Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(KBS TV) For-and-Against Controversy over the National Pension: “State Guarantee” vs. “Debt Surge” (May 6, 2013)

2026.11.21
(KBS TV) For-and-Against Controversy over the National Pension: “State Guarantee” vs. “Debt Surge” (May 6, 2013)

Anchor

Those of you who faithfully pay into the National Pension every month may be worried that you will not get your pension back later.

When the National Assembly tried to create a legal provision requiring the state to pay benefits even if the fund is depleted, the government came out against it, saying that writing it into law would lower the national credit rating, and a controversy has erupted.

Reporter Nam Seung-woo reports.

Report

Having paid into the National Pension, will they end up unable to receive it because the fund is depleted... The public’s anxiety runs high.

<Interview> Sim Pu-reum (Jingwan-dong, Seoul): “Not getting it back later—that is what makes me most anxious. That is the most...”

<Recording> “I want to be sure to get it, and get a lot...”

People have heard countless times that the state is responsible for paying National Pension benefits, but because there is no legal basis, it is hard to fully believe.

So the National Assembly’s Health and Welfare Committee recently passed, by agreement between the ruling and opposition parties, an amendment bill that specifies a state guarantee of National Pension benefit payment.

But it was immediately stalled.

The government has come out against writing it into law, arguing that “the increase in national debt will lower the credit rating” and that “there is no precedent for a state guarantee anywhere in the world.”

<Interview> Yun Suk-myung (Director of the Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs):

“I think softening it into a provision stating that the state, as a prudent manager, will do its utmost in operating the pension would be an appropriate supplementary measure.”

The opposition and civic organizations are pushing back.

They argue that, since state payment is guaranteed by law for the special occupational pensions—the Government Employees, Military, and Private School Teachers Pensions—the government’s position also violates equity.

In particular, the Government Employees Pension and the Military Pension are already running deficits, and 2 to 3 trillion won in taxes is being put into them every year.

<Interview> Lee Pil-seong (Senior Vice President, National Pension Branch, Korean Confederation of Trade Unions (KCTU)): “Does this mean that citizens who are not civil servants, teachers, or soldiers cannot receive the state’s protection in old age?”

There is also the rebuttal that, contrary to the government’s claim, Germany and Japan, both advanced pension countries, specify in law that state resources are to be put in when pension funds fall short.

Only one day is left in this extraordinary session of the National Assembly.

It looks as though writing a state guarantee of National Pension benefit payment into law will not be easy to get through.

This has been Nam Seung-woo, KBS News.

https://news.kbs.co.kr/news/mobile/view/view.do?ncd=2654564

Attachments

Related Posts