Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(JoongAng Ilbo) [Issue Tracking] Pension Reform Talks Involving the Government Employees’ Union — Recurring “Memories of Deterioration” (November 22, 2014)

2026.11.15

Government Employees Pension reform has struck a reef called the “social consultative body.” With the Saenuri Party holding to its position that it cannot accept one, against the New Politics Democratic Union and the government employees’ union, which are calling for a consensus body to be formed, discussion of the reform plan has not moved a single step forward. Kim Hyun-sook, floor spokesperson of the Saenuri Party, said on the 21st, “For the government employees’ union, a stakeholder, to take part in the work of amending the Government Employees Pension Act infringes on legislative authority,” adding, “Demanding that a social consensus body be formed is a ploy to scuttle reform.” By contrast, Representative Kang Ki-jung, chair of the New Politics Democratic Union’s Public Pension Development Task Force, argues, “Just looking at the cases of Germany and Austria and the 2009 Government Employees Pension reform, there are ample grounds for a social consensus body.”

 The ruling party’s reluctance to bring the government employees’ union, a stakeholder, into the discussion body stems from “bad memories” of the past. The Lee Myung-bak administration’s 2009 attempt at Government Employees Pension reform is the prime example. In 2006 the government formed a joint public-private Government Employees Pension System Development Committee (the Development Committee) and drew up a reform plan. But it ran into opposition from the government employees’ union and had to abandon the effort midway without even submitting a bill. A second Development Committee, with the government employees’ union taking part, was then formed again in 2008. The result was a revised plan that retreated sharply from the original reform plan. The Development Committee raised the member’s own share of the contribution rate from 5.525% to 7% of taxable income, but this fell short of the first reform plan (8.5%). It also rolled back the pension accrual rate, which has the greatest effect on determining pension amounts, to 1.9% from the reform plan’s 1.7% for existing civil servants and 1.25% for new civil servants. As a result, the pension system had to go back on the operating table only five years later. A pension expert who took part in the second Development Committee at the time said, “Stakeholders, including the government employees’ union, made up a majority of the Development Committee,” adding, “Even when we put forward neutral opinions, we were only attacked and they were not accepted.”

 In the 2000 reform under the Kim Dae-jung administration, too, the government employees’ union took advantage of a National Assembly in which the opposition held the majority to secure an opposition-sponsored bill that lowered the contribution increase from the government plan and raised the retirement allowance. In the end, a revised plan that split the difference between the government and opposition plans passed the National Assembly. The provision under which the government covers Government Employees Pension deficits with taxes was also included at this time.

 In 2003, under the Roh Moo-hyun administration, the government employees’ union persuaded ruling and opposition lawmakers to pass a “deterioration plan” expanding Government Employees Pension benefits. This was because civil servants’ pay had risen sharply since 2001 under a policy of bringing civil service pay up to realistic levels. Accordingly, unlike the existing plan, which adjusted pension amounts by the inflation rate, it provided that the rate of change in pay would be reflected when the gap between the inflation rate and the rate of change in pay was large.

 The government employees’ union now insists that a social consultative body be formed to discuss public pensions as a whole. But citing three past failures, the Saenuri Party argues that such a body will become an obstacle to reform.

Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, said,

“The National Pension was reformed so that it will not run a deficit until 2060, but the Government Employees Pension runs a deficit every year, so it is inappropriate to discuss the two together.”

 ◆Apology for the confusion over the Nuri Curriculum budget=Saenuri Party Floor Leader Lee Wan-koo said at a joint meeting of the party’s National Assembly standing committee chairs and secretaries on the 21st, regarding the previous day’s confusion over the Nuri Curriculum budget, “As floor leader, I apologize that the handling process was not smooth.” Senior Deputy Floor Leader Kim Jae-won claimed, “Not knowing the details, when the report came out, I had no choice but to say ‘it is not true,’” adding, “We were taken in by the opposition’s media maneuvering.”

Reporter Cheon Kwon-pil [Source: JoongAng Ilbo]

https://www.joongang.co.kr/article/16495359

Related Posts