Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Full Interview Transcript] Committee Member Yun Suk-myung: “Pension Reform Should Go the ‘More for the Lower, Less for the Upper’ Way, with a Minimum Guaranteed Pension Introduced” (Posted October 15, 2014, 12:43 a.m.)

2026.11.16

* Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today, This Is Yoon Jae-seon>

[Key Remarks]

“The Government Employees Pension’s annual deficit is rising fast and is expected to reach 19.5 trillion won in 2040”

“Average life expectancy is 81; the period of receiving a pension is growing longer and high-pension recipients are also increasing”

“A low-contribution, high-benefit structure has become entrenched... finances grow more unstable as time passes”

“An automatic adjustment mechanism takes changes in average life expectancy and economic growth into account... leaving the government no room to feel burdened”

“An automatic adjustment mechanism is fatal when contribution periods are short”

“A minimum guaranteed pension system is needed for vulnerable groups”


[Full Transcript]


After President Park Geun-hye said she would draw heavily on the cases of Germany, Austria, and other countries in connection with the Government Employees Pension reform plan, attention has turned to European-style reform of civil servants’ pensions.

She said this in a recent written interview with a European current-affairs magazine.

We will talk with an expert about what lessons European-style reforms of civil servants’ pensions hold for us, as we are embroiled in conflict over Government Employees Pension reform.

Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, is on the line.



- Hello, Committee Member Yun. Let us start with what we are curious about. How large is the deficit subsidy for the Government Employees Pension now?

▶ It is growing very rapidly every year. Last year it was 2 trillion won, and this year it is expected to be 2.5 trillion won. The problem is that it is expected to reach 18 trillion won by 2018. The cumulative deficit over the next 10 years or so is expected to be about 53 trillion won, and the annual deficit is expected to be 7.3 trillion won in 2021, 14.5 trillion won in 2030, and 19.5 trillion won in 2040.



- What is the structural reason the Government Employees Pension deficit has no choice but to keep growing?

▶ Two aspects can be mentioned. One is that civil servants’ average life expectancy has risen sharply compared with what was expected when the Government Employees Pension system was introduced. When it was introduced in 1960, average life expectancy was 52, but these days it is 81, an increase of 29 years. As the period of receiving the pension has lengthened accordingly, and high-pension recipients have recently been increasing, the deterioration of the finances is getting worse. The other aspect is a problem with the system itself. Because the so-called low-contribution, high-benefit structure, in which one pays little and receives much, has become entrenched, financial instability seems to grow as time passes. For reference, since 2010 civil servants themselves have paid 7% and the state 7%, for a total of 14%. Civil servants feel that they are paying a great deal, but there was a long period in which they paid little, and to keep the system going at today’s benefit level without a deficit, at least 28%, more than double the current rate, would have to be collected by even the most conservative estimate.



- Conflict and confrontation over Government Employees Pension reform are not a problem unique to us, are they? I understand that Europe, which began discussing the problem of population aging earlier, also began discussing public pension issues long before we did.

▶ Western societies introduced their pension systems long ago, and problems also arose early, so there has been a great deal of discussion. The first country to begin discussing pension reform was Sweden. Problems with public pensions emerged with the two oil shocks of the 1970s, so discussions on pension reform began in 1985. After a fierce debate in the political arena lasting no fewer than 14 years, the reform was passed in January 1998, and from 1999 the system for the general public was changed in a truly revolutionary way, while the civil servants’ pension was changed from 2003. As for the foreign cases the President also mentioned, Germany began discussions in the early 1990s and its system changed substantially between 1998 and 2004. Austria also introduced a new system from 2005.



- So you are saying Europe also faced considerable resistance and side effects from pension reform. How did they make up for them and overcome them?

