Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Full Interview Transcript] Center Director Yun Suk-myung: “A 20-Million-Won Golf Membership Will Now Be Counted Entirely as Income” (Posted December 27, 2013, 12:18 a.m.)

2026.11.16

*Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today, This Is Seo Jong-bin>


[Key Remarks]

“The Basic Old-Age Pension is paid with no link to the National Pension contribution period”

“The Basic Pension is linked to the National Pension contribution period”

“People earning 1.5 million won as apartment security guards exceed the recognized income threshold and cannot receive the Basic Old-Age Pension”

“There are even cases of people living in Tower Palace and receiving the Basic Old-Age Pension”

“A 20-million-won golf membership will now be counted entirely as income”

“For those above median income, the disadvantage from differentiated Basic Pension payments would not be large”

“For those at or below median income, cuts to the Basic Pension will weaken their willingness to join the National Pension”


[Full Interview Transcript]

Starting next year, a Basic Pension will be paid to older people with low incomes. The law is being changed so that people who live in expensive apartments registered in their children’s names and drive imported cars cannot receive the pension. Let us hear an expert’s view on who will receive the Basic Pension and how much, and whether the scheme has any problems.

We are joined by telephone by Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Hello, Director!

- First, please explain what kind of scheme the Basic Pension is and how it differs from the Basic Old-Age Pension.

▶ The Basic Pension has been submitted to the government and the National Assembly, though the law has not yet passed. Under the submitted bill, the Basic Pension pays those among Korea’s older people aged 65 and over who are in the bottom 70% by income—that is, the 70% with lower incomes—between 100,000 won and 200,000 won a month. The Basic Old-Age Pension is a scheme introduced during the controversy over the 2007 National Pension Act amendment bill. In practice it has been applied since 2008. It is the same as the Basic Pension in that it is financed by taxes. The beneficiaries are likewise the bottom 70% by income, but the Basic Old-Age Pension pays 96,800 won a month regardless of the National Pension contribution period. The Basic Pension differs in that it pays a minimum of 100,000 won and up to 200,000 won, linked to the National Pension contribution period.

- The recognized income criterion that serves as the basis for selecting Basic Pension recipients is reportedly changing. What is the recognized income criterion?

▶ Recognized income means income together with the assets older people own, converted into income. In the case of older people, given the form their working hours and labor take, they have almost no earned income, and they usually own assets, do they not? So these assets are converted into income, applying an asset conversion rate of 5%. The criterion for selecting Basic Pension recipients on the basis of the total expected income after this conversion is what is called recognized income.

- Why was the recognized income criterion changed at this point?

▶ There are older people who, because life is hard, scrape by working as apartment security guards and are paid about 1.5 million won. Because their earned income exceeds the recognized income threshold, they cannot receive the Basic Old-Age Pension. The same would likely be true of the Basic Pension. On the other hand, there were situations in which people living in expensive apartments such as Tower Palace and owning luxury cars or golf memberships received the Basic Old-Age Pension. So the government seems to have changed the rules with the strong intent that, from now on, anyone with luxury assets will not be able to receive the Basic Pension.

- People with expensive imported cars or golf and condominium memberships will reportedly also be excluded from receiving the Basic Pension. Under this revision, there will presumably be cases of people who were receiving it and no longer will, and of people who were not and now will. You said you could explain with examples?

▶ Let me describe two cases. As for those who were receiving the Basic Pension and no longer will: people who own real estate worth about 200 million won in a large city and have a 20-million-won golf membership can receive the Basic Old-Age Pension. But instead of applying a 5% income conversion to the 20-million-won golf membership, the entire 20 million won will be counted as income, so from now on these people will not be able to receive the Basic Old-Age Pension. On the other hand, people working as apartment security guards on a monthly wage of 1.5 million won could not receive the Basic Pension, but the system looks set to change so that, with a wider earned income deduction, such people will be able to receive the Basic Pension.

- So it is all right even if the person earning 1.5 million won a month owns an apartment?

▶ A basic deduction applies up to the 2.08 million won minimally needed to live on. For the remaining amount, unless it is a very luxurious apartment, they can receive it.

