(KBS 1TV) [Sunday Diagnosis Live] What Are the Conditions for Successful Pension Reform? Posted January 1, 2023 (8:49 a.m.)
![(KBS 1TV) [Sunday Diagnosis Live] What Are the Conditions for Successful Pension Reform? Posted January 1, 2023 (8:49 a.m.)](/uploads/editor/2026/11/13ff3d216a664e92b462ead55f919031-Screenshot_20261117_020416_Samsung-Browser.jpg)
■ Host: Cho Hyun-jin
■ Panel: Na Kyung-won, Vice Chair of the Presidential Committee on Ageing Society and Population Policy, Ambassador for Climate and Environment at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and former Floor Leader of the Liberty Korea Party;
Yun Suk-myung, Chief Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, Advisory Committee Member of the National Assembly Special Committee on Pension Reform, and former President of the Korean Pension Association;
Park Sang-joon, Professor at the Faculty of International Research and Education, Waseda University, and former Chief Researcher at the Korea Institute for Industrial Economics and Trade
Let us now move on to the pension issue.
The biggest issue concerning the National Pension is, of course, that the pension fund could soon be depleted. Please show us the National Pension fund outlook. The National Pension financial projection is carried out every five years. It was done in 2018. On that basis, the National Pension is currently projected to turn to deficit in 2042 and to see its fund run dry by 2057. The National Assembly Budget Office and the Korea Economic Research Institute project that it could be depleted even sooner. If things go on like this, those born in 1992, who turned 30 last year, will reach age 65, when they start receiving pension benefits, at a point when the National Pension has run dry and there is nothing left at all. As a result, among the younger generation, there are now even complaints like, “I may not be able to receive it, so why should I pay into the pension?” Committee Member Yun, could you first give us the broad framework of how pension reform should be done?
Yun Suk-myung: Last year.. or was it this year? The Korea Economic Research Institute said that by the time those born in the 1990s, who are now turning 30, reach the point of receiving pensions, the national reserve will be completely gone, so they will not get a pension. This was widely reported in the media in this way and caused a very big stir in our society, and I think we need to approach this from two perspectives. Having no fund reserve does not mean the pension cannot be paid. But the problem in our society all this time has been that a vague optimism has strongly dominated our society: that even if the fund runs out, there is nothing to worry about because we can switch to pay-as-you-go, that is, cover the year’s pension expenditure by collecting that year’s taxes or contributions. So even if the fund is depleted, the pension can be kept going for a considerable period. But what we need to focus on is that the generations who will have to cover the social costs, the pension expenditure, at that time could suffer enormously. We are only interested in the timing. The fund, for example, is now expected to be depleted a little earlier than 2057, but if the fund is depleted in 2057, the contribution needed to cover pension expenditure at that point is, according to the government’s official projection data, 35% of monthly income. If you earn a monthly salary of 1 million won, you have to pay 350,000 won in National Pension contributions. Even if your company pays half, is that not an enormous figure? It would be 175,000 won or so. When I run my own projections.
Cho Hyun-jin: At the moment people pay 9%, right?
Yun Suk-myung: Yes. They pay 9%.
Cho Hyun-jin: And an employee pays 4.5%.
Yun Suk-myung: When we run our projections, it comes out at 38%, higher than the government’s official figure of 35%. So it can go higher if the population structure worsens. So regarding the fund depletion date, what our society needs to put its heads together over is not whether we will receive a pension or not once the fund is depleted, but how much pain the members of our society will have to endure and how severe the intergenerational conflict will become in order to keep this system going at that time. We need to focus on that. What we need to discuss from that perspective is this. On one side, the argument goes: Korea is said to have the highest elderly poverty rate among OECD countries, and the average contribution period for the National Pension will still be only about 27 years even 50 years from now. And what is the benefit rate that we know the National Pension provides? A person earning 1 million won a month who pays 90,000 won in National Pension contributions can receive about 400,000 won after 40 years of coverage. But because the average contribution period is only 27 years, they receive not 400,000 won but only about 250,000 won, so how can anyone live on that? So let us raise pensions instead. Arguments like this have dominated our society for the past five years. And there are aspects of this that our people know very little about. The trap of the 27-year average contribution period is, as with the typical elderly poverty rate, the trap of averages. I do not know whether our host was born around the same year, but if we look at the expected National Pension contribution periods of those born in 1970, classifying them from the lowest income, the first decile, to the highest income, the tenth decile, from 1 to 10, the first income decile shows an expected contribution period of about 19.3 years, under 20 years, even some 50 years from now. In contrast, the high-income group, the tenth decile, is expected to have an expected contribution period of about 34 years. But as I said earlier, the biggest blind spot of our National Pension at present is that the pension eligibility age is already rising to 30 this year while the mandatory contribution age is fixed at 50. As the two of you said earlier, if