term care facilities are examined thoroughly and closely.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Then, of the points I raised earlier, let us set aside for separate discussion the investment returns of welfare projects and whether this would really be effective in raising the fertility rate. Let us first sort out just the concern about national debt. Dr. Yun Suk-myung, what is your position on the concern that national debt may increase?

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. First, regarding the point that our national debt is about 40% of GDP, I would like to speak somewhat more pessimistically than that,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
It is higher.

□ Yun Suk-myung
because, for example, what accounts for half of our national debt is what goes into guaranteeing the payment of the Government Employees Pension and the Military Pension: of the total national debt, the 40% of GDP mentioned earlier, about 20% of GDP is the Government Employees Pension and the Military Pension. That is how large that part of the national debt is now.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
In other words, one half of the 40%.

□ Yun Suk-myung
One half. And the reason I mention this is that the National Pension now has something similar, called “implicit pension debt”: it is not visible to the eye, but if you compare it to an iceberg, there is the part that has risen above the surface, and there is money the government additionally needs in order to guarantee payment. If the money we have, the National Pension Fund, is about 570 or 580 trillion won, then … about 500 trillion won more is needed. We should be collecting that, but we are not collecting it now. Yet we do not currently count it as national debt. Why do we not count it? Because the state has not inserted a payment guarantee provision, it is not counted as national debt. But what I want to say is this: unless our country goes under, is it really not going to pay National Pension benefits? So although, for various reasons such as national credibility, it cannot be counted as national debt, people like me take the view that in a substantive sense it should be national debt. Also, as I said earlier, I understand that what public institutions, that is, government agencies and the public sector, carry is not counted as formal national debt either. So I would like to say that the national debt of 40% of GDP we are talking about is considerably understated compared with the debt we actually have. Along with this, what we must view as important is this: when things are good, everything is good, but when they turn bad—just as when people grow old all their organs deteriorate at once—by the time the National Pension’s financial condition worsens, our society will be entering a full-fledged super-aged society, and conditions for things like raising revenue will not be good. What I am concerned about is this: I sympathize with the intent, but in what is called the new normal era, societies with far worse socioeconomic conditions than now are coming 20 or 30 years from now. The present has far better socioeconomic conditions than that time, and if already now we cannot expand these facilities by collecting taxes and instead carry out these projects in a way that increases national debt, might this not turn out to be not so positive later on? So while I sympathize with the intent, I would like to say that we need to approach this aspect comprehensively as well.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Let us hear views on national debt. Professor Lee Jun-haeng.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes. In fact, the original wish to have the National Pension do some of this investment was because, if it were really done that way, it would pose no problem at all in terms of national debt, so that approach would have been the easiest. But since there were many objections to that, the idea now is to try this approach instead. This poses no problem from the National Pension’s standpoint, but, as was just said, it ultimately takes a form that increases national debt, and even if it is done through public corporation bonds—though I do not think issuing them will be easy either—in the end it is all national debt. So carrying out such projects would be no problem if they were truly profitable, but it is precisely because profitability is hard to guarantee that the government intervenes, and I think it is right that this be done with government budget funds. Then, once government budget funds are involved, it becomes a question of how to allocate resources, which becomes a key issue for decision-making; if this area is truly important, one should work to allocate more resources to it, persuade the public, and win it from the legislature. But if instead one tries to carry out such projects with earmarked money, then—this is the same discussion we have been having all along—I have the concern that there is room for misplaced inefficiency to creep in.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Let us hear the views of Attorney Lee Chan-jin.

