(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Full Interview Transcript] Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung: “Civil Servants Poorly Paid? 4.47 Million Won a Month — Over 50 Million Won a Year” (Posted September 23, 2014, 11:46 p.m.)
*Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today, This Is Seo Jong-bin>
[Key Remarks]
“We should hear the Pension Association’s plan first”
“On the claim that severance pay and retirement allowances are small... the direction of the overhaul includes compensating elements such as making severance pay realistic”
“The actual cut will be only 15–17%”
“The National Pension has an income redistribution function... the Government Employees Pension has none”
“The Government Employees Pension ceiling is 8.05 million won... the Government Employees Pension is still more advantageous”
“Civil servants poorly paid? 4.47 million won—over 50 million won a year”
[Full Interview Transcript]
The government and the ruling party’s Government Employees Pension reform is meeting a backlash from the civil service.
Civil servants themselves agree on the need to reform the Government Employees Pension system, but the backlash is all the greater because the views and positions of those directly affected were not reflected at all.
We connect with Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs and Adjunct Professor in the Department of Economics at Korea University, to hear his views on what the problems with the Government Employees Pension reform are and whether there are any solutions.
- Hello, Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung.
Should we regard the draft of the Government Employees Pension overhaul plan being pursued by the government and the ruling party as having been announced? How should we see it?
▶ When the Pension Association first presented its plan, it did not take a particular position. But after the public hearing fell through, both the Saenuri Party and the competent ministry, the Ministry of Security and Public Administration, lent it weight by saying it needed to be reviewed as a very important plan. What that means is that it can in effect be regarded as the government and the ruling party’s alternative.
- Yesterday we interviewed the chairman of the Korean Government Employees’ Union, who said they could not trust the Pension Association?
▶ A lot is being said about that. I did not take part directly in the discussion process either. I am a board member, but its members are diverse. Experts are gathering to draw up the plan, and what matters is what plans ultimately come out of that process; approaching it by saying the members are questionable without even hearing the plan could be a problem. The way it looks is not entirely smooth, but I think it would have been a better procedure to hear the proposed plan first and raise objections then if it contains a fatal flaw.
- The criticism was that because the organization called the Pension Association was created under the leadership of chaebol-affiliated insurers, it is made up of people seeking to shrink public pensions and devise ways to promote private pensions.
▶ I think that will become clear naturally as we watch the discussion process. It is not that simple, is it? You cannot hide the sky with the palm of your hand. I think it is not too late to raise such problems if they appear as things unfold, after first hearing the substance.
- The gist of the pension reform plan is to pay 43% more each month and receive 34% less, right?
▶ The pension system is complex, and in simplifying it the media are reporting it around keywords like that. The overall outline is right, but there are differences. Because it is an increase in burden and a benefit cut measured against the Government Employees Pension, and the biggest issue raised in discussing the Government Employees Pension is that retirement allowances are smaller than in the private sector—only about 39%—right? But they have said they will bring the retirement allowance, which is smaller than in the private sector, up to 100%. So there is not only cutting; there are also increases as compensation. So taking that into account, although civil servants’ benefits are said to be cut by 34%, the fact that the actual cut will be only around 15–17% also needs to be conveyed properly.
- So there is a separate plan to compensate through the retirement allowance.
▶ Yes. In exchange for cutting the Government Employees Pension, the retirement allowance is being raised to achieve relative equity with the private sector, so taking that into account, the cut is much smaller than what is reported in the media.
- Then how does it compare with the National Pension?
▶ It is so complex that it is hard to explain in detail in a short time. Those who entered the service before 2016 will still have a higher benefit rate than under the National Pension, even after the reform. On the other hand, new entrants from 2016 onward will have the same benefit rate and contribution burden as under the National Pension. Even so, there are differences. The National Pension has an income redistribution function: the average income of National Pension members is now 2 million won a month, and there is a function whereby those earning more than 2 million won support those with lower incomes with part of the contributions they pay. By contrast, even if the Government Employees Pension is aligned with the National Pension for those entering in 2016 and later, the Government Employees Pension has no such income redistribution function. And whereas the income ceiling is 4.08 million won for the National Pension, it is 8.05 million won for the Government Employees Pension, so the Government Employees Pension still has an advantage.