- It has been controversial that the longer a person’s National Pension contribution period, the smaller the Basic Pension he or she receives. What do you make of the view that this amounts to so-called reverse discrimination against National Pension members?

▶ This issue does not seem simple at all. For people whose income is above a certain level, differentiated payments would probably not put them at much of a disadvantage. The reason is that the National Pension currently offers the highest return of any financial product in Korea. So, although they would receive 100,000 won less, there do not seem to be people whose expected National Pension is 1 million won; on top of that, the problem is that groups whose employment is, on average, insecure and whose incomes are low already have small expected National Pension amounts. But if the Basic Pension amount is cut year by year as the National Pension contribution period grows, there is a strong concern that their participation will weaken. Not a few experts have consistently raised concerns about this. On the reverse-discrimination issue, judgments seem likely to differ. If one holds that every generation should receive the same Basic Pension amount, the reverse-discrimination issue could arise, but if one considers the introduction of the Basic Pension in terms of solving the high poverty of those who could not properly prepare for old age, the reverse-discrimination issue could be sidestepped.

- There are also concerns that this will create the perception that there is no need to pay into the National Pension for a long time, which could make old age insecure. What do you think?

▶ The plan to keep cutting the Basic Pension as the National Pension contribution period gets longer is likely to weaken the incentive to join the National Pension, so it seems to be a point that needs a great deal of thought.

- Some also see young people, the middle-aged, and the middle class as losing out. It could become a source of intergenerational conflict—will they actually lose out?

▶ As I said earlier, from the standpoint that every generation should receive the same Basic Pension amount, in the case of the younger generation, since the national — increases, they receive that much less, so one can say they lose out. From that standpoint, that is correct. But although the government, despite much criticism, does tend to raise the issue, our older population, currently 6.13 million, will grow to 18 million after 2060. The Basic Pension scheme already costs a lot of money now, and it could become a scheme that requires enormous sums in the future. So on the receiving side one can speak of reverse discrimination, but on the paying side the question may arise of why on earth it was designed this way.

- The Korea Institute of Public Administration surveyed 53 pension experts, and 72% opposed it for the reasons I asked about earlier. Can the Basic Pension scheme actually be implemented well?

▶ An explanatory release was issued saying the Basic Pension survey results were not fair. What needs to be examined carefully is that, as I said earlier, because the Basic Pension will cost a great deal in the future, the pension was introduced to reduce costs from a long-term perspective. But at this stage we need to think a little more fundamentally: the purpose of introducing the Basic Pension is to alleviate the elderly poverty rate, the highest in the OECD. Yet at present 40% of older people aged 65 and over have a recognized income of 0 won. Even if they receive a 200,000-won Basic Pension, it falls short of the minimum cost of living of 572,000 won. So it may cost a great deal of money without much effect on old-age poverty. In that respect, there are limits to achieving the policy objective, and because the vulnerable within the middle class do not earn much in wages, their National Pension participation rate could weaken, which could backfire. These issues are not easy. It seems we need to put our heads together and find a solution.

- What do you think of the idea of considering the use of the National Pension Fund if funding for the Basic Pension falls short?

▶ I believe that the moment the National Pension Fund is used, the foundation of the National Pension will collapse. There was a great deal of controversy about this from the start of the year, and many people expressed strong opposition, saying the National Pension Fund must never be used for the Basic Old-Age Pension. Even now, not a few people fail to pay National Pension contributions for one reason or another. Not everyone is paying. In this situation, if the fund that was so painstakingly accumulated were used for the Basic Old-Age Pension, it could become a disincentive, leading many people to think they can receive benefits without paying contributions.

- Then how should the Basic Old-Age Pension be financed?

▶ I am sorry to say it, and there is much controversy, but I see no suitable option other than taxes. Because the various other methods seem likely to cause major problems in the long term. Since this is a problem that has built up over a long time, it keeps getting postponed. It is painful in the short term, but among taxes, rather than the frequently mentioned value-added tax or indirect taxes, it seems desirable to approach it through direct taxes borne by high earners.

ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.

https://news.cpbc.co.kr/article/489616

Related Posts