we encourage older people to work and raise the mandatory contribution age to 64 or 65, then, for example, someone born in 1970 who works at a good company, like our host here, could see their contribution period rise to as much as 40 years. That is how we should look at this problem, in a forward-looking way. But in the pension issue, the current elderly and those close to retirement ask for everything to be solved at this point, while those looking ahead to the future may say, “If things go on like this, are we not just paying contributions to benefit the generation before us and getting nothing, receiving no benefit at all, and, if I may put it a bit strongly, breaking our backs?” From this perspective, then, how should we discuss this system openly, and in which direction should we go in terms of sustainability, benefit adequacy, a kind of universality, and equity? Other countries have already solved all of this. In the direction of working longer and paying a little more, even if receiving a little less. And for the truly poor elderly, a system like our Basic Pension, run by the government with tax money, is focused on the truly poor elderly, choosing and concentrating so as to pay at least a level that allows anyone born a citizen of the Republic of Korea to live a life worthy of a human being. It would be good if we approached it from that perspective, but at present, those who mainly discuss pension reform or overhaul plans are inevitably people who hold vested interests in our society and who hold relatively a great deal of social power. There are aspects in which these people do not say much about how serious our situation is in order to protect their own vested interests, and in which they want to keep this system as it is, at least until they retire, to protect their vested interests. And young people, relatively speaking, still have a somewhat limited understanding of the pension system, their voice in society is very weak, and their numbers are relatively small, so we keep heading in the direction of deterioration. To allow this problem to be discussed from a more objective perspective, I think the policy authorities need to disclose the information we have properly, without addition or subtraction, about what situation we are in. Since it is the first morning, I am not sure whether I should say this or not.
Cho Hyun-jin: The answer is getting a bit too long, so let me just ask one thing for a moment. Looking at the fund outlook, I think this is what people are curious about. The factors with the biggest impact would be population and, the other, the economy, would they not? But the projection says it will be depleted in about 30 years from now. Thirty-some years. Then we do not know how economic growth will go in the meantime, so how can we trust the projection? If we work hard or circumstances improve, might the fund improve too and the situation become more optimistic? Could people not hold such hopes?
Yun Suk-myung: Those who take an optimistic view on those points try very hard to publicize them, but one aspect that makes our pension system very difficult to discuss with the public is that countries such as Germany and Sweden introduced their pension systems more than 100 years ago, so these are generations whose great-great-grandfathers and great-great-grandmothers received pensions, and their pension systems have entered the so-called mature stage. Our pension system is still at a relatively early stage. Many people pay contributions, but not many people receive pensions, so is that not why the elderly poverty rate is high? Even if the National Pension reserves amount to 700 trillion or about 800 trillion won, what the host just described is like the Titanic, which set out on its maiden voyage and sank after hitting an iceberg in the Arctic, is it not? The uncomfortable truth of our pension system is that, although we hold reserves of 700 or 800 trillion won, the amount we have promised to pay to those who joined since we introduced this system in 1988 already exceeds about 2,500 trillion won. What that means is that we are already about 1,500 trillion won short of the money we will have to pay later, so no matter how well the fund is managed, from the point when the fund turns to a deficit until the point when it is depleted, astronomical sums cannot help but flow out each year. So solving this problem by improving the fund’s rate of return is a kind of last line of defense.. it would have an effect, but a fundamental solution is rather difficult.
Cho Hyun-jin: So that limit has long been exceeded.
Na Kyung-won: And the economic growth rate will not rise. This is related to Korea’s low fertility. KDI also announced recently that, because of low fertility and population aging, Korea’s economic growth rate is projected at 0.5% in 2050. So in fact, there is no prospect of things getting better through improved economic growth; in fact, it is very pessimistic. But one thing we can hope for is whether we can really carry out pension reform. On this, according to a recent opinion poll, 88% of the public now say pension reform must be done. And there is also strong public opinion that people would accept pension reform for the sake of our children’s generation. That is over 60%. So in practice, as Committee Member Yun summarized so well earlier, many citizens have finally come to agree on the need for pension reform. But this is only agreement in principle; there has been no agreement on how much pain I personally will have to bear, so I think we must now disclose all the information, share it with the public, and recognize that pension reform can truly be delayed no longer.
Cho Hyun-jin: Looking at the opinion polls, what I also found interesting is that the direction we need to go is, generally speaking, toward paying more and receiving later. But what the public wants is: paying more, okay. But they would like to receive more. That was the most common answer. How did Japan solve this?
