(Dong-A Ilbo) [The Pension 3.0 Era] <Part 2> The Future of the National Pension (August 22, 2013)
Survey of 50 Welfare Experts
Raise National Pension Contributions?
The Problem Is the Fertility Rate

Can the National Pension properly serve as a safety net for life in old age? This question arises as it becomes increasingly likely that those eligible for the Basic Pension will be narrowed from all elderly people aged 65 and over to 70% or 80% of them.
When the Dong-A Ilbo asked 50 welfare experts about the sustainability of the National Pension, 82% (41), or roughly eight in 10, said that contributions must be raised. If the current contribution rate of 9% is maintained, the National Pension reserve fund will be depleted in 2060. At that point, a pay-as-you-go system, in which money paid by the young generation is paid directly to the elderly, would have to be introduced, and the contribution rate would have to be raised into the 21% range.
○ Should the current administration raise contributions?
Nearly half of the experts (42%, or 21) called on the Park Geun-hye administration to raise the contribution rate to prevent the collapse of the National Pension.
Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, argued, “It must be raised to 13% right away. If the increase is put off to future generations, the voices of opposition will grow even louder, making it even harder to raise the rate.”
Korea’s National Pension contribution rate is far lower than those of member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). In 2009, the average public pension contribution rate among OECD member countries was 19.6%, more than double Korea’s. Korea’s rate is lower not only than those of Finland (21.6%) and Sweden (18.9%) but also than Japan’s (15.4%).
There is also considerable opinion that a rate increase is necessary but premature. The counterargument is that 47 years remain until the fund is depleted and that, with the economic slump dragging on, citizens and businesses lack the capacity to bear higher contributions. The government is also reluctant.
Lee Yong-ha, Senior Researcher at the National Pension Research Institute, expressed concern: “If the rate is raised in the current situation, groups who are not enrolled in the National Pension even now will remain unable to escape the coverage gaps.”
At the public hearing of the National Pension System Development Committee held on the 21st as well, the view that the rate should be raised in stages starting before 2017 clashed evenly with the claim that an increase would be difficult until 2043.
Some even claim that the “2060 crisis,” when the reserve fund reaches zero, has been exaggerated. As evidence, they point out that the public pensions of advanced countries such as the United States and the United Kingdom have no reserve funds and instead operate well on a pay-as-you-go basis.
○ Is raising the fertility rate the ultimate solution?
Some say that the reserve fund is too large relative to the size of Korea’s economy, so the very prediction of depletion is nonsense.
This year the reserve fund is about 417 trillion won, roughly 31.1% of gross domestic product (GDP). As a share of GDP, this is among the highest in the world. By 2035 the ratio will approach 50%. Cases worldwide in which a fund exceeds 30% of GDP are hard to find.
Professor Kim Yeon-myeong of Chung-Ang University (Department of Social Welfare) said, “Because the reserve fund is so enormous, there are considerable side effects, such as the stock market fluctuating depending on the direction of its investments,”
“and questioned, “When the whole world knows the open trade secret that Korea will sell off, after 2043, the stocks and assets it has invested in with the reserve fund in order to pay pensions, will it be able to sell them at a fair price?”
Some experts call for a focus on raising the fertility rate in order to ultimately solve the problems of the National Pension.
Professor Kim Yong-ha of Soonchunhyang University (Department of Financial Insurance) pointed out, “To stabilize future pension spending, a variety of policy tools must be mobilized. Unless the current trend of low fertility is reversed, no policy will be effective.”
Reporters Yoo Geun-hyeong and Lee Saem-mul [email protected]