□ Lee Chan-jin
The pension liability is something that remains a constant anyway. So what we should actually be talking about with regard to national debt is this. When the government or the public sector carries out public infrastructure projects like these, the current generation, the economically active population that benefits, and the retired generation all gain from their welfare effects. With the rental housing project for young people, the effect shows up in their living costs: statistics show that rent now takes up nearly 30% of young people’s income. So this greatly reduces that cost. Then their disposable income can increase, and their capacity to bear taxes increases. Their tax-bearing capacity increases, and as a result their capacity to pay pension contributions increases. So, in a sense, this is also an investment that can set off a virtuous circle: it first makes one turn, increases overall capacity to bear burdens—increases society’s overall capacity—and then circles back virtuously to make the state’s finances richer. So I would say that the national debt debate on this should not be viewed simply and one-dimensionally, but should take into account even how the welfare effects flow back through the national economy as a whole.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. We have looked at the national debt issue. As for the investment returns of welfare projects such as rental housing and long-term care facilities for older people, there are forecasts that these are already in a state of oversupply and so will not produce proper returns. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, how do you see it?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Right now we are working hard on profitability analysis and have run many simulations of our own. So among such welfare facilities there will of course be some that are not profitable. But those things actually depend on conditions. That is, it differs depending on under what conditions and how they are supplied. For example, on something like vacant land, if the floor area ratio is kept to about 200% or below, it will not be profitable. Then, in a good location, if the floor area ratio is raised somewhat, it becomes profitable. This is adjusting the conditions, and we keep running simulations of that kind. We run optimizing simulations so that losses here are offset by gains there, making it profitable when viewed in total. That is the concern Dr. Yun raised earlier and the concern Professor Lee Jun-haeng raised, and we need an approach of investing after thoroughly analyzing those aspects and examining them closely. Next, is there not a great deal of wasted spending in our national budget of 400 trillion won? By cutting that—what is called expenditure restructuring—through expenditure restructuring we can also secure a certain amount of funds to invest here, so I hope there will be no misunderstanding that national debt will rise sharply or anything like that.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Dr. Yun Suk-myung.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. What I want to make clear is that I am not wholly rejecting or criticizing this project itself,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, you have said so several times.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, let me say that there are parts of the intent I sympathize with. Even so, there are again parts where I want to voice concern, and this time I also want to mention positive aspects. Earlier, Attorney Lee Chan-jin said that in cases like Japan and Sweden public investment had many positive effects, but many experts in this field also take a highly critical view that what Japan and Sweden did in this area was not necessarily all positive. In Japan’s case, from the 1970s, under the Greenpia project, a great deal of pension fund money was invested with the aim of developing the entire Japanese archipelago, and a considerable part of it suffered very heavy losses as profitability declined and the real estate bubble burst. In Sweden’s case, there is the positive side that a lot of rental housing and the like was built. There clearly were problems in those cases, but among the important points I want to make now is this: in the case of childcare facilities, the supply from private and public providers already exceeds 100%. So people ask whether there is not already an oversupply, but the problem is that working mothers, so-called “working moms,” have no childcare facilities they can trust with their children. There are more than enough facilities, but there is no standardized childcare facility that lets parents work with peace of mind. From that perspective, if good facilities—childcare facilities people can trust—are created through this kind of public investment, that could be positive; and long-term care facilities, too, are very numerous, but, with apologies, because the private providers put profitability first, from the families’ point of view the long-term care facilities are not very satisfactory. If, through investment in the public sector, facilities emerge that can provide standardized services, so that families truly feel “we can care for our parents comfortably here,” that could be very positive. Earlier I said Japan lost a lot on the Greenpia project, but one positive point of Japan’s public investment is that it raised the share of national and public hospitals to about 30%. Ours is now under 10%. As a result, when the government runs health and medical programs, it is very much dragged along one-sidedly by the providers, that is, the medical care providers. If we do this effectively and secure enough facilities that the state can exercise some control, that clearly could be positive. Even so, I want to say once again that these matters need to be approached very, very carefully.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Shall we hear from Attorney Lee Chan-jin and then Professor Lee Jun-haeng?

