Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Interview] Yun Suk-myung: “Private School Teachers Pension Reform Will Proceed Without Much Difficulty — Military Pension Reform Is Also Inevitable” (Posted November 10, 2015, 12:12 a.m.)

2026.11.16

* Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today, This Is Yoon Jae-seon>

[Key Remarks]

“The reason the ruling party is speeding up reform is the inconsistency between the Private School Teachers Pension Act and the Government Employees Pension Act”

“The Private School Teachers Pension fund will be gone by 2030”

“The ratio of the government’s contribution to the Private School Teachers Pension Service should be maintained”

“The amendment of the Private School Teachers Pension Act is likely to proceed without great difficulty”

“Military Pension reform must be considered to secure the Military Pension’s sustainability”




[Full Transcript]


Following the recent Government Employees Pension reform, the government and the ruling party plan to pass an amendment to the Private School Teachers Pension Act in the regular session of the National Assembly within this year.

Why is the ruling party speeding up the reform, and if the amendment passes the National Assembly, what changes will there be in private school teachers’ and staff’s contributions and pensions? We will take a detailed look with a pension expert,

Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.

▷ Hello, Committee Member Yun.

▶ Yes, hello.



▷ Thank you for joining us even though you are in Jeju.

▶ Thank you.



▷ Why is the ruling party speeding up the reform, even toying with the card of a budget-related bill, which can be passed without the agreement of the ruling and opposition parties?

▶ To put it briefly from two angles first, there is the aspect that the Private School Teachers Pension system will find it hard to remain sustainable as an old-age income security system.

There is the so-called financial instability.

The other is that the Government Employees Pension Act has already been amended, with the amendment passed after much controversy.

If things are left as they are, contradictions may arise between the Private School Teachers Pension Act, which largely follows the Government Employees Pension, and the legal framework for civil servants.

▷ In what way?

▶ It is complicated, but I will explain it anyway.

The Private School Teachers Pension system has a part that is governed by its own Private School Teachers Pension Act.

This is the contribution side, concerning how much one pays in contributions.

The other is the part that follows the Government Employees Pension, which in technical terms is called application mutatis mutandis.

That is the benefit side, concerning how much pension one receives. But when the Government Employees Pension was amended, it was done after much controversy, so many important provisions were put into the transitional provisions.

But even though the Private School Teachers Pension Act follows the Government Employees Pension Act, that is, applies it mutatis mutandis, it is set up to apply only the main text mutatis mutandis. It is not set up to apply the addenda mutatis mutandis, and this time a substantial portion of the important amendments to the Government Employees Pension Act were placed in the addenda.

So, to give a few examples that listeners can easily understand, the Government Employees Pension accrual rate is currently at 1.9%, and it is scheduled to fall gradually to 1.7% over 20 years.

This is in the addenda. If the Private School Teachers Pension Act is not amended, Private School Teachers Pension contributors will see it drop from 1.9% to 1.7% right away next year.

And another is the pension eligibility age, which is 60. This, too, was set in the addenda of the Government Employees Pension Act amendment to rise slowly to 65 by 2033, but without an amendment, for those retiring next year the pension eligibility age, the age at which one receives the pension, would jump by five years, from 60 this year to 65 next year. That could cause a great deal of confusion.

▷ In a word, the ruling party is in a position where it has no choice but to speed up the reform because of the inconsistency between the Private School Teachers Pension Act and the Government Employees Pension Act... You mentioned the problem of financial instability earlier, saying it is not sustainable, but some say the Private School Teachers Pension’s finances are better than the Government Employees Pension’s. Could you give us a comparative assessment?

▶ The Government Employees Pension requires a large deficit subsidy every year, whereas the Private School Teachers Pension has a reserve of about 15 trillion won.

As a result, people involved with the Private School Teachers Pension complain: we are on a different level from the Government Employees Pension; we have as much as 15 trillion won, so why do you keep comparing us on the same footing as the Government Employees Pension?

To put it bluntly, I would say it is a factor that creates an optical illusion.

The reason the Private School Teachers Pension holds a reserve while the Government Employees Pension does not is, first, that the system was introduced 15 years later.

So to view them on the same footing, one has to push the timeline back by 15 years, and looking at the finances under the current system as it is, an income-expenditure deficit of 700 billion won will arise from 2025. And in 2032 the money, the fund, will be completely gone...

▷ So you mean that although a reserve of 15 trillion won has been built up, that is what will happen by 2025 and 2032?

▶ Yes. And more importantly, after much controversy, the National Pension pushed back its fund depletion date to 2060, did it not?

If the Private School Teachers Pension is left as it is, the situation in 2060 is so serious that the deficit for a single year alone would equal the 15 trillion won reserve the Private School Teachers Pension now boasts of.

