Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(YTN Radio) [Economy Hot Issue] “Felt Welfare: Is Money the Problem?” — Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (August 14, 2013)

2026.11.14
(YTN Radio) [Economy Hot Issue] “Felt Welfare: Is Money the Problem?” — Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (August 14, 2013)

<Wednesday Economy Hot Issue> “Felt Welfare: Is Money the Problem?”
— Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs

Anchor:
The economy has two major issues. One is growth, and the other is distribution. On the distribution side, what can come up is welfare. People naturally assume that if there is growth, distribution will go well, but that is not necessarily so. So you cannot make it a fixed answer that welfare will necessarily follow from growth. Even with growth, welfare policy can work only if we distribute well and plan welfare well. There seems to be a widespread sense that poverty and polarization are deepening in every corner of society right now. Watching the controversy over this tax reform plan, today I would like to start from this question: just how serious are the state of welfare in Korea and its problems? We have Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, on the phone. Hello.

Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (hereafter Yun Suk-myung):
Yes. Hello.

Anchor:
How large is Korea’s welfare spending right now? It has grown a lot, hasn’t it?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes, it has grown enormously. I think I should say something from the outset. Public perception of it is low, but welfare spending is increasing very rapidly. As you know, because Korea is a member of the OECD, that is, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, we tend to compare our welfare spending with that of OECD member countries. But the latest is 2009, because international organizations’ statistics come out four or five years late while they are being compiled. The problem is that Korea’s welfare spending is rising very fast even among OECD member countries, so 2009 data are somewhat out of touch with reality. What we can look at now is the 2009 baseline. On that 2009 baseline, public welfare spending as a share of gross domestic product, that is, GDP, averages 22.1% in the OECD, while ours is 9.4%. Since that is only about 43%, there is a great deal of criticism that it is far too little. But there is something we need to point out here. In Korea, severance pay, which is a statutory system, is not reflected in this figure. It is not counted under the OECD standard. If it were counted, the figure would rise to about 49% or 50%. Then, if we take into account the national burden ratio, the national income level, the population share, and the maturity of the pension system, which accounts for a large share of spending, we see that, overall, about 70% of the OECD average would be appropriate for Korea. So from that standpoint, spending is rising fast, but it can be said that it needs to rise somewhat further than it is now.

Anchor:
So you are estimating that, compared with OECD countries, it should be somewhere between about 15% and 17%?

Yun Suk-myung:
The overall shortfall is...

Anchor:
The shortfall, I see. Then if spending is rising this fast, as you say, do you think the public or the government feel that the level of welfare has improved?

Yun Suk-myung:
There is no doubt that the overall level of welfare has improved. But the fact that the public does not feel much benefit from welfare seems to be caused by welfare polarization.

Anchor:
Oh, there is polarization in welfare too?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. The polarization seems very serious. Take social insurance, which accounts for the largest share of welfare: the National Pension, health insurance, employment insurance, and industrial accident insurance,

Anchor:
The four major social insurance schemes?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. Health insurance benefits more or less the whole population, but in the case of the National Pension, employment insurance, and industrial accident insurance, it is mainly people with good jobs who benefit. Then there is public assistance paid to low-income groups, the so-called National Basic Livelihood Security System being the representative scheme, and because this system, too, is concentrated on those truly below the minimum cost of living, people in an in-between position see no particular benefit even though welfare spending has increased enormously. This seems to be a very serious problem.

Anchor:
Compared with other countries, then, what stage would you say we are at?

Yun Suk-myung:
Well, the comparison is not simple. In welfare, under what is called “Welfrontierism,” welfare states fall broadly into three types: the Scandinavian model, represented by Sweden; the continental European model, represented by Germany; and the Anglo-American model. People in Korea who talk a lot about welfare issues mostly talk about the Scandinavian type represented by Sweden. In these countries, the average tax burden ratio is around 45%. So it is hard to compare them directly with Korea. If we take the countries that are similar in various economic and social conditions to be the United States, Japan, the United Kingdom, and so on, then compared with those countries Korea does not appear to lag far behind in overall social security and welfare.

