(cpbc Peace Broadcasting) [Interview] Yun Suk-myung: “Raising Health Insurance Contributions Is Unavoidable — the Shortfall Must Be Covered by State Funding” (August 23, 2016)
* Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, interviewed on Peace Broadcasting Radio’s <Open World Today! This Is Yoon Jae-seon>
[Full Transcript]
“Over the past five years, even as the National Health Insurance coffers overflowed, contributions were collected in excess of what was needed, adding to the burden on the public.”
That is what the National Assembly Budget Office pointed out recently.
In addition, criticism has been raised in the National Assembly that the government has been cutting back, year after year, on the state funding for the National Health Insurance that is prescribed by law.
How should we view the controversy over the excessive collection of health insurance contributions and the criticism of reduced state funding? Let us hear an expert’s view.
We are joined by Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
▷ Committee Member Yun, hello!
▶ Yes, hello.
▷ Is it because health insurance contributions go up every year?
The contribution burden people actually feel seems larger. How much have contributions risen over the past five years?
▶ In terms of the figures, it does not look as if they have risen very much, but let me explain.
Because there can be a considerable gap between the figures and what people actually feel.
In 2011 the health insurance contribution rate was 5.64% of monthly pay, that is, of the monthly wage including allowances and the like.
In 2015 it rose to 6.07%, and this year it rose to 6.12%.
So the contribution rate itself went up by 0.48 percentage points, which in percentage terms is about 8.5%.
One might think an 8.5% rise over five years is nothing much, but the reason it can feel different is this: in the National Pension, which is likewise a social insurance scheme, the ceiling on earnings subject to contributions is 4.3 million won a month, however high one’s income.
So a person pays a 9% contribution of 390,600 won on 4.34 million won a month, and if employed, the employer pays half, so the person pays about 195,000 won, right?
In health insurance, however, the ceiling is very high, at 78.1 million won a month. So with the contribution rate now at 6.12%, a person at that level—admittedly a very rare case—would owe about 4,779,700 won in contributions a month.
The share the person pays comes to about 2.39 million won, which is a very large sum.
So even though the absolute increase in the contribution rate does not look large, the amounts to which the ceiling applies are big, and that seems to be why people feel it so keenly.
▷ Perhaps that is why. They say the National Health Insurance coffers are overflowing—what is the actual fiscal situation?
▶ The reason this controversy has arisen recently is that the reserves have been growing a great deal.
In 2010 they were about 959.2 billion won.
That grew to 15.8 trillion won in 2014, and then to 16 trillion 9,800 won as of the end of last year.
▷ So it is approaching about 17 trillion won?
▶ Yes. And at the end of last year the current-year balance was a surplus of 4.2 trillion won.
And as of the end of May this year, money has been piling up to about 17.85 trillion won, so people are asking whether too much is being stockpiled.
Because it amounts to 35.2% of annual benefit expenditure, controversy seems to have arisen over it.
▷ Let us go over this first.
There must be solid grounds when health insurance contributions are set, surely?
On what basis, and how, are they set?
▶ To put it very simply, unlike the National Pension, health insurance is short-term in nature, so after projecting the expected health insurance expenditure for the year, one looks at whether the current contribution level is adequate to cover that cost, and if it is not—if it falls short of covering the projected expenditure—the approach is to ask whether contributions should be raised somewhat.
That is a bit abstract, so to give an example: if a body such as the National Health Insurance Service expects an increase in expenditure such as the medical care benefit costs that hospitals and medical institutions are paid for providing health care services, then from the providers’ standpoint they seem to think a contribution increase is unavoidable.
▷ So that is why it is being said that total health insurance expenditure was set higher than it actually was?
▶ Yes, that is right.
The National Assembly Budget Office is asking whether total health insurance expenditure was set higher than it actually was by overestimating items such as medical care benefit costs.
In particular, looking at 2014, it seems to be raising the issue of whether total health insurance expenditure was overestimated by as much as 3.8 trillion won.
▷ As you said, reserves of 17.85 trillion won have accumulated over the past five years through May. What do you make of the National Assembly Budget Office’s point that contributions were collected in excess of what was needed even though the health insurance coffers are overflowing?
▶ I always try to look at issues from a very objective standpoint.
Many people argue that the money should be used to strengthen benefit coverage, or that too much was collected.
I think this matter needs to be viewed more carefully and from a long-term perspective.
Because, yes, health insurance reserves have increased rapidly over the past five years.
And there is discontent: with the economy already in difficulty, why is the government collecting more and making things harder for the public?
Nevertheless, although we have built up enormous reserves of 18 trillion won, our health insurance expenditure is rising so fast that, if the government subsidy were to disappear, they would all be gone in just two years.
So if conditions are good there is no particular problem, but we live in a very dynamic society, do we not?
To prepare for the various difficult situations that might arise, running the health insurance finances somewhat conservatively, keeping a certain level of reserves, does not look so bad to me.