□ Lee Chan-jin
I partly agree with what Dr. Yun just said. However, in Japan’s case the Greenpia project was a comprehensive resort project. And what was benchmarked on it here was the Cheongpung Resort project, so those are projects that all went bust anyway. As for the assessment that the housing, hospitals, welfare facilities, and similar projects invested in by Japan’s national pension were successful, I think Dr. Yun probably agrees.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Lee Jun-haeng.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes. I think that claiming the profitability of public-sector investment will turn out well, or measuring it, is a very difficult thing. Basically, of course, I think raising the fertility rate and the like is naturally the top task. Then the government must invest resources in it. In reality, whether it is worth arguing over profitability—no one knows how that will turn out for each project, on that point. I think what matters is that the government somehow be able to do such things, and that it persuade the public so that resources can be put into that. And if, depending on the case, one approaches it from a methodological angle, then by creating something that acts as kindling and providing the groundwork that lets the private sector expand on it and do something, that is, by approaching it with the concept of guarantees, the effect can be greatly magnified through what we commonly call leverage. That too could be one method. So in any case this is necessary, and on the question of what method to use, I do not think arguing further over profitability will gain us much.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, I see. Let us leave it there. And as for the debate on whether doing this would really help raise the fertility rate, it might become a debate for debate’s sake, so we will simply leave that part there. You are with KBS <Empathy Debate>.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
We continue with KBS <Empathy Debate>. In the first part we had an intensive debate on whether public investment by the National Pension is worth doing. From now on, I would like us to think about how the National Pension Fund should best be managed. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, I am sorry to keep asking you for explanations; you explained a little at the beginning how the National Pension Fund is currently being managed, but could you also tell us about asset allocation and the future fund management plan?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, I spoke earlier about asset allocation—about the current one. The system is not fixed in place; the asset allocation strategy keeps changing with economic conditions and financial market conditions. Explaining that would mean giving a university lecture, so let me just say that the Fund Management Headquarters carefully calculates the asset allocation every year in that way. Also, childcare facilities were mentioned earlier; the truth is that daycare centers are now in oversupply. Because there are many private daycare centers, the idea is not to build more public childcare facilities on top of them; there is also the idea of having the public sector purchase private daycare centers and convert them into public ones. I could not say earlier that this does not mean just building childcare facilities indiscriminately, so I am saying it now. So, to come back to fiscal stability, in line with that asset allocation strategy,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Earlier, was Professor Jeong Sung-hoon the only one I did not give a chance to speak?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
I did not raise my hand for an additional comment earlier. So it is managed in that way, and in fact the depletion date varies with the rate of return. It also varies with the amount of pension contributions paid in; since it is fluid, I cannot speak definitively about fiscal stability, but roughly, there is the projection of depletion in 2060. It peaks in 2040, peaking at roughly 2,500 trillion won. That is how it is currently planned. So recently there has also been a proposal to raise the contribution rate, and I think that too should be decided according to how the fund is managed going forward.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Management going forward is very important, because there are now various negative factors: for example, because of low fertility the number of contributors will start to fall, life expectancy will rise so the period of drawing pensions will lengthen, and as the population ages and economic growth slows, the fund’s rate of return will also fall. Because of all this, the management system needs to be built better and the fund managed better. I would like us to start by first examining how you assess the current state of the National Pension as it is managed now, and where, if anywhere, you see problems. Professor Lee Jun-haeng, how do you see it?