Anchor:
Yes. Many economists and politicians talk about the welfare policies of the Scandinavian Peninsula, but the environment there is very different from Korea’s, isn’t it? From Korea’s, right?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. It is very different. I recently visited the three countries for ten days myself, and I envy them a great deal.

Anchor:
Their populations alone are around 9 million, aren’t they?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. Sweden is the largest at 9.3 million, Finland is about 5.3 million, and Norway about 4.8 million. As a result, it seems easier than in Korea to build a social consensus on running a welfare system with heavy spending, and they also seem to have had a full learning effect over more than 50 years.

Anchor:
Socialist governments held power there for some 50 years or more, right?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes, Social Democratic Party governments for that long,

Anchor:
Social Democratic governments, yes. Listening to what you are saying, this is in fact how it has been under this administration. For the welfare budget, if, say, about 13 trillion won is needed, the plan was to raise about 9 trillion won by making budget spending more efficient and about 4 trillion won through taxes, by bringing the underground economy into the open or through voluntary tax reporting, to collect more tax. On the first part I mentioned, making welfare spending efficient and getting it right, it turned out that 63.9 billion won had been paid to 320,000 dead people. Unless this problem of the welfare budget leaking away is fixed quickly, it looks difficult.

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. Amid talk that taxes must keep going up and so on, although they said it would not be a direct tax increase, when reports come out in this situation that the National Pension Service and others made wrongful payments, it seems only natural that the public reacts badly. As you said, recoveries of National Pension payments have been decided in 80,000 cases, amounting to 57 billion won. The public cannot help but be very dissatisfied about this, and the big problem seems to have arisen in the process of integrating the Social Welfare Integrated Management Network, the delivery system for welfare programs that each government ministry and local government had run separately. So rather than keep making such excuses, the government should take the lead in fixing these problems quickly, and the Ministry of Health and Welfare has also said that it will quickly form a task force to carry out checks and prepare countermeasures.

Anchor:
Yes. President Park Geun-hye’s welfare pledge, in short, is a customized welfare policy for each stage of the life cycle, isn’t it?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes, that is right.

Anchor:
Free childcare for ages 0 to 5 and more daycare centers, full support of university tuition for the third child, and 100% health insurance coverage of medical costs for the four major serious diseases: these were the original guarantees, and lately there is a feeling that they have been pulled back a great deal. Is this really possible without a tax increase? How do you see it?

Yun Suk-myung:
Well, a tax increase seems unavoidable for now, but although many people criticize it, bringing the underground economy into the open and broadening the tax base should come first. Why? Because unlike other countries that run welfare states, Korea’s underground economy, that is, the informal sector, is far too large.

Anchor:
How large do you estimate it is relative to GDP?

Yun Suk-myung:
Well, estimates go back and forth, but everyone seems to agree that it is at least 25%, which is an enormous size. Beyond the size, what many people complain about is that office workers, that is, salaried employees, have “glass wallets,” so all our income sources are exposed, whereas among the self-employed there are many who are struggling but also many high earners, aren’t there? If their incomes cannot be identified accurately, there seem to be considerable problems in terms of tax justice as well. So the government should do its utmost on this front, but in terms of the overall expansion of the welfare system that the government is now talking about, a tax increase looks unavoidable, it seems to me.

Anchor:
Yes. As you just said, if the underground economy is about 25% of our total GDP, then since this is a 1,000 trillion won economy, that is a 25 trillion won economy, the underground economy... Even if only 10% of this 25 trillion won underground economy is brought into the open, 2.5 trillion won comes in a year, so 10 trillion won in resources would be secured over four years, wouldn’t it?

Yun Suk-myung:
It might even be more than that, ha ha.

