(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Full Interview Transcript] Yun Suk-myung: “The Reality of the Government Employees Pension Must Be Properly Disclosed to Win Public Support” (Posted August 26, 2014, 11:58 p.m.)
* Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today, This Is Seo Jong-bin>
[Key Remarks]
“For an earner of 5 million won: National Pension 990,000 won, Government Employees Pension 3.13 million won”
“The system was changed so that people can receive a pension even in their 40s”
“The National Pension has an income redistribution function”
“Those who receive more pension than they paid in are highly likely not to receive severance pay”
“The reality of the Government Employees Pension must be properly disclosed; the deficit has grown sharply just five years after the overhaul”
[Full Transcript]
Debate is heated over how to reform the Government Employees Pension, one of the axes of social conflict. Discussions have begun in earnest, and “a plan to reform the Government Employees Pension by linking it to the National Pension” is reported to be the front-runner. Over the 54 years since the Government Employees Pension was introduced, there have been several reforms, but all of them were transparent shams. So how should it be reformed this time?
Our guest is known as the foremost expert on the Government Employees Pension. Let us connect with Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. For reference, Research Fellow Yun also serves as an adjunct professor in the Department of Economics at Korea University.
- The Government Employees Pension was introduced 54 years ago and the National Pension 26 years ago. The reason for reforming the Government Employees Pension is to reduce its deficit and to ease the sense of relative deprivation among National Pension contributors. If we compare the amounts received under the two pensions, how large is the difference?
▶ The difference in amounts commonly reported in the media is an average, and averages hold many traps. I would like to speak plainly so that listeners can understand easily. First, the average amounts most often cited in the media are 840,000 won for the National Pension and 2.17 million won for the Government Employees Pension. But for the National Pension, that refers to people who have been enrolled for 20 years or more. These are amounts in which past income is reflected at—70%, 60%. So if we compare it with what applies under the new reform, the average pension amount of National Pension beneficiaries is 340,000 won a month. That is because their contribution periods are short, so to show the difference in amounts between the two systems very clearly, let me put it in terms of monthly income. For an earner of 3 million won a month, the Government Employees Pension pays about 1.88 million won and the National Pension pays 830,000 won. That is when the contribution period is set at 33 years for both. With a monthly income of 5 million won, the Government Employees Pension pays 3.13 million won and the National Pension 990,000 won. At 7 million won, the Government Employees Pension pays 4.39 million won and the National Pension 990,000 won. At the maximum ceiling of 8 million won, the Government Employees Pension pays 5.02 million won, and the National Pension still pays 990,000 won. Moreover, because these figures apply the so-called reform that took effect in 2010, people with long periods of past service receive larger pensions than this, so the gap widens even further.
- When you talk with civil servants, it seems to differ depending on whether they joined before or after 2010, does it not?
▶ What I just described is based on those who joined after 2010.
- That is why there is an effort to change this structure. When the Government Employees Pension was first introduced in 1960, the benefit amounts and the eligibility age were different from today, were they not?
▶ Yes. When it was first introduced in 1960, the pension benefit rate averaged 40%. The age at which one could receive the pension was also 60. But this kept rising until the mid-1980s, reaching 76%, which is a 90% increase in terms of the rate of increase. The pension that could be received at 60 was also changed so that, with just 20 years of enrollment, it could be received from the early-to-mid 40s. And from 1991, a retirement allowance corresponding to private-sector severance pay was introduced, and an average of 40% is being paid; that is only an average, and long-serving employees receive as much as 60%.
- Is it possible even now to receive a pension in one’s 40s?
▶ The system has changed a great deal, but among those receiving it there are quite a few in their 40s. With the 2000 reform, one can receive a pension after waiting twice the number of years by which one fell short of 20 years. So there are still people who can receive it in their early-to-mid 50s.
- The core of the government’s Government Employees Pension reform plan is to overhaul the system by comparing the Government Employees Pension and the National Pension on the basis of lifetime earnings. Lifetime earnings is the starting point of the reform; how do you view this?
▶ The approach itself does not seem bad, but there is likely to be much room for controversy depending on the criteria used for the calculation. This was already done by the first Government Employees Pension Development Committee from 2006, and there was a wide difference of opinion between stakeholders in the civil service and outside experts, because the question is where to set the lifetime-earnings standard; in terms of lifetime earnings, private-sector workers have less job security, do they not? Even people working at large companies leave in their early 50s, drift from one small or medium-sized firm to another, start a business, and lose all their severance pay, so there is an enormous gap in views over how to calculate lifetime earnings.