□ Lee Jun-haeng
On National Pension fund management. Distrust among the public is considerable—is there not a great deal of distrust in the pension itself right now? What people are most concerned about is “what if I do not get it later?” Now, regarding management, if the rate of return could be raised, that would of course help a great deal, but whenever fund management is discussed, people talk a great deal about stability. Yet this stability depends on what the actual size of the funds is. What I mean is that until 2060 in any case—until 2040, it grows very rapidly. When money keeps growing at such a tremendous pace for more than 20 years, is managing it conservatively really the right answer? People talk far too much about stability. Now, I am not saying we should put it riskily into stocks or anything; but an example I often use when lecturing is this: suppose you must pay out 5% every year. To pay that, putting it in a bank deposit is safe. But there is no way that can pay 5%, is there? Then is putting it in a bank to get 5% safe? That is actually very unsafe, is it not? So you try to invest where you can earn enough to pay the 5%, and inevitably such returns can come only from investing in risky assets. Then investing in risky assets is very unsettling, so how do you invest? You do it because, viewed over the long term, additional returns commensurate with that much risk turn out to come in. That is why, until 2040—actually until 2060, but in any case until 2040—this is money that grows enormously, and, putting it a bit crudely, one could even say it would be fine to go all in on stocks, 100%. Because over the long term, stocks do better. But when money must be paid out right away, you cannot do that. Because if you invested in such things and took a loss on stocks, you would have to pull the money out at a loss and pay it, and the loss would simply be final. But in theory, over the long term, that is how it works, which is why one allocates to risky assets. So investing in things that are too risky, or saying stability must be given great weight—risk and return do run counter to each other, but at least until 2060 one must choose an investment approach suited to this trend of continually growing funds, and later, when the money starts to shrink again, one must choose an approach suited to that. At that point stability naturally becomes very important, but for the time being, management that takes on somewhat more risk is needed. In fact, overseas pension funds invest in far more risky assets. That is what I would like to say.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
You are saying we should pay a bit more attention to returns. Attorney Lee Chan-jin.

□ Lee Chan-jin
Yes. When people talk about managing the fund, they usually say “this is how returns are made,” but those who study or are involved in pensions put it this way: they say the rate of return is determined by asset allocation. What that means is that however the Fund Management Headquarters or other experts manage it, the rate of return is determined by what share is assigned to particular asset classes. Why? Because a giant fund like the National Pension reaches the scale of the national economy, it is all but confirmed—confirmed in capitalist societies—that exceeding the statistical rate of return realized in the market, so-called “beating” it, is statistically impossible. So in the end one can generally say that the rate of return is effectively determined by the asset allocation: what percentage goes into stocks, usually called risky assets, how much into bonds, and how much is assigned to the class called alternative investments. So I partly agree with what Professor Lee Jun-haeng said about returns, and as for the current state of fund management, it used to be managed with a focus on bond investment, but as of the end of 2017, the share of bonds is set to be reduced to about 53%. Then stocks are allocated about 34.6%, with 19% domestic and fifteen-point-something percent overseas. These shares are on a rising trend. So, as for where these shares will be at some point, how do we, those involved in fund management, put it? We note that there is a time margin of about 20 years before the fund reaches its growth peak, that is, there clearly is time to invest aggressively; so I can say that considerable agreement is being reached on raising, to a certain extent, the share of profitable investments, that is, profitable asset classes. And from some year in the 2040s onward, when the pension matures and benefits begin to be paid in earnest, liquidity must be secured. Since several hundred trillion won a year, in current-value amounts, will be paid out in pension benefits, there must be assets that can be converted to cash, and in the end the most stable of these is bonds, so a certain share of bonds, especially domestic bonds, must be secured. While adjusting what level that share should be kept at—and yet, since the share of domestic bonds is quite high, suddenly cutting it could have a considerable impact on the national economy—these things are adjusted smoothly and continuously; this is called medium-term asset allocation, and it is reflected each year in the fund management plan, changing the shares little by little. So you can take it that such aspects are being reflected to some extent.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon.

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, so, as I said at the outset, if we go back 42 years—we are now talking about 2060 as the point of depletion, and that is 42 years from now. Well, in 1968 no one could have worried about 2010 and allocated assets on that basis. Because interest rates shoot up and come back down, asset allocation is made according to economic conditions, as I said earlier. When interest rates fall, you invest less in bonds, and when bond yields rise, you invest somewhat more in bonds; it works that way, so the contribution rate will also be set accordingly, in line with that.

□ Yun Suk-myung
If I may,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Dr. Yun Suk-myung.