Anchor:
Right? We have talked about funding all along, but let me ask you about one more funding issue at the end. There is talk that tax revenue in the first half of the year has fallen by about 10 trillion won. And even under the revised tax reform plan, tax revenue is expected to fall by 440 billion won, and however much they say they will expand tax revenue through economic growth, isn’t a fundamentally different approach needed in raising the resources for welfare? How do you see it?

Yun Suk-myung:
First of all, the commitment to providing welfare is something that both the ruling party and the opposition largely agreed on in the last presidential election, isn’t it?

Anchor:
That is right, yes.

Yun Suk-myung:
But once we decide to provide welfare, rather than pressing too hard over who did well or badly, or whether pledges are kept or not, we need to build a consensus on how we should proceed in order to provide welfare properly. From that point of view, many people seem to acknowledge that a tax increase is unavoidable, but as things move toward raising taxes, the opposition raises many objections about the part where the need for a tax increase is acknowledged. Even if taxes are raised, in my view it would be better to leave indirect taxes such as an increase in value-added tax, which is less painful, for later generations, and I think it would be good to go toward raising direct taxes, even if that is more painful. Also, in this process there is a lot of talk about raising corporate tax and so on, a tax increase on the rich, but I am not trying to defend the rich here: they are already bearing quite a burden. I think that instead of dividing people into camps, it would be desirable for building social consensus to go in a direction where, apart from those who are truly struggling, those who can bear even a little more bear a little more, and the wealthy with more room to spare bear somewhat more.

Anchor:
Well. It would be good if things were put the way you just did, that society should share the burden a bit more together, but when some people say it is just a matter of plucking a few feathers, many people seem to get angry. Welfare has to be quite finely designed, doesn’t it?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes.

Anchor:
So it has to be approached systematically in many ways, and as you said, what do you see as the most urgent welfare need for us?

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. Because so many welfare issues come up in such a scattered way, the public, unable to feel any benefit, seems to take much of it as empty talk, but the most desirable form of welfare as I see it is building a tight social safety net. What this means is that if it becomes ingrained in the public mind that, even if you fail at something, the state will guarantee at least a life of human dignity, then young people too will take on very challenging work rather than stable jobs such as the civil service, and creative talent will then contribute greatly to the nation’s wealth creation. I think building the welfare budget in that direction is desirable for both individuals and the country.

Anchor:
That is a good point. But there seems to be one condition. Those who did such things illegally would not need protection in the form of a minimum livelihood or a social safety net, would they?

Yun Suk-myung:
Of course. Such cases must be thoroughly screened out.

Anchor:
Yes. So, on large corporations and high-income earners, whose tax burden you also mentioned earlier: in other countries these days there are people who say they will pay more tax of their own accord, but here no one is stepping forward like that right away, and on the other hand, as Newstapa also reported, we have to worry about tax evasion by the rich through offshore tax havens. How should these problems be resolved to achieve better welfare?

Yun Suk-myung:
First of all, building a social consensus is important, and the question is what kind of social consensus. In Western public finance there is the idea of the externality of justice: one reason many rich people pay a lot of tax to their local communities is that if poor people in the community fall ill, their own children could be infected, and so the breadth of thinking widens beyond the purely economic in various ways. If we, too, want to build a society that achieves social integration soundly and in which everyone can live reasonably well, then those who have earned a lot of money should consider that they earned it because our society exists, and it would be good for them to set aside somewhat the thought of “why do you keep asking only us to pay?” And many people in the middle class also say, “Where would we get the money, with private education costs and jeonse deposits going up? Why do you keep asking us to bear more tax?” But if we want welfare, I think it becomes possible, in terms of social integration, only if we show an attitude of each bearing a little more even in difficult circumstances.

Anchor:
We will stop here for today. Thank you.

Yun Suk-myung:
Yes, thank you.

Anchor:
That was Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.

[Copyright (c) YTN radio. Unauthorized reproduction, redistribution, and use as AI data prohibited.]

https://m.radio.ytn.co.kr/interview_view.php?id=25928&s_mcd=0206

Related Posts