(Pension Future Forum Future Generations Network Statement) On the Contents of the Press Release on the Basic Pension Issued by the Office of Representative Nam In-soon on October 31, 2026
(In response to the office of Representative Nam In-soon’s
press release on the Basic Pension,
this is a statement by the youth organization under the Pension Future Forum,
the “Future Generations Network.”)
A Basic Pension Debate Caught in the ‘Trap of Averages’: Look to the Essence of Structural Reform
We Ask Representative Nam In-soon to State a Clear Position on the Direction of Basic Pension Reform
Citing Ministry of Health and Welfare data, the office of Representative Nam In-soon recently stated that the general property of Basic Pension beneficiaries in the top 1% by recognized income (assessed income plus the income-converted value of assets) averages 340 million won and their earned income about 2.2 million won a month, and made remarks to the effect that the issue of wealthy asset holders receiving the Basic Pension had been somewhat exaggerated.
Yet these data, if anything, raise even more questions. To begin with, the very expression “top 1%” needs to be looked at again in numbers. Since Basic Pension beneficiaries now number more than 7 million, the top 1% alone comes to about 70,000 people. Is it really reasonable to lump the property of as many as 70,000 people into a single figure, an average of 340 million won, and on that basis to conclude that the controversy over wealthy asset holders receiving benefits has been exaggerated?
An average does not show a distribution. We cannot tell how many are in the 100 million to 200 million won range, how many have 500 million won or more, or how many wealthy asset holders with 1 billion won or more there actually are. If a large number of people with extremely little property are included, the average can fall sharply even if quite wealthy asset holders exist. What is needed now, therefore, is not a single average but the distribution of the roughly 70,000 people by property and income band.
There is an even more fundamental problem. Why should such important statistics be provided to only one particular lawmaker’s office and reach the public only after passing through that office’s interpretation? The Basic Pension is a national program into which tens of trillions of won in taxes are poured every year, and young people and future generations, who will bear its costs for a long time to come, are also stakeholders in the policy. Within the bounds of protecting personal information, the de-identified raw data, or at the very least the distribution by property and income band and the calculation criteria, should be disclosed to researchers so that anyone can reproduce and verify the same results.
Another thing to examine is the change within the older generation. The economic circumstances of the young-old and the old-old differ too greatly for everyone aged 65 or older to be grouped together as one. Poverty rates are far higher among the old-old, whereas the baby-boom generation now newly turning 65 has longer National Pension contribution periods than earlier generations and has accumulated relatively more income and assets.
Research, too, points out that economic circumstances and asset gaps within the baby-boom generation are widening and that old-age income security policies reflecting the characteristics of each generation are needed. Even so, we still maintain a system that first fixes a number, “70% of the population aged 65 or older,” and then fits people into it.
The reason we raise this issue is not to find a few wealthy older people and take their Basic Pension away. It is to ask, while providing more generous support than now to older people who are truly poor, whether it is reasonable to keep maintaining the 70% ratio even as the older population and its economic circumstances change greatly.
We therefore ask Representative Nam In-soon to state a clearer position on the future direction of Basic Pension reform. We ask the Representative to make clear whether, in the Representative’s view, it is desirable to keep paying 70% of older people even as the older population surges; whether the same ratio should be maintained even as the incomes and assets of the generations of older people entering in the future rise; or whether the role and eligibility criteria of the Basic Pension should be redesigned so that resources can be concentrated on older people who truly need help.
The younger generation is not demanding that older people be given less. What we ask is that the Basic Pension be paid properly to older people who are truly poor and that the program be made bearable for the generations that will shoulder its costs over the coming decades. More than 70,000 people cannot be explained by a single number, and the structural problems of the Basic Pension must not be left unattended by falling into the trap of averages.
We ask the office of Representative Nam In-soon and the Ministry of Health and Welfare to disclose verifiable detailed statistics behind these data and to state a clear position on structural reform of the Basic Pension, including the “70% of older people” eligibility criterion. Future generations, who will be responsible for the Basic Pension, are waiting for the answer.
November 2, 2026
Pension Future Forum Future Generations Network
(The statement file is attached.)