□ Yun Suk-myung
On the matter of stability, there seems to be a great deal of controversy. I am speaking not only about stability but about the direction of National Pension Fund management itself. Regarding the basic idea that the fund must be managed stably, in recent years in particular—and this is in a similar vein to what Attorney Lee Chan-jin said earlier—many have argued that if the National Pension Fund earns 1 percentage point above the market return every year, fund depletion can be pushed back by more than 10 years. From my standpoint, that is very hard to agree with, because the National Pension Fund is an enormous aircraft carrier. Even when this aircraft carrier sees an obstacle ahead and changes course, it takes a considerable amount of time to turn. In that sense, the National Pension Fund must be managed stably, and even if the portfolio as a whole is built aggressively, once everything is added together it is hard for it to outperform the market return; that is why I say it should be approached with stability in mind. I think the right approach is to work toward a balance between contributions and benefits in the National Pension system rather than to rely on raising the fund’s investment return. But there is one thing I would like to say: up to the early 2040s, the fund will clearly be in its peak period of accumulation, so we do have some room. Yet there is an important point we must not overlook: because the history of our pension system is not very long, there is still a great deal of public distrust of the National Pension. Abroad there are funds that invest very aggressively. CalPERS, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System, invests very aggressively, so when the stock market is good its returns are very high. People compare against such times and criticize our National Pension’s returns as very low, but there is another lesson to take from it as a cautionary example: during the 2008 global financial crisis, CalPERS’s return plunged to around -30% in a single year. If something like that were to happen to our National Pension, contributors would probably fall into a near-panic. From that perspective, while investing aggressively to raise returns is important, and part of the portfolio should be built that way, I would like to say that overall we have no choice but to take a stable course.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Another thing to consider is that the government has been expanding the National Pension Fund’s overseas investment since 2009. I would like to hear what you think of the argument that the National Pension Fund should reduce its share of domestic equities somewhat and increase its investment in overseas equities. Professor Lee Jun-haeng.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
One of the biggest reasons the National Pension came to increase its overseas investment is what is called the whale in a pond, as I think many of you have heard. The National Pension is too big relative to the size of the capital market available for investment at home, even now. And it is going to double, then triple, and quickly at that. At that rate, as people commonly say, even if it only keeps its equity share where it is now, the National Pension will become the largest shareholder of every company in Korea. And in practice, depending on whether the National Pension buys or sells, stocks and bonds in the domestic capital market—and interest rates—swing up and down, so the first alternative for dealing with that is to increase investment overseas, but

