Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(Dong-A Ilbo) Sweden Pays the Basic Pension to 47% of All Elderly People (September 26, 2013)

2026.11.16

(Pension Future Forum comment:

The reason that, from 2003 to 2006,

the Roh Moo-hyun administration’s

bill to stabilize the National Pension’s finances

failed to pass the National Assembly

was the then opposition’s insistence that the Basic Pension be paid to all elderly people,

that is, that a universal

Basic Pension be paid.

The leading experts who backed that insistence

were Professor Kim Yong-ha of Soonchunhyang University and Professor Seok Jae-eun of Hallym University.

Yet, after the Basic Old-Age Pension Act passed in 2007,

a mere six years later,

Professor Kim Yong-ha’s comment in the Dong-A Ilbo article below

that paying the Basic Pension

to the top 30% of the elderly by income

is undesirable

could, it seems, be called a comment that leaves

anyone who knows the situation of that time

dumbfounded.)

[Revising the Basic Pension Pledge]


Most advanced countries differentiate by pension and assets…

Experts: “Eligibility must be narrowed further to ease elderly poverty”

In advanced countries, it is common to pay the Basic Pension at differentiated rates according to pensions, assets, or residence requirements. Cases of paying it 100% to all elderly people are rare.

Professor Kim Yong-ha of the Department of Financial Insurance at Soonchunhyang University said, “Paying the Basic Pension to the well-off top 30% is undesirable. Paying it uniformly when the fiscal situation is poor amounts to giving groups with stable incomes a sum that is not even chewing-gum money.”

The government plan to differentiate the Basic Pension according to the amount of National Pension received resembles the Nordic countries, such as Sweden, Finland, and Norway, which operate their pension systems on the concept of a minimum pension system.

When Sweden reformed its pension system in 1998, it changed it so that the benefit is paid to 47% of all elderly people. If a person’s pension is below the minimum guaranteed level, the government makes up the remaining amount. This differs from Korea, which first pays a basic 100,000 won to everyone, but it is similar in that it guarantees a pension above a certain amount.

Some say that eligibility should be narrowed somewhat further to fit the policy goal of easing elderly poverty, on the grounds that the cutoff for the bottom 70% by income can hardly be regarded as a poverty line.

Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, assessed, “It is desirable to clearly define vulnerable elderly people as the policy target. Considering the cost involved, the policy effect of easing elderly poverty is expected to diminish.”

Criticism of the approach of cutting the Basic Pension according to the amount of National Pension received is also considerable.

Professor Kim Yeon-myeong of the Department of Social Welfare at Chung-Ang University

pointed out, “Even someone who retires in their 50s and becomes self-employed sees the Basic Pension reduced if he or she keeps paying National Pension contributions. Exempted non-payers lose any reason to pay contributions.”

Reporter Lee Saem-mul [email protected]

https://www.donga.com/news/article/all/20130926/57835109/1

Related Posts