(Dong-A Ilbo) [Premium Report] Government Employees Pension Reform’s Effect a One-Year “Flash in the Pan” — 2 Trillion Won a Year Plugged from the National Treasury (2014-02-12)
Two Pensions, Two Retirements <Part 1>
The State of the Government Employees Pension and Reform Options

The State of the Government Employees Pension and Reform Options
《 The government has decided to draw “the sword of reform” against the Government Employees Pension. The Ministry of Security and Public Administration plans to form a Government Employees Pension System Development Committee (tentative name) in the first half of this year (January–June) and to draw up an improvement plan. Will the Park Geun-hye administration, which loudly proclaims “the normalization of the abnormal,” actually succeed in reform? In a series, we analyze in depth what is wrong with the Government Employees Pension and how it should be changed. 》
Demands to reform the Government Employees Pension burst forth in 2003. On the projection that the National Pension Fund would be depleted in 2047, a second National Pension reform of the “pay more, receive less” kind was carried out, and there were loud voices saying the Government Employees Pension should be fixed at the same time. The Government Employees Pension Act was amended in 2009. But the prevailing reaction outside the civil service is that little has changed.
○ Civil servants earn more over a lifetime
In a paper titled “Comparing the National Pension and the Special Occupational Pension Schemes from a Lifetime-Income Perspective,” written in 2008 when he was a professor at Kwandong University, Professor Kim Sang-ho of the Gwangju Institute of Science and Technology assumed total pay of 1.84258 billion won for a civil servant who started at Grade 7 in 1988 and 2.09264 billion won for the average worker at a mid-sized company with 100 or more employees. The money paid in as contributions was 182.38 million won for the civil servant and 159.17 million won for the worker.
After retirement, the pension the civil servant receives comes to 587.96 million won, assuming a life to age 80, while the worker receives only 232.29 million won. Including pay, the civil servant receives 2.43054 billion won and the worker 2.32493 billion won. If the survivor’s pension paid to the spouse after one’s own death is also included, the gap grows much larger still.
Professor Kim said, “Civil servants appointed in 1988 were found to have a lifetime total income, including the survivor’s pension, about 2.0% higher than that of workers.” This is based on 1988, when civil servants’ pay was 75.8% of that of mid-sized company workers. Applying the same calculation to 2008, when civil servants’ pay had risen to 89.0% of the mid-sized company level, the gap in lifetime total income widens to 7.6%. The argument that “civil servants’ pay is low, so they should at least receive a larger pension” is now less persuasive.
Job security is a separate issue. Professor Park Jung-soo of Ewha Womans University (Department of Public Administration) said, “Considering that civil servants are under almost no stress from dismissal or early retirement, the gap between civil servants and ordinary company employees would be even larger.”
○ Civil servants receiving large pensions are, in effect, propped up by ordinary citizens
Civil servants pay 14% of their pay as pension contributions while in service. Ordinary workers, by contrast, pay 9%. Of course, for civil servants the government pays half of the 14%, and for ordinary workers the company pays half of the 9%.
But the Government Employees Pension cannot currently be sustained without treasury subsidies. According to the Government Employees Pension Service, in 2009 the government covered a Government Employees Pension deficit of 1.9748 trillion won. In 2010, right after the Government Employees Pension was amended, this fell to 1.3071 trillion won, but it has since risen again, reaching 1.8953 trillion won last year. The Service explained, “Had the Government Employees Pension Act not been amended, this year’s treasury subsidy would have exceeded 4 trillion won,” adding, “The amendment has had a savings effect of 52%.”
But the subsidy-saving effect appears to have already run its course. The Service projected that the subsidy would be 2.4854 trillion won in 2014 and would grow to 6.2518 trillion won by 2020. The prevailing expectation is that the government will in fact have to contribute even more than this projection.