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Right—let us send the whale out to the Pacific.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes, that is right. So that would be what you could call the first reason, and the next is to seek a diversification effect. If you invest in many countries abroad—domestic equities are very closely tied to domestic economic conditions, whereas with money placed abroad, even when the domestic economy is somewhat weak the overseas economy may be good—in this situation, overseas investment can only grow, and it is now being expanded considerably. But in that connection, a great many issues—problems, you might call them—are also being raised. People say that overseas investment is being expanded while paying a lot in expensive fees, and that is partly true, but if it actually earns more abroad than those fees, then paying them is fine. Since the returns all come out net, one can certainly debate whether it was done well or badly, but there is one more perspective: if the National Pension increased its internal staff, it would not have to pay as much in overseas fees—that is, if it kept the investment staff in-house. In fact, in a way, the people the National Pension employs are paid for from the government budget. So their cost is not deducted from the fund. The fees paid for overseas investment are deducted from the fund as a cost, but if in-house investment capacity were increased, there is some room to lower those fees considerably. That is a side issue, though; overseas investment therefore has no choice but to grow, but the problem is that whether it is right, in terms of national development and of resource allocation for the country as a whole, to invest domestic savings abroad on such a large scale will be another, separate issue, I think.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I suppose so. That would be another issue. There is overseas equity investment, and there is real estate too. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, what do you think about overseas investment?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes, I agree to some extent with everything Professor Lee Jun-haeng said, but let me make one point. For example, the claim that we turn our eyes abroad because there is no room for domestic investment sounds right at first. But we should first take a careful look at whether there really is no domestic investment to be made. The current administration speaks a great deal about income-led growth. Seen from that angle, we need to check whether there is domestic investment to be made first in venture companies or in small and medium-sized enterprises, which are struggling, or in unlisted companies—places that can create jobs and drive income-led growth—and whether, in line with today’s topic, rental housing to address low fertility and population aging, and welfare facilities for older people, were considered first. In other words, I am talking about order. First invest domestically in places that can increase incomes and boost domestic demand, and then, if there is money to spare, overseas investment will be unavoidable. I hope the National Pension Fund will examine such matters closely.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Dr. Yun Suk-myung.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, from my standpoint, as the National Pension Fund grows rapidly—earlier our host said to send the whale out to the Pacific,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Because you called it the whale in a pond.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, I agree with much of that. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon made his point, and that too seems to have merit. If the National Pension Fund now holds 570 trillion or 580 trillion won, a considerable part of it came in as investment returns, but a considerable part is also contributions paid by National Pension contributors. What many experts in fields such as social welfare have pointed out about National Pension Fund investment so far is this: because the fund invested mainly in large conglomerates to earn stable and also high returns, there has been no investment in venture companies or small and medium-sized enterprises at a time when income polarization is already serious, so there has also been criticism that the National Pension Fund is fueling polarization in share prices as well. So those considerations do need to be taken into account, but overseas investment will have to be an unavoidable choice. It has to be sent out to the Pacific, whether to the United States or elsewhere. What I would like to say is that the important thing is this: overseas investment has no choice but to grow, but we are now paying a great deal in management fees, called “brokerage fees,” and we need to give some thought to that as well. Also, alternative investment has not come up yet, but in my view one of the easy approaches is this: because the National Pension has a long recovery horizon, if we buy prime real estate in key cities around the world—for example, core real estate in New York, core real estate in London, core real estate in Shanghai, core real estate in Tokyo—that is market risk, so if prices there fall, it would mean the entire world economy is in bad shape. Taking a somewhat more forward-looking stance along those lines would be good, and another important point is ultimately public trust, the trust of contributors: to secure it, if we produce something like a report to the public that sets out the details of fund management more thoroughly than now, across National Pension Fund management as a whole, including overseas investment, I believe misunderstandings about this could be reduced considerably.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, that seems well worth listening to. Attorney Lee Chan-jin, what do you think about overseas investment?

□ Lee Chan-jin
Yes. The fund management framework used to have what is called a home bias, which is the ratio of the domestic share to the overseas investment share. In the past, assets were allocated on the basis of the domestic share being 1.8 times higher, and a few years ago this was lowered to 1.5. So for the year in which the current medium-term asset allocation ends—2021, I believe—the maximum target is set at 6:4. As for where the growth is concentrated, it is ultimately overseas equities and alternative investment that are growing a lot. Then, looking at what form we should take, the reality seems to be that many fundamental questions are being raised: is it really the best course for this money—which pension contributors set aside for the future by painfully cutting their disposable income—to be turned wholesale into financial products and invested overseas like this? So what those who manage the fund need to think about here is, in a way, the creative development of investment asset classes beyond today’s typical asset classes, ones that expand our future sources of growth and jobs; in other words, creating new markets is very important. So there is a need to concentrate capacity anew on such things. And another point: as I said earlier, since returns are in effect determined by asset allocation, entrustment fees for overseas mandates are in fact excessive. If they are the opportunity cost of first expanding overseas, they may have to be accepted, but I think we could proceed in a way that minimizes those transaction costs by building up the expertise and skill of the staff at the domestic body that carries out fund management.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Professor Lee Jun-haeng.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Let me make just two points on this. It is said that the fees paid for overseas investment go to specialist overseas asset managers because our expertise is somewhat lacking, but, as Attorney Lee Chan-jin just said, whether in equities or anything else, picking individual stocks contributes quite little to returns. So even in equities, what matters is which regions you choose across overseas equities as a whole; in other words, it is fine to invest so as simply to track overseas indexes. And the products called ETFs that have appeared recently have come out in large numbers in Korea too, including domestic equity ETFs. Abroad there are also a great many ETFs.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
What is an ETF?