▶ There was a great deal of opposition. What they had in common was that, first, the state disclosed neutrally and very transparently why the pension system had no choice but to be reformed, and after disclosing it neutrally, on the judgment that reforming it this way seemed desirable for the nation’s future, political leaders exercised considerable drive to put it into practice. In Germany, Chancellor Schröder, who pushed pension reform, was a Social Democratic chancellor whose support base was workers, was he not? Even while being called a traitor by the workers who formed his support base, he carried out the reform, saying that for Germany’s future we had no choice but to go this way. In Austria, on the other hand, the ruling government drafted a reform plan, and a great many people gathered in the square in front of Vienna’s city hall and held an enormous demonstration. At that point the government and ruling party, finding themselves in a difficult position, asked the opposition: in our view the plan the government has prepared seems a good one, but please review whether there is a better one. After deliberating, the opposition concluded that, no matter how they looked at it, the plan put forward by the government and ruling party seemed best for Austria’s future, and so the political parties reached an agreement. Stakeholders opposed it very strongly, but through that strength the reform succeeded.



- What is the core of European-style pension reform in countries such as Germany, Austria, and Sweden? One element, I understand, is an automatic adjustment mechanism.

▶ The automatic adjustment mechanism is very complicated, and it is somewhat burdensome to address it directly at our current stage, so first, to give the core of Germany, Austria, and Sweden in broad terms, it can basically be seen as a direction of paying more and receiving less. So in Germany’s case the contribution period was extended somewhat, from 35 to 40 years, and Austria extended it up to a maximum of 50 years while cutting the pension paid out further, moving toward lowering benefits and raising contributions. Austria, too, raised its contribution rate to as much as 12.5. That is the basic part, and even after reform of this kind, there are periodic factors of financial instability as average life expectancy rises and economic growth falls, are there not? So, fundamentally to avoid policy controversy and conflict with stakeholders, they put in place an automatic linkage mechanism that automatically reflects in pension payments any rise in average life expectancy or fall in economic growth beyond what was expected. That leaves no room for political judgment to intervene.

- In a way, then, this differs from our Government Employees Pension, in which both contributions and benefits are defined.

▶ Yes. In our current situation, one of the biggest points of contention, and a source of conflict, is the question of why the government is not now keeping its past promise to pay a certain amount, is it not? Under this automatic adjustment mechanism, such controversy is ruled out at the source. Because, based on the contributions paid, the pension is later paid out in line with trends in average life expectancy and economic growth at the time of receipt, there is no room for the government to feel that kind of burden.
- Considering financial instability, it seems there may be a need to introduce an automatic adjustment mechanism, and that such a discussion should take place. What is your judgment?

▶ The automatic adjustment mechanism has advantages. It has the advantage that it can be done without political controversy, social conflict, or social costs, but there are some differences between us and Germany, Austria, and Sweden. These countries have very long histories of pension systems, and contribution periods are long on average. In Germany, even ordinary citizens who are not civil servants have already been contributing for close to 35 or 40 years, based on men. Even though the automatic adjustment mechanism is a very good system, when expected pension amounts are small because contribution periods are short or incomes are low, it poses a fatal problem for old-age income security. Financial stability can be achieved, but it has a negative side in terms of stable old-age income security. An approach that takes that aspect into account as well seems necessary; the Government Employees Pension is somewhat easier to shift in this direction than the National Pension, but even within the Government Employees Pension, because it is operated on an income basis, those in lower grades do not receive large pensions even now. So we should also move in the “more for the lower, less for the upper” direction. I believe this kind of system is necessary in the long run, but to go this way, there are vulnerable groups whose expected pensions are small, are there not? It seems we should proceed while introducing something like a minimum guaranteed pension system, under which such people, once they have been enrolled for a certain period, are guaranteed at least the minimum pension needed for life in old age. Countries such as Sweden have introduced one. We should pursue pension reform not merely with an eye to financial stabilization but also with income security in mind, as a way of securing a bridgehead for moving in this direction.

Yes, we will leave it there. We have heard views on the cases of European civil servants’ pension reform and their lessons.

That was Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Thank you for the interview today.

ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.

Reporter Yoon Jae-seon

https://news.cpbc.co.kr/article/534218

Related Posts