(Dong-A Ilbo) The Pension 3.0 Era] <Part 1> Desirable Ways to Operate the Basic Pension (August 21, 2013)
Survey of 50 Welfare Experts
“The Pledge of a Uniform Basic Pension Payment Must Be Revised”
70%… The Criterion for Differentiated Payment?
Income vs. the National Pension: Evenly Split

《 Seven in 10 welfare experts said that, even if it means retreating from President Park Geun-hye’s pledge, the Basic Pension of 200,000 won should not be paid identically to all eligible recipients. Their argument is that, because the funding is hard to secure, the pledge must be revised in order to build a sustainable system. The Dong-A Ilbo asked 50 welfare experts for their views on the desirable direction of Korea’s pension systems, including the Basic Pension that President Park promised during the presidential election and the National Pension. 》
Of these, 70% (35) answered that “differentiated payment is desirable even if the Basic Pension pledge is scaled back.” That is, the maximum payment would be set at 200,000 won, and the amount would be reduced according to certain criteria.
Opinions were evenly divided on what criterion should be used to differentiate payments. Thirty-six percent (18) answered that those with higher incomes should be paid less Basic Pension. Thirty-four percent (17) said that the more National Pension a person receives, the less Basic Pension that person should be given. Experts who said 200,000 won should be paid uniformly accounted for 24% (12).
Earlier, the National Happiness Pension Committee (the Happiness Committee) recommended narrowing the elderly eligible for the Basic Pension to the bottom 70% or 80% by income. To the Ministry of Health and Welfare, however, it presented multiple options: a uniform payment of 200,000 won and differentiated payment. On this basis, the government will announce its final plan as early as the end of August.
○ If income is the criterion
If income is made the criterion for paying the Basic Pension, how accurately the government can ascertain the incomes of the elderly becomes a crucial issue, because the items recognized as income are diverse, including earned income, business income, property, and public transfer income.
Unlike salaried workers, whose incomes are fully visible, the incomes of self-employed elderly people are based on what they report, so it is difficult for the government to ascertain them accurately. The same goes for retirees’ property. The difficulty of ascertaining income is a problem that also arose when contributions were set for regional (self-employed) subscribers to the National Pension and the National Health Insurance.
Professor Kim Yong-ha of Soonchunhyang University (Department of Financial Insurance) expressed concern: “If the Basic Pension is paid on the basis of income, the elderly are highly likely to avoid saving. There may also be cases of income being hidden through various expedients.”
Some also point out that using income as the criterion disadvantages long-term National Pension contributors. Citizens who have been enrolled in the National Pension for a long time may have held relatively stable jobs and accumulated considerable assets.
Professor Kim Yeon-myeong of Chung-Ang University (Department of Social Welfare) pointed out, “For elderly people who have been enrolled in the National Pension for a long time, a large part of their income consists of pension receipts. Because this income is high, they end up not properly receiving the Basic Pension.”
○ If the National Pension amount is the criterion
This is the option the Ministry of Health and Welfare is most seriously considering, because pension amounts are easy to ascertain and it requires the least funding.
The problem is that elderly people who did not join the National Pension would receive the maximum amount (200,000 won). Conversely, those with more than 20 years of National Pension membership might not receive a single won of Basic Pension. As of last year, only 195,513 National Pension beneficiaries had been enrolled for 20 years or more, but their number will rise sharply after 2020.
Long-term delinquent National Pension contributors (some 1,253,000 people) are also quite likely to hold out and keep not paying contributions. In fact, between February and June this year, 39,205 voluntary National Pension members withdrew, in the hope that they could stop paying National Pension contributions and rely on the Basic Pension instead.
Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, predicted, “If the National Pension is used as the criterion, vulnerable and low-income groups are highly likely to leave the National Pension en masse.”
Deepening generational conflict is another worrying point. Most of those now in their 20s to 40s will have more than 20 years of National Pension membership by the time they retire, and so may be excluded from eligibility for the Basic Pension.
Professor Kim Yeon-myeong said, “It is as if they prop up the Basic Pension while young, only to end up not receiving it once they become old.”
○ If 200,000 won is paid uniformly
For now, the differentiated payment plan is the frontrunner, but the possibility remains that things could swing abruptly toward the uniform 200,000-won plan during National Assembly deliberations. The opposition is strongly advocating it.
But both the ruling party and the government are uneasy that it would require far more funding than the differentiated payment plan. As of 2020, the uniform 200,000-won plan would require about 1.4 times as much funding as the plan differentiated by National Pension amount. This gap widens sharply, to about twofold in 2040 and about threefold in 2060.
Some argue that the framework of old-age pensions should be redesigned, tightening the eligibility criteria while increasing the amount instead.
Professor Kim Soo-wan of Kangnam University (Department of Social Welfare) argued, “With limited funding, targeting 70% of the elderly inevitably reduces the amount of support. Eligibility should be narrowed to the bottom 50% or below, who are struggling to make ends meet, while the payment amount is increased.”