□ Lee Jun-haeng
It bundles stocks together. For example, there is a stock price index for Korean shares, is there not? There used to be no product that let you buy the stock index, but now funds have been created that let you buy the index, and they are traded like stocks. So buying that share is the same as buying the stock market. Abroad, too, there are funds that track indexes, whether the S&P or the MSCI index, so you can buy those, and they are very cheap. Moreover, the capacity to manage such products exists among domestic staff. So in this respect—picking stocks is what we call active investment—if we reduce active investment and invest mainly in the indexes I mentioned, in things like ETFs, returns would fall relatively little while efficiency could still be raised considerably. That is the one point I wanted to make from this angle.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. We have been thinking about fund management. Finally, let us look at one more thing and then wrap up the debate: plans to reorganize the fund management system. As came up earlier, in connection with the Choi Soon-sil scandal of meddling in state affairs, there have been steady calls to change the National Pension’s fund management system. So proposals are being made to give the National Pension greater independence: to make the Fund Management Headquarters, now an organization under the National Pension Service, independent and set it up outright as a public corporation—turning the National Pension Fund Management Headquarters into a public corporation. What do you think about this? Would it allow far more independent and sound decision-making? Shall we hear your views? Briefly, please. Attorney Lee Chan-jin first.

□ Lee Chan-jin
Briefly, the existing discussion seems to have centered largely on turning the Fund Management Headquarters into a public corporation and the like. But from the standpoint of those of us actually involved in fund management, the current discussion of the fund’s independence is rather that the system should be overhauled across the board toward strengthening the expertise and independence of the top decision-making body, such as the Fund Management Committee—the decision-making body, so to speak. What this means is that, judging by more than 20 years of fund management experience, we have learned that returns were determined by how investment asset classes were defined and how weights were allocated to each asset class. If so, the issue in fund management is not expertise in managing individual stocks; a very important point in the current discussion is that a group of experts who decide strategic investment policy must be concentrated in this decision-making body. So if the new government moves forward with reorganizing fund management, I think what is needed is a reorganization in the direction of enhancing the independence and representativeness, together with the expertise, of the decision-making body centered on the Fund Management Committee, and of making that committee a standing body.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Sung-hoon, your view?

□ Jeong Sung-hoon
Yes. If yet another fund management corporation is set up under the National Pension, under the Service, then the current structure of the Ministry of Health and Welfare and the National Pension Service becomes the National Pension Service, then the fund management corporation, with the Ministry at the very top. In other words, it builds a house on top of a house, and we need to consider whether it is efficient to keep adding corporations this way, because in fact the problem is people. It is a matter of people, and the meddling in state affairs happened because of problems in the system and institutions; it is not as if setting up another corporation means there will be no more corruption. So if a fund management corporation is to be set up, I am not sure about a corporation as an executing agency, but if all of the authority held by the National Pension Service were handed over to it, what would the National Pension Service do then? Because of that, I see this as a problem of people, systems, and institutions, and, as Attorney Lee Chan-jin said earlier, I believe reform should come through systems and institutionalization—to the extent of strengthening the authority and independence of the Fund Management Committee, the decision-making body, and making it a standing body.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. The Fund Management Committee you just mentioned is the top decision-making body for the Fund Management Headquarters, is it not? But there has been some criticism that the committee is made up of people with no connection to finance. What do you think?

