Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(Yonhap News) The National Pension Income Replacement Rate: From 70% to 60% to 40%, and Now Raised to 50%. May 4, 2015 (4:54 p.m.)

2026.11.21

As the ruling and opposition parties have agreed to raise the National Pension’s income replacement rate from 40% to 50%, interest in the adequacy of the income replacement rate is growing.

The income replacement rate refers to how much pension one receives relative to the income one earned on average over the National Pension contribution period. The average income over the contribution period, converted into present value, is the “average income,” and the rate is calculated as the pension payment relative to that average income.

For example, if a person with an average income of 1 million won receives 500,000 won as a pension, the income replacement rate is 50%.

The pension amount varies greatly depending on the length of the contribution period and the level of income.

When the government sets the income replacement rate as a matter of policy, it uses as its benchmark the income replacement rate of “a person who paid National Pension contributions for 40 years with an average monthly income of 2 million won.” This is called the “nominal income replacement rate.”

The income replacement rates agreed on by the ruling and opposition parties are all based on the “nominal income replacement rate.”

Because the nominal income replacement rate is based on 40 years of enrollment, it differs from the “effective income replacement rate” that applies, on average, to most contributors. Especially now, when people start work late and retire early, it is not easy to complete a 40-year contribution period.

The effective income replacement rate is about half the nominal income replacement rate. A person enrolled for 25 years with an average income of 2 million won receives a pension of roughly 500,000 won, in which case the effective income replacement rate is 25%.

When the National Pension was first introduced in 1988 under the Roh Tae-woo administration, the nominal income replacement rate was 70%. Compared with the level of contributions, the pension amount was on the generous side.

The first reform was carried out in 1997 under the People’s Government, when Korea was receiving an International Monetary Fund (IMF) bailout.

The income replacement rate fell to 60%, and it was decided to raise the pension eligibility age gradually from 60 to 65, by one year every five years from 2013 through 2033.

Raising the pension eligibility age means raising the age at which pension receipt begins.

The National Pension’s long-term finances can be that much more stable, but contributors receive their pensions later.

The second reform took place in 2008 under the Participatory Government. At that time, a plan was finalized to lower the income replacement rate to 50% at once and then by a further 0.5% each year so that it reaches 40% in 2028, and it remains in place today.

Both reforms proceeded over a considerable period amid fierce debate among stakeholders, experts, and the political sphere.

By contrast, regarding the recent agreement to raise the income replacement rate back to 50%, it has been pointed out as a problem that, unlike in the past, there was no proper discussion.

Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, pointed out,

“Unlike past reforms, there was no intense discussion in the process of raising the income replacement rate to 50%,” adding, “The National Pension’s income replacement rate was adjusted abruptly at a meeting held to discuss the Government Employees Pension.”

The two axes of the controversy over the National Pension’s income replacement rate are the National Pension’s old-age security and its sustainability.

The controversy over the National Pension’s level of protection concerns whether people receive an appropriate pension relative to what they paid in.

Those who say the level of protection is insufficient point out that the National Pension amount falls far short of covering living expenses. The criticism is that National Pension benefits are so small that they amount to a “pocket-money pension.”

According to a recent Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs report, “Prospects for the Entitlement Structure and Benefit Levels of the Multi-Tiered Income Security System” (by researchers Woo Hae-bong and Han Jeong-lim), the income replacement rate of National Pension beneficiaries among those born from 1952 to 1984 was only 30%.

Until now, the government’s position on the National Pension’s benefit adequacy has focused on “closing the coverage gaps” and “the era of one pension per person.”

Its judgment is that expanding opportunities to join the National Pension for career-interrupted full-time homemakers, the unemployed, part-time workers, and others, and thereby changing the existing “one pension per household” system into a “one pension per person” system, would increase benefit adequacy accordingly.

The National Pension’s sustainability problem is what drove past National Pension reforms.

According to the Third National Pension Long-Term Financial Projection released in March 2013 by the National Pension Financial Estimation Committee, the National Pension is projected to turn to deficit in 2044 and its reserve fund to be depleted in 2060, owing to rapid population aging and other factors.

There is also the rebuttal that the fund-depletion argument is exaggerated.

The argument is that Korea should respond calmly, considering that it went through National Pension reform early on and that its reserves are not small compared with those of other countries.

Korea has adopted a “funded system,” in which a certain amount is accumulated and invested. The point is that it has more leeway in reserves than other countries that use a “pay-as-you-go (PAYG) system,” in which the working generation bears the cost each year.

In 2014, the National Pension’s reserve ratio (reserves/required expenditure) was 28.1 times, higher than the 1 to 4.8 times of other countries such as Japan, Canada, the United States, and Sweden.

Kim Seong-suk, President of the National Pension Research Institute, explained in an article titled “Understanding the Depletion of the National Pension Fund,” recently posted on the institute’s website, “Considering the reserve ratio, there is a fair amount of time to spare for institutional reform,” adding, “Whether to maintain a financing method that continues to hold a fund, or to improve the PAYG method as advanced countries have, is a matter to be decided through social consensus.”

https://news.kbs.co.kr/news/mobile/view/view.do?ncd=3069331

Related Posts