Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Full Interview Transcript] Yun Suk-myung: “Linking the Basic Pension to the National Pension — Concern That Participation Among Vulnerable Groups Will Weaken” (Posted March 4, 2014, 12:21 a.m.)

2026.11.16

* Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today, This Is Seo Jong-bin>

[Key Remarks]

“The government plan reduces the Basic Pension payment as the National Pension contribution period grows longer”

“Concerned that participation among vulnerable groups may weaken”

“Large gap between the bottom 70% and the bottom 80% of older people aged 65 and over by income”

“The Democratic Party plan has no control mechanism for the rapid growth of the older population”


[Full Transcript]

With the ruling and opposition parties failing in the February session of the National Assembly to agree on the Basic Pension bill, one of the contentious bills, payment of the Basic Pension in July has become impossible, and if the bill is passed in the April session, the Basic Pension looks set to be paid from September at the earliest. Let us connect with an expert to find out what the points of contention between the ruling and opposition parties are and whether there is any compromise. We are joined by Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.

- Hello, Director Yun Suk-myung.
The contentious issues in the Basic Pension bill, which is going through birth pangs, can be summed up as three: the link between the Basic Pension amount and the National Pension contribution period, and then the pension amount and eligibility. First, please briefly explain the plan for linkage with the National Pension proposed by the government and the ruling party.

▶ It reduces the Basic Pension payment as the contribution period grows longer. Specifically, from a National Pension contribution period of 12 years or more, for each additional year—once it goes beyond —, the amount originally to be paid as the Basic Pension, 200,000 won a month, falls to 100,000 won. There has been a lot of controversy over this, but if you think about why the government is trying to introduce such a linkage, even if the linkage is introduced there is little difference in the funding required right now. Between the opposition and the ruling party the difference is only about 300 billion won a year, but in the long term, as National Pension contribution periods lengthen, the funding required can decrease accordingly; because Korea’s older population is increasing so rapidly, the government and the ruling party seem to have drafted the plan with that in mind.

- The opposition opposes the linkage. They worry that with the linkage, National Pension members may give up the pension, or join only for 11 years, the period up to which they can still receive the full Basic Pension. What do you expect?

▶ There has been enormous controversy over this since last year. First, for workplace-based members, that is, people with jobs, the employer deducts National Pension contributions from wages in advance, so it is impossible not to pay even if they wanted to. The problem is that vulnerable groups—low-income self-employed people whose incomes are hard to determine and day laborers with unstable employment—are even now not paying contributions well for one reason or another. In particular, the concern is that if the National Pension contribution period is linked to the Basic Pension, participation among these vulnerable groups may weaken further than it is now. To give a specific example, a person recognized as having an income of 2 million won a month who joins the National Pension for 15 years can receive a pension of about 340,000 won. — joining, they receive about 320,000 won a month. But if a married couple each join for 11 years and receive the Basic Pension, they can receive about 340,000 won, a 20% reduction from 400,000 won. So when the 340,000 won of Basic Pension they can receive without paying contributions is compared with the National Pension they can receive only by joining for 15 or 20 years, there seems to be a concern that vulnerable groups would weigh such considerations all the more.

- The parties have also failed to narrow their differences on the amount of the Basic Pension. The opposition argues that, even if eligibility is reduced to the bottom 80% or 70% by income, everyone should receive the same 200,000 won, whereas the government and the ruling party’s position is that eligibility can be expanded from the original 70% to 75%, but payments should be differentiated by linking them to the National Pension. The standard for the pension amount and eligibility is what is called monthly recognized income. What is this?

▶ Most older people have retired from the labor market and have little earned income, do they not? But they own real estate or financial assets, do they not? So, on the view that these should also be counted as income, recognized income converts owned real estate and financial assets into income by applying an annual interest rate of 5%. Because older people’s minimum housing costs must be deducted, a basic housing cost of 108 million won in large cities and 68 million won in small and medium-sized cities is deducted before conversion into income.

- Then we should look at the distribution of recognized income across the lower income brackets of older people?

▶ There is a big difference between the 2010 and 2013 standards, but first, applying the government’s official 2013 concept of recognized income, among older people aged 65 and over in the lower income brackets, the 26% with the lowest incomes were found to have a recognized income of 0 won. They have nothing at all. By contrast, the bottom 50% have 240,000 won a month, up to 70% have 870,000 won, 75% have 1.3 million won, and up to the bottom 80% have 2.1 million won, so overall, looking at older people aged 65 and over, the gap in monthly recognized income widens sharply beyond the 70% mark.

- Under the Basic Pension Act currently in force, older people aged 65 and over receive 100,000 won each. If eligibility were set at the bottom 75% by income, how many people would be able to receive the Basic Pension?

▶ As of this year, the population aged 65 and over is estimated at about 6.38 million. Applying 75% to this, about 4,785,000 people would receive the Basic Pension.

- Then if 200,000 won were paid uniformly to older people in the bottom 75% by income, how much more funding would be needed than now?

▶ The current Basic Old-Age Pension has some differentiated payments, but to simplify the calculation: paying 100,000 won a month to 70% of older people aged 65 and over costs about 5.36 trillion won a year. Paying 200,000 won a month to 75% of older people would cost about 11 trillion won and 80 billion won a year. That is about 6.12 trillion won more.

- The Democratic Party argues that, rather than changing the law to differentiate payments, changing just one provision of the current law would make it possible to pay a uniform Basic Pension of 200,000 won a month to older people in the bottom 70% by income. That is, the provision setting the pension amount at 5% of the average income of National Pension members (the A value) would be changed to 10%. What problems would that cause?

▶ I am not a legal expert, so this is a little awkward, but in theory, by amending just the Basic Old-Age Pension Act and changing the related enforcement decree and enforcement rules, it would be possible to pay 200,000 won a month under the Basic Old-Age Pension Act rather than as the Basic Pension. The problem, as you know, is that the older population will increase a great deal. As of this year there are 6.38 million older people aged 65 and over, but in 26 years there will be 16.5 million and in 30 years 17.99 million, a rapid increase. In that there is no — cost increase or control mechanism, the government and the ruling party seem to be wrestling with this with considerable concern.

- Could a control mechanism not simply be created?

▶ It would be good if we put our heads together and came up with an appropriate solution.

- In terms of the current fiscal situation, effectiveness, and fairness, the claims of the ruling and opposition parties each have their merits and drawbacks. Is there no compromise or alternative to be found?

▶ For now, the ruling and opposition parties are both very stubborn, which puts me in an awkward position, but what matters is to look at it on the principles of not reducing the incentive to join the National Pension, ensuring that those who faithfully paid contributions do not lose out, and not placing a heavy burden on later generations; from that standpoint, linking to the National Pension contribution period would, in terms of vulnerable groups’ incentive to join, somewhat more —. — If a uniform 200,000 won is paid, the funding required will surge, will it not? Given that the burden would be too great, even if the range of differentiation is not large right now, from a medium- to long-term perspective the ruling and opposition parties should each step back or reconsider a little and work toward a social consensus on gradually widening the range of differentiated payments according to the level of recognized income.

Well, we will stop here for today. Thank you.

That was Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.

ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.

https://news.cpbc.co.kr/article/498950

Attachments

Related Posts