▷ So there are such estimates. It seems the direction of the amendment will also have to be paying more and receiving less. It would be easier to understand if you could explain with an example based on the content of the amendment the government and the ruling party are pushing. Could you give us the example of a teacher or staff member in their 10th year?

▶ Yes. In the case of a teacher or staff member in their 10th year, assuming they work another 20 years, they will pay 65,000 won more a month in contributions, and the pension they receive, where what matters is the initial pension amount, will be 2.05 million won, 280,000 won less than now.

▷ If it is changed that way, will the Private School Teachers Pension’s financial condition improve?

▶ Well, it does help the financial condition. A moment ago, did I not say that total expenditure will exceed total revenue from 2021 and that the fund will run out in 2032?

If it is changed this way, the point at which total expenditure exceeds revenue will be postponed by six years, to 2027, and the point at which the fund is depleted will be postponed by 10 years, to 2042.

But it is not a fundamental solution, because the number of school-age children is falling sharply due to low fertility, is it not?

▷ By 2030 the population will have shrunk completely, will it not? In practical terms...

▶ The Private School Teachers Pension faces an even more serious problem, because if school-age children decrease, the number of teachers hired will inevitably shrink as well, will it not?

By then the number of pension recipients will increase sharply while the number of new teachers and staff who will pay Private School Teachers Pension contributions will decrease, so in a sense the problem can be said to be far more serious than that of the Government Employees Pension.

▷ The opposition argues that the government should raise the government contribution it must pay to the Private School Teachers Pension Service. What do you think about this, Committee Member Yun?

▶ They have a point. Because private schools are in a difficult financial situation, are they not? Currently, of the 7% paid as the employer contribution, the government bears 41%.

If the Private School Teachers Pension Act is amended, the contribution rises by 2 percentage points, from 7% to 9%. Even if the current ratio is maintained, the government’s burden rises accordingly. As much as the contribution rises...

The government’s finances are tight, are they not? Taxes are not being collected well either, and private schools may have their difficulties, but on the whole it is not only private schools that are struggling; the whole country is struggling, is it not?
From that perspective, pension reform means responding preemptively to future difficulties, so I think everyone will have to tighten their belts. Given that the government’s contribution will rise even if the ratio is not raised, I think it is right to keep the current ratio itself as it is.

▷ The contribution rate is 7%...

▶ It is 7%, and there is the portion corresponding to 41% of that 7%, is there not?

▷ Which the government is paying...

▶ I think it is right for that ratio to stay as it is without major change. Because even if that ratio is maintained, the contribution in absolute terms rises by 2 percentage points, so every year after the reform the absolute amount the government will have to pay increases.

▷ You said, as you mentioned, that the Government Employees Pension reform was far from a fundamental reform... There is also doubt about whether the amendment of the Private School Teachers Pension Act can really be pushed through on the ruling party’s schedule. How do you see it?

▶ As I see it, there will be controversy, but it seems it can be pushed through without much difficulty.

The background to my thinking is that every time the Government Employees Pension was reformed in the past three rounds, the Private School Teachers Pension was reformed in the same way. That was, first of all, our established practice.

What is important is that the Government Employees Pension Act passed after much controversy, and it was amended through the so-called National Grand Compromise Body.

Not only civil servants’ organizations but also the Korean Federation of Teachers’ Associations took part in this body. So it has already been prepared through agreement, and since the Private School Teachers Pension has been reformed every time the Government Employees Pension was reformed so far, saying that the Private School Teachers Pension cannot be reformed this time alone, as an exception, seems to lack justification.

▷ At her New Year press conference in January this year, President Park Geun-hye said that the Private School Teachers Pension and the Military Pension should be pursued while comprehensively considering the special nature of the occupations and the financial soundness of the pensions. Do you think the Military Pension also needs to be addressed following the Private School Teachers Pension?

▶ The Military Pension is a more sensitive issue. They are the people responsible for national defense, are they not? But my position on this issue is that, while recognizing the special nature of military personnel and acknowledging the special aspects of the Military Pension, efforts toward achieving financial stability must continue without end.

The reality we face now is that people live much longer than in years past, is it not?

But society’s capacity to support is falling, so in an aging society every pension system, as a separate system, is losing sustainability, and reform in a direction that can raise sustainability seems inevitable. It does not seem to be an exception.

▷ But the question of when is something to be reviewed carefully... Is that what you are saying?

▶ Yes, yes. That is right. And then what the intensity of the reform will be; it seems a bit more thought is needed on such matters.

▷ We have been speaking with pension expert Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.

Thank you for your time today.

▶ Thank you.

ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.

Reporter Yoon Jae-seon

https://news.cpbc.co.kr/article/602713

Attachments

Related Posts