(Yonhap News TV) “Restoring Trust in the Pension Is Necessary” vs. “Hundreds of Trillions Added to the Nation’s Debt” (September 4, 2018)

(On the Moon Jae-in administration’s
push to introduce a National Pension payment guarantee provision,
this report includes interviews with a supporter of the guarantee,
Kim Nam-hee, team head at People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy, and
with one who is concerned about introducing the guarantee provision,
Committee Member Yun Suk-myung.)
“Restoring Trust in the Pension Is Necessary”
vs
“Hundreds of Trillions Added to the Nation’s Debt”
[Anchor]
Controversy over National Pension reform keeps growing.
Amid fears that people may pay contributions only to receive nothing, the government is considering spelling out a payment guarantee in law.
But there is also a strong counterargument that this would make the nation’s debt snowball and make pension reform even harder.
Reporter Jeong In-yong reports.
[Reporter]
[Moon Jae-in / President] “I ask that you actively consider ways to ease public anxiety by making the (National Pension) payment guarantee clear.”
As anxiety grew over projections that the National Pension would be depleted in 2057, three years earlier than expected,
President Moon Jae-in called for a payment guarantee plan.
Progressive civic groups take the same position.
[Kim Nam-hee / Head of the Welfare and Tax Team, People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy] “I think legislating a state payment guarantee is necessary, if only to restore trust in the National Pension. As long as public distrust persists…”
But a payment guarantee is not as simple a matter as it seems.
First, spelling out a payment guarantee amounts to acknowledging that the National Pension is a debt the state must repay.
That means it would be no different from the Military Pension, which is already depleted but continues to be paid with tax subsidies.
In that case, by corporate-style accounting, the nation’s debt could rise by more than 600 trillion won.
A payment guarantee could also make pension reform harder.
That is because people could oppose the contribution increases needed to prevent fund depletion while demanding only payment, shifting a heavy burden onto future generations.
[Yun Suk-myung / Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs]
“At an abstract level, one can examine the pros and cons of a state payment guarantee, but efforts to improve the system so as to secure the sustainability of the pension system must also go hand in hand.”
The government has begun gathering public opinion to finalize a National Pension reform plan.
By next month, when the plan is due to be submitted to the National Assembly, it must reach a conclusion between the hard choices of restoring trust and a snowballing national debt.
This has been Jeong In-yong, Yonhap News TV.