Park Sang-joon: Well, the two of you have just said something really important. That is the sharing of information. And our understanding of it. In Japan’s case.. Korea is now said to be entering a super-aged society, and Japan’s major pension reform also took place when it was entering a super-aged society. Until then, the Japanese too had heard that it was difficult, difficult, hard, hard, pessimistic, but they did not know to what extent. They did not know, and then, when they really entered a super-aged society and things really became difficult in 2004, information was disclosed and people came to know. Once people know, and there is then a process of actively publicizing and informing them, when they realize there is nothing to be done, that whichever way they look there is no other way, then they accept it. A process of persuasion is needed along the way, and that happened under the Liberal Democratic Party government in 2004 and again under the Democratic Party government in 2012. And both times it was done without a major dispute between the ruling and opposition parties. So Japan, too, carried out reform only after reaching the point where there was really no ground left to retreat to, and that is exactly where Korea is now. No room to retreat. So now is really the time it must be done. First, about the information, you mentioned pessimistic things just now, and all of these should simply be made known. Make everything known, and say: we are now in this difficult situation, so we really must change now.
Cho Hyun-jin: I see.
Yun Suk-myung: On this point, if I may.
Cho Hyun-jin: Yes. Briefly.
Yun Suk-myung: Recently Vice Minister Lee Ki-il of the Ministry of Health and Welfare, who is in charge of pensions, went to Japan and back with the key pension officials.
Cho Hyun-jin: There were many news articles about it.
Yun Suk-myung: Japan’s pension, the Employees’ Pension, holds the money to pay out 100 years from now. As a result, the benefit amounts people receive have fallen somewhat. So what can embrace all generations and give confidence to those born in 1992, who turn 30 this year, is giving them the assurance that, even if they receive a little less, they will be able to receive a pension from retirement until death; and in that connection, pensions are very complicated. The Japanese case offered many lessons on this as well, and if all meeting proceedings are livestreamed on YouTube, people can become familiar with it. I think we need to benchmark that kind of thing.
Cho Hyun-jin: President Yoon Suk-yeol has also expressed his determination to do it even if it is unpopular and he is criticized for it. Looking at the government’s National Pension reform schedule, please put up the table for a moment. The results of the long-term projection will be announced in March next year. Based on this, a pension reform plan will be announced in October. In early-to-mid 2027—that is, the plan is to produce the complete version of pension reform at the end of this administration or the beginning of the next. One thing I wonder about here is whether it can really be pushed through toward the end of the term. That does worry me somewhat.
Park Sang-joon: That will not work. Koizumi. When Japan carried out its big reform in 2004, saying the pension rate would be raised gradually to more than double over 10 years, and that contributions would rise but what people would receive in future would be cut, that was in the middle of Koizumi’s term. So it was possible because he put it forward in the middle. Producing the complete version at the end of the term means it would be implemented by the next administration, which is far too uncertain.
Cho Hyun-jin: I see. We are almost out of time now, so including low fertility and population aging and then pension reform, since it is New Year’s Day, let us hear a suggestion from each of you, with hope, on how we can make things a little better if we do this, how we can ease our anxieties and live well, and then wrap up today. Committee Member Yun, would you start, with about 30 seconds?
Yun Suk-myung: We are now talking only about receiving less pension, but even if the benefit rate stays at the current level, as many of you said earlier, if older people’s employment is promoted and people work longer, to 65 or 70, the pension amount they can actually receive may become larger even if the benefit rate falls somewhat. That is the hopeful thing I can say on January 1, and to do that, labor market reform is needed and labor market conditions need to change to become more age-friendly.
Cho Hyun-jin: I see. Professor Park.
Park Sang-joon: Since it is the New Year, I would like to say: new wine in new wineskins. And let us have the courage to face the truth.
Cho Hyun-jin: Yes. Vice Chair.
Na Kyung-won: Since we have wrapped up with pension reform, there is no way for me to add much. The reason things did not go well until now is that, in fact, the political sphere and others postponed it because of political interests, the interests of votes. Now, in fact, whether it is policies related to low fertility and population aging or the issue of pension reform, this is not the time to fight. It is no longer the time for conflict and division but for building agreement with one another, and on this matter our circumstances are dangerous enough that we can fully build agreement. So I think that if, over this year, we become a society that builds agreement, we can solve a great deal.
Cho Hyun-jin: We look forward to you playing that role politically as well. Viewers, following today’s discussion of low fertility, population aging, and pension reform, next week we will examine labor reform. Another homework assignment our society can no longer put off. We will invite both labor and management for a fierce debate. Thank you very much to the three of you for appearing on Sunday Diagnosis Live on New Year’s Day.
Happy New Year to you as well.
Cho Hyun-jin: I wish you viewers a happy New Year too. Thank you.