- But looking at the issue of civil servants’ pension contributions, National Pension contributions are 4.5%, while civil servants’ pension contributions are higher, at around 7% of wages.
▶ Currently contributions are 4.5% for the National Pension and 7% for the Government Employees Pension. The term income replacement rate does not capture this well, but there is a concept that can serve as a basis for comparison, the “accrual rate.” It is a technical term for how much Government Employees Pension benefit is paid for each year of service as a civil servant. Experts actually use this term. Even after the Government Employees Pension was reformed in 2009, the accrual rate for one year of service is 1.9. Multiplying this by 33 years gives an income replacement rate of 62.7. But the National Pension’s income replacement rate applied to ordinary citizens falls to 1 by 2028. So looking at the measures already reformed, there is about a twofold difference in what is received. So comparing contributions of 4.5% and 7%, they are actually paying less.
- But the government employees’ union says there is not much difference, since with the reform effective January 1, 2010, everything switched to taxable income.
▶ What I said is that it is true that 7% is a heavier burden than 4.5%, but compared on the basis of the already-reformed provisions, the pension amount received differs by about twofold, so in terms of the benefit-to-contribution ratio the Government Employees Pension is higher. The switch to taxable income also has important meaning. In the past, it was often said that the Government Employees Pension paid more than the National Pension because its contribution burden was higher, right? But the switch to taxable income happened only after 2010. Before that, in 2009 the contribution burden was 8%, but the contribution was based not on taxable income but on a standard called monthly base pay. Monthly base pay is only 65% of the taxable level, because various allowances are excluded. So although it is said that the Government Employees Pension members paid a lot over a long period, the contribution rose to 8% only after 2001. Before that it was not even 8%, and converted on the same basis as the National Pension, it was only 5.5%. So comparisons must be made on the same basis; even now, comparisons between the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension do not seem to be going very well, and the standards need to be unified to avoid this kind of confusion.
- When news of the Government Employees Pension overhaul came out, civil servants made claims such as: abolish the pension altogether and raise our salaries instead, or do not apply the pension reform across the board but apply it differently to senior and junior civil servants. What do you think?
▶ You raised two things at once. To take the latter first: although people say the Government Employees Pension is generous, looking at the reality, within the Government Employees Pension there is a considerable gap between junior and senior grades, as large as the gap between the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension. Regardless of income level or expected pension amount, the same reform measures came to be —. This time relatively strong reform is being considered, and if it applies equally regardless of grade, the retirement life of the lower grades, whose expected pensions are small, could become insecure. So the intensity of reform needs to be applied differentially. The so-called “more for the lower, less for the upper” type seems good, and if necessary an appropriate income redistribution function also seems to be needed. Next, the income ceiling for the pension is now 8.05 million won. Within the civil service it may not be thought that high, but I wonder whether the ceiling is too high, and I think that lowering it could be used as a way to redistribute to some degree within the civil service.
- The government’s current pension reform plan was, to be precise, drawn up by the Pension Association. You think it needs to be supplemented?
▶ Yes. The Association made no such proposal, but I think this element is necessary. And regarding the first question, people point out that civil servants are poorly paid, and this needs to be examined dispassionately. As of the end of last year, the actual pensionable income applied under the Government Employees Pension—the average monthly wage—was 4.37 million won. Calculated as an annual salary, that is over 50 million won. Average household income for urban workers is about 2 million won for one person and 3.65 million won a month for two. In this situation, with an average of 4.5 million won—and would it not have risen this year?—if this is claimed to be poor pay, public sentiment may not take it lightly. Of course, there is a problem with low starting salaries for junior grades, but that seems to require adjusting the civil service pay structure.
ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.