□ Lee Chan-jin
First, there is a misunderstanding here: the current Fund Management Committee does not function as the top decision-making body—structurally. In fact, under the law, the party actually responsible for fund management is the Minister of Health and Welfare. The committee decides on four items set out in the law, such as asset allocation and drawing up the fund management plan, and for the rest it deliberates and resolves on proposals referred to it by the Minister of Health and Welfare; that is about the extent of the structure. However, under the social consensus structure, the fund management guidelines provide for the Fund Management Committee to deliberate and resolve on such investment policies, and as a result there are the limits that come with being a social consensus body; it may make policy decisions actively in line with the Ministry of Health and Welfare’s policy stance, or it may be reduced to operating as an auxiliary body of the Ministry. So my view is that it should be made more independent and specialized, and that a standing body is needed that can monitor, control, and evaluate the executing body—the Fund Management Headquarters, or perhaps a corporation yet to be created.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. We are hearing views on making the Fund Management Headquarters independent. Professor Lee Jun-haeng.

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes. There is really a lot to say on this, but since we are short on time, I will,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Should we have started with this?

□ Lee Jun-haeng
Yes, to speak only to the important points: first of all, it needs full-time, standing status. Because I think having experts is important, but having people who carry representativeness is also important. So, as for that representativeness, rather than dismissing it outright by saying that people who know little about fund management are sitting there, we need to make those who come accountable. The problem is that because it is not a standing body, the minister sets meeting times at will, and when schedules do not fit, things fall through; and because members come only occasionally, their sense of responsibility—of course I am not saying they have none—falls off considerably. So when some odd remark comes up in the middle of a discussion, a lot of time is spent on something beside the point, and the important matters just get... because meeting time is fixed. But the most important thing is for it to become a standing body with accountability. Compensate the members there adequately, give them sufficient meeting time, and so on; so the most important thing is to give it independence and accountability, and once that happens, what it must do there, as I said earlier, is asset allocation, and it needs that capability. People talk a lot about whether our fund’s returns are good or bad compared with those abroad, but whose responsibility is that? The Fund Management Headquarters’ share of the responsibility is ultimately small. It does what it has been told. Then the question is who decided that, but since we are a bit short on time, I will,

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, I think we need to hear from Dr. Yun Suk-myung as well and then close.

□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. As Professor Jeong Sung-hoon said earlier, I think it is actually better not to go in the direction of managing the system and the fund separately. Even if a new corporation is created, it too would be an organization that would find it hard to escape political influence, so, to make the existing organization more effective and to enhance its independence, I think the Fund Management Headquarters now within the National Pension Service needs to be expanded or revitalized within the Service in a way that strengthens its independence. Next, the most important thing: Professor Lee Jun-haeng spoke earlier about making the Fund Management Committee a standing body, and, as the recent controversy over the National Pension Fund shows, since the whole nation takes part in the National Pension, representativeness itself seems very important. But when this committee meets, people from particular interest groups drag things out for a long time over issues that are not even important. That is what causes problems, but I believe securing representativeness is very important. Then how do we solve this? Whether the Fund Management Committee is made a standing body or whatever else is done, if under it we activate specialized committees for each field, made up of experts recommended by each interest group, and have them filter out almost all of the contentious issues, so that the Fund Management Committee meets regularly and votes on matters that have already been largely filtered, I think we could secure both expertise and representativeness at the same time.

□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, thank you. I appreciate your remarks. It is time to wrap up. Today on KBS <Empathy Debate>, we debated the controversy over public investment by the National Pension and considered the direction for efficient management of the National Pension Fund. However good the intent may be, if there are critical positions, is it not important to push ahead while building social consensus? That is the thought I am left with. My thanks to the four of you who joined the debate: Dr. Yun Suk-myung of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, Professor Lee Jun-haeng of Seoul Women’s University, Attorney Lee Chan-jin of People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy, and Professor Jeong Sung-hoon of Daegu Catholic University. Thank you for your hard work.

□ Panel
Thank you.

https://news.kbs.co.kr/news/mobile/view/view.do?ncd=3503374

Related Posts