Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(Yonhap News, KBS News) Yonhap News — Pension Reform Controversy: Experts Also Divided over “Raising vs. Freezing” the National Pension Income Replacement Rate. May 4, 2015 (6:39 p.m.)

2026.11.21

Regarding the political sphere’s agreement to raise the National Pension’s nominal income replacement rate from 40% to 50%, pension experts gave mixed reactions on its necessity, feasibility, and other aspects.

The experts broadly agreed on the need to strengthen benefit adequacy but offered differing views on how to do so.

Professor Kim Yeon-myeong of Chung-Ang University (Dean of the Graduate School of Social Development) stressed, “The nominal income replacement rate is the income replacement rate for someone enrolled in the National Pension for 40 years,” adding, “The effective income replacement rate is far lower than this, at a level at which one cannot get by in old age, so raising the nominal income replacement rate is clearly necessary.”

According to Professor Kim, the average National Pension contributor has been enrolled for 25 years with a monthly income of 2 million won, in which case the effective income replacement rate is about 25%.

In other words, a worker who earned 2 million won a month would receive a National Pension of 500,000 won each month, which falls far short of guaranteeing a dignified life in old age.

Professor Kim took part, as a member recommended by the opposition party, in the working group on Government Employees Pension reform that produced the political sphere’s agreement to raise the nominal income replacement rate.

Professor Kim pointed out, “If the fund depletion date is fixed at 2060, raising the nominal income replacement rate to 50% requires raising the contribution rate by only 1.01 percentage points, from the current 9.0% to 10.01%,” adding, “When the government says the contribution rate must rise to 18% for the same goal, that presupposes postponing fund depletion until after 2100.”

He went on to stress, “The government is engaged in typical fear marketing, talking about the excessively distant future to argue that the income replacement rate must be maintained,” adding, “That the fund will be depleted in 2060 means, in other words, that it will be stable for the next 44 years. We also need to consider the fact that the National Pension’s reserve fund is far larger than those of other countries.”

In response, Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, made clear an opposing view: “Raising the income replacement rate to 50% would require sharply raising the overall contribution rate to 20%, so it is not appropriate given Korean realities.”

Research Fellow Yun stressed, “The self-employed pay 100% of their contributions, and if they come to feel the contribution burden heavily, vulnerable groups could drop out of the National Pension,” adding, “Rather than raising the income replacement rate, the right course is to shrink the coverage gaps and lengthen contribution periods so as to raise the effective income replacement rate.”

On the criticism that the nominal income replacement rate is low compared with overseas public funds, he explained, “If foreign pension systems are at the adult stage, Korea’s National Pension is still at the toddler stage,” adding, “Because Korea’s National Pension has a short history since its introduction, contribution periods are not long, so the effective income replacement rate appears low.”

Kim Jin-soo, Dean of the Graduate School of Social Welfare at Yonsei University, criticized, “A structure in which people receive a pension below the minimum cost of living even after more than 20 years of enrollment is a problem,” but added, “It is not right to set aside the National Pension’s various problems and simply call for raising the income replacement rate.”

Professor Kim said, “The most important thing in National Pension reform is the effort toward fiscal stabilization,” adding, “Considering the National Pension’s stability after 2060, the discussion should focus not on raising the income replacement rate but on changing the contribution rate formula that favors high earners and on expanding benefit adequacy for low earners.”

Oh Gun-ho, Co-Chair of the Steering Committee of Welfare State I Make, proposed, “Rather than concentrating on a 50% income replacement rate, we need a way to raise benefit adequacy by raising the Basic Pension on a universal basis.”

He went on to argue, “With the introduction of the Basic Pension, the system has become a dual system of the National Pension and the Basic Pension, so in strengthening benefit adequacy, how this dual system is combined is what matters,” adding, “The Basic Pension should be strengthened to raise the benefit rate of public pensions, that is, of the Basic Pension and the National Pension combined.”

https://news.kbs.co.kr/news/mobile/view/view.do?ncd=3069400

Related Posts