(Dong-A Ilbo) Basic Pension Pushed Ahead Without Even Statistics on Improvement in Elderly Poverty (October 4, 2013)
■ Critical voices spread among experts

The Basic Pension is a new welfare policy intended to solve the problem of elderly poverty. The idea is to help by expanding the current Basic Old-Age Pension, since few elderly people have prepared for old age through public pensions such as the National Pension or through private pensions.
It has been confirmed, however, that the government has no precise evidence of how much elderly poverty would improve if the Basic Pension were introduced.
○ Effect unknown despite enormous fiscal outlays
In Korea, a person whose recognized income falls short of 830,000 won a month is defined as being in poverty. Poor elderly people (aged 65 and over) of this kind account for 45.1% of the total, about three times the average (13.5%) of 30 member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). This is the basis on which the government has stressed that introducing the Basic Pension will ease the poverty of the current generation of elderly people.
In this regard, an official of the Ministry of Health and Welfare said on the 2nd, “We commissioned the National Pension Research Institute to study how far the elderly poverty rate would fall once the Basic Pension is introduced, but we have not yet obtained accurate data.”
This means the government is introducing a system that requires enormous funding without properly examining its effects.
Professor Jeon Kwang-hee of Chungnam National University (Department of Sociology) pointed out, “Monitoring is fundamental to the effects of any policy. The Basic Pension, which costs trillions of won a year, must be verified even more thoroughly,” adding, “If there are still no simulation data on the introduction of the Basic Pension, they must be produced, even now.”
Many hold the view that introducing the Basic Pension would lower the elderly poverty rate by 5–10%. But there are virtually no scientific projections that government-affiliated research institutes, let alone academia, would accept.
Professor Seok Jae-eun of Hallym University (Department of Social Welfare) said, “It is true that, because accurate samples are hard to find, there is considerable difficulty in projecting the poverty-rate improvement that the introduction of the system would bring.”
Professor Kim Yeon-myeong’s team at Chung-Ang University (Department of Social Welfare), in presenting projections of the Basic Pension and the elderly poverty rate together with the National Action to Set the National Pension Right on the 12th of last month, argued, “Paying the Basic Pension at differentiated rates has less effect on improving elderly poverty than paying 200,000 won uniformly as pledged.”
The government and some in academia raised questions about the simulation method and the concept of the poverty rate.
○ Tailored support measures are more efficient
Meanwhile, voices are growing that the debate across all sectors of society over the Basic Pension is wasteful. The point is that both the “government plan,” which differentiates payments in conjunction with the National Pension, and the “uniform 200,000-won plan” demanded by the opposition and some civic groups fall short as solutions to the problem of elderly poverty.
Mr. A, the head of a public institution, argued, “The Basic Pension is certainly an important issue, but the debate is somewhat excessive,” adding, “Arguing in a situation where the effect on easing the elderly poverty rate is extremely slight whether 100,000 won or 200,000 won is paid is a waste of national strength.”
The statement that the Basic Pension will have little effect on improving the poverty rate even if introduced means that life for Korea’s elderly is that hard. Last year, 3.93 million elderly people aged 65 and over received the Basic Old-Age Pension. They belong to the bottom 70% by income, and about 39% of them (1.52 million) have a monthly recognized income of 0 won. Even if they receive 200,000 won after the Basic Pension is introduced, it will be hard for them to escape poverty.
Against this backdrop, experts emphasized that the side effect of the Basic Pension debate turning political must be guarded against and that, to raise the effectiveness of the Basic Pension system, its effect on improving the poverty rate must first be examined scientifically.
Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, said, “Who receives how much more must not become the center of the debate. The focus should be on how to build a system that actually helps lower the elderly poverty rate through selection and concentration.”
Reporters Yoo Geun-hyeong and Lee Saem-mul [email protected]