- Whenever criticism arises that Government Employees Pension benefits are high, it is pointed out in return that civil servants’ retirement allowance is smaller than that of ordinary workers and that their pension contributions are higher. They say the standards are different; how are they different?
▶ First, regarding contributions being high: from 2010, contributions have been levied on income equal to 65% of the base used to calculate them, so nominally the contributions were high, but if you calculate them the same way as the National Pension, the employee’s share was 4.9% until 2000 and 5.5% until 2009. The National Pension today has a short history, and the employee’s share is 4.5%, and 9% for the self-employed, is it not? Compared from this perspective, the claim that civil servants receive large pensions under the 54-year-old Government Employees Pension because their contributions are high does not seem valid, at least through 2010.
Next, I said the retirement allowance averages 40%, but in our country the share of the self-employed is high, so many people do not receive severance pay; only half of the entire economically active population receives it. If we are going to compare, we must compare properly: for those who receive severance pay, unlike the Government Employees Pension, the National Pension has an income redistribution function. That is, for people earning 2 million or 3 million won or more, there is an income redistribution function that shares part of the pension they would receive with low-income earners. Earlier I said that an earner of 8 million won can receive about 5 million won under the Government Employees Pension but 990,000 won under the National Pension, did I not? So the comparison has to be made on the same basis. Those who benefit from the income redistribution function, that is, people who receive more than they paid in, are highly likely not to receive severance pay, and those who are likely to receive severance pay receive a National Pension that, because of the income redistribution function, is incomparably lower than what civil servants receive. That is why people speak of the trap of averages.
- So the Government Employees Pension is a pension proportional to income, and because the National Pension has an income redistribution function, a simple comparison is difficult; and as for contributions, civil servants’ are based on their monthly remuneration while the National Pension’s are based on taxable income, so if the National Pension’s standard were applied to Government Employees Pension contributions, the contribution rate would fall accordingly. Is that what you are saying?
▶ That was the case until 2010, but from 2010 that standard was applied. Because the system is 54 years old, and those from before 2010 are benefiting from the past system. From that perspective, I think the comparison needs to be made properly.
- Looking at the Government Employees Pension reform plans now under discussion, it is reported that the plan is to cut pension benefits and instead raise the retirement allowance paid in a lump sum at retirement. I cannot help but ask a fundamental question. The two pensions have different designs and different sources of funding. So in many respects the standards do not even match for a simple comparison. Could making the levels of the two pensions similar end up being a matter of interpretation, like the saying “an earring if you hang it on your ear, a nose ring if you hang it on your nose”?
▶ At first glance this seems very good, but the system must be revised carefully, because it now seems to be moving toward matching the benefit-to-contribution ratios, and even so, there is a large difference in the ratios being changed, is there not? Approached as an average, there is no great difference, 1.7 versus 2.3, but when you look at individual cases, enormous differences emerge, do they not? Simply matching the benefit-to-contribution ratios could create another distortion, so I think the system should be revised in a direction that allows as transparent a comparison as possible.
- Civil servants are also voicing complaints about the reform plan now under discussion, that is, the plan to cut the monthly Government Employees Pension and instead raise severance pay to make up the difference. How do you view this?
▶ On this point, I do not think there should be much opposition from the civil service. Because, as I see it, the civil service says that, all things considered, they receive no more than National Pension contributors, does it not? The basic direction of this effort is to create systems that can be compared, and I simply cannot understand why those who claim they receive no more are so opposed to creating comparable systems.
- What would be needed to make them comparable?
▶ First, I think it would be good to properly disclose the reality the Government Employees Pension faces. It has already been reformed three times. It was reformed in 2009, yet in less than five years the size of the deficit has grown sharply, has it not? Depending on when one entered the Government Employees Pension system and one’s grade, pension amounts are being calculated that differ considerably from what the reform actually set out. That cannot be understood from a mere description of the system reform. So if we disclose, taking into account age, length of service, and so on, how much pension people have received and are expected to receive, the problems will naturally come to light, and on that basis a social consensus could easily be formed.
- Are you saying that such data on the actual situation are not being disclosed?
▶ Yes. Important data on the actual situation are not being disclosed at present. That does not seem to be a direction befitting the era of Government 3.0.
- The Government Employees Pension reform is being carried out by civil servants, is it not?
▶ On that point, in the last three reforms, stakeholders from the civil service, making up a majority, led the reform, so although it was called a reform and was praised at the time as a good reform, problems keep erupting within a few years.
We will leave it there. We have heard views on the direction of Government Employees Pension reform. That was Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.
