(Pension Future Forum Position Statement) Regarding the Basic Pension Presentation at the Debate Hosted by the Public Pension Strengthening People’s Action and Others (November 8, 2026)
Pension Future Forum Position Statement
Our Position on the Claim That the “More for the Lower, Less for the Upper”
Basic Pension Raises the Elderly Poverty Rate
At a debate hosted by some civic groups, including the Public Pension Strengthening People’s Action,
a presentation was made, and reported in the press, claiming that the government’s “more for the lower, less for the upper” (下厚上薄) Basic Pension overhaul plan would push the elderly poverty rate to 38.89% in ten years, actually 0.37 percentage points higher than if the current system (38.52%) were maintained.
This amounts to dismissing the reality of the multi-tiered old-age income security system and deceiving the public by exploiting a statistical illusion.
To correct the logical errors in that claim, the Pension Future Forum states its position as follows.
First, we condemn the deceptive misuse of even the OECD recommendations, the global standard.
The measure of keeping Basic Pension recipients who are above the OECD relative poverty line eligible while halting their price indexation until death
is an eminently reasonable policy that this Forum has long proposed and that has also been adopted in the Ministry of Health and Welfare’s current overhaul plan.
If this policy holds the incomes of the middle-income group fixed, then, arithmetically, the relative poverty line itself, which is tied to overall median income, will shift.
Packaging a statistical illusion that has nothing to do with any actual worsening in the lives of low-income people as “the poverty rate rose because of ‘more for the lower, less for the upper’”
is either ignorance of how the statistics are calculated or a deliberate distortion meant to stir up public opinion for a particular purpose.
Second, the claim completely ignores the “maturation effect of the National Pension” and the “characteristics of assets.”
Discussing elderly poverty while isolating the figures of a single program, the “Basic Pension,” to project the poverty rate ten years from now is likewise shortsighted conjecture.
The elderly generation of 2035 will consist mainly of the baby-boom generation, with long contribution periods and high real benefit amounts.
Owing to the maturation of the National Pension system, their public pension benefits will be far higher than those of today’s elderly generation.
Several recent empirical studies have also shown that, unlike past generations, they have accumulated real and financial assets on a substantial scale.
Claiming a future deterioration in the poverty rate while excluding the key variables of old-age income is far-fetched reasoning that distorts reality.
The Pension Future Forum urges an immediate stop to clouding the public’s eyes and ears and misleading public opinion with nothing but “half-baked variables” and “extreme assumptions.”
Rather than avoiding debate to hide the holes in their logic,
we demand that they step forward confidently into a transparent academic debate grounded in objective and comprehensive data.
November 8, 2026
Pension Future Forum