▷ You mentioned the government subsidy earlier.
By this subsidy you seem to mean the state funding for the National Health Insurance prescribed by law. Criticism has also been raised in the National Assembly that it is being cut back every year. What do you think of this criticism?
▶ Originally, the state subsidy is supposed to cover 20%.
But the problem now, with expected expenditure and the like not being projected properly, is that over five years very small amounts were provided—on average, for example, only 16% to 17% was provided over the nine years from 2007 to 2015.
▷ So it fell short of the statutory funding level?
▶ Cumulatively, about 12.3 trillion won less was provided, so criticism has been raised that this is a very serious problem.
Let me say a word about this. Every year, when the government drafts the budget and tries to estimate the size of the health insurance subsidy, it has to take several factors into account.
In particular, there are three key variables.
Variables such as the rate of contribution increase, the growth rate of the insured, and the growth rate of the insured’s income have to be considered, and what the Budget Office is pointing out is that, of these, only the rate of contribution increase was underestimated—and that point in itself seems hard to deny.
▷ If state funding was about 16%, short of the 20% statutory level, would a contribution increase not be unavoidable?
One could think of it that way too, it seems?
▶ That is a good point. Our older population is growing so rapidly that it is hard to find a precedent anywhere in the world, is it not?
A rapid rise in the older population has very important implications for health insurance expenditure.
Because over a person’s lifetime, some 70 to 80% or more of the health insurance expenditure he or she uses is used in the five years or so before death. And this is a country where the population aged 65 and over is expected to reach 35–40% of the total within the next 50 years, is it not?
So in the future, medical expenditure is likely to be incomparably larger than it is now.
Also, with benefit coverage being expanded and expensive medical equipment being introduced, medical costs seem likely to keep rising.
So no matter how frugally we spend in the future, a contribution increase seems to be unavoidable in some respects.
Another thing to consider is the criticism that the state subsidy should by law be 20% but has been only 16–17%, right?
But under current law the state subsidy is to be paid only through the end of 2017.
▷ So from 2018 there will be no support?
▶ In my view, given the various political circumstances, it seems it would be difficult to cut it off right away.
But we need to look at the finances. If government support were cut off, a deficit of 7.4 trillion won is expected in 2018 alone.
To avoid a current-year deficit in 2018, contributions are projected to need to rise by 17.67%.
So what I would like to say is that the government’s state subsidy is unlikely to vanish entirely, but because health insurance expenditure looks set to grow so quickly and so much, rather than demanding that the state take responsibility for it, the right solution would seem to be an approach in which we work to secure the sustainability of the system itself and the government makes up the shortfall.
▷ Looking at the national fiscal outlook report the government has just released, there was an analysis that the health insurance fund would be exhausted in 2025 if the current system continues, was there not?
Then, seen from one angle, while there is criticism of excessive collection, it looks as if the government has no choice but to raise the contribution rate to prepare for the future. How do you see it, Committee Member Yun?
▶ What I would like to say is that, as with the pension system too, a scheme in which people pay little and receive a lot is hard to sustain over the long term.
According to a big-data analysis recently released by the Ministry of Health and Welfare, on average a household’s health insurance contribution burden is a little under 100,000 won, but the benefits it receives are about 170,000 won, 1.7 times as much.
A system like this seems hard to sustain.
So, as I said a moment ago, because expenditure is expected to rise very steeply from 2017, the government’s effort to secure a certain level of reserves cannot simply be condemned.
Because if we do not raise contributions little by little every year to prepare for the future, the health insurance finances will later deteriorate as we expect, will they not?
Then a very large increase all at once would be unavoidable to cover the deficit. In that sense, if we fail to prepare for hard times while times are good, we may place a greater burden on the public later, so even if it is painful, it seems necessary to build a social consensus on raising contributions gradually.
▷ So you are saying such discussions should begin now to prevent a situation in which contributions are raised sharply all at once five or ten years from now?
▶ Yes.
▷ We have heard an expert’s view on the controversy over the excessive collection of health insurance contributions.
That was Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
▶ Thank you.
ⓒ cpbc News. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.
Attachments
- Screenshot_20261116_235552_Samsung Browser.jpg(358.6 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235621_Samsung Browser.jpg(357.9 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235713_Samsung Browser.jpg(487.1 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235759_Samsung Browser.jpg(354.9 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235821_Samsung Browser.jpg(475.8 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235848_Samsung Browser.jpg(435.9 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235905_Samsung Browser.jpg(464.7 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235934_Samsung Browser.jpg(450.4 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261116_235953_Samsung Browser.jpg(460.3 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261117_000007_Samsung Browser.jpg(451.0 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261117_000030_Samsung Browser.jpg(511.6 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261117_000113_Samsung Browser.jpg(510.9 KB)ViewDownload
- Screenshot_20261117_000131_Samsung Browser.jpg(339.7 KB)ViewDownload