The reason the subsidy keeps growing is that, even after the amendment, the Government Employees Pension retains a framework of collecting less and paying more. Since the amendment, the Government Employees Pension contribution rate has been 14% and the annual benefit accrual rate (the rate by which the pension amount rises with each year of service) about 1.9%. This is not much different from the pre-amendment contribution rate of 11% and annual accrual rate of 2.1%. The income replacement rate, too, is 62.7%, 12.7 percentage points higher than Japan’s 50%. Yet Japan’s contribution burden is 18%, actually 4 percentage points higher.
In the end, ordinary citizens who receive small pensions are, in effect, propping up civil servants who receive large ones.
○ Young civil servants “seething”
The new generation who entered the civil service after January 2010 have many complaints about the Government Employees Pension Act as amended in 2009. The amended provisions apply to the new generation immediately, whereas the older generation enjoys no small number of arrangements that protect its vested interests.
Under the 2009 amendment, the new generation is subject to an income replacement rate of 62.7%. The older generation, however, is credited with the pre-amendment income replacement rate of 76.0% for contributions paid before 2010.
The fact that, from 2010, the pension eligibility age was pushed back to 65 and the survivor’s pension rate cut by 10 percentage points is also cited as a factor fueling the discontent of new-generation civil servants. Someone who entered public service in December 2009 can receive the pension for up to five years longer than someone appointed the following January—despite a difference of only a month.
Extending the pension calculation period from the last three years before retirement to the entire period of service is another provision that applies only to the new generation. The government argues that using the entire period of service as the basis includes periods of lower pay and therefore has the effect of reducing the pension amount. This is true for the younger generation who became civil servants after 2010. The generation that became civil servants before then, however, is subject to this provision only in part.
Suppose, for example, that a civil servant worked 25 years through 2009 and 10 years from 2010, for a total of 35 years of service. For the period from 2010 on, this civil servant’s pension amount is set on the 10-year average. But for the 25 years before 2010, the pension amount is set on the basis of 2007–2009, when the monthly salary was high. Given this kind of arithmetic, new-generation civil servants cannot help but be deeply dissatisfied.
▼ “Match the National Pension’s level or merge with it” ▼
Government Employees Pension benefits rise 1.9% a year
Twice the National Pension... imbalance widening
Advocates of Government Employees Pension reform agree that cutting pension amounts is unavoidable in order to secure fiscal soundness and achieve equity with the National Pension. The point is that the “low-contribution, high-benefit” structure must be broken.
At present, the Government Employees Pension replaces 62.7% of average income over the period of service once 33 years have been fully paid. Its annual benefit accrual rate is 1.9%, nearly twice the National Pension’s 1%.
Reform advocates also argue that, in the long run, the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension should be merged. That is, the Government Employees Pension’s annual benefit accrual rate should be lowered in stages to the National Pension’s level of 1%. They also point out that the contribution rate must be raised to about twice the current 14% to secure fiscal soundness while reducing tax support. Last year Japan succeeded in merging the Employees’ Pension Insurance (Japan’s national pension) and the Mutual Aid Pension for public employees (Japan’s government employees pension). Representative Lee Man-woo of the Saenuri Party stressed, “The Government Employees Pension is more generous than the National Pension in every respect. It should be adjusted in the direction of merging the two as quickly as possible.”
Some also argue that the current framework should be kept while pension amounts are partly reduced. The idea is to reduce the sense of relative deprivation among National Pension contributors while still recognizing the special nature of the civil service’s work. They want account to be taken of the fact that civil servants’ retirement allowance is only about 50% of the severance pay at ordinary companies. They hold that it would be reasonable to reduce the Government Employees Pension’s annual benefit accrual rate to about 1.5–1.75%.
Professor Kim Yong-ha of Soonchunhyang University (Department of Finance and Insurance) said, “The fact that civil servants’ severance pay is lower than that of ordinary workers must be taken into account,” adding, “Even if reform goes ahead, civil servants’ self-respect must at least be preserved.” Meanwhile, there are also calls to lower the Government Employees Pension’s income ceiling (7.83 million won a month), which strongly favors long-term members, to the level of the National Pension (3.98 million won a month).
Above all, the prevailing public opinion is that the discussion of Government Employees Pension reform should be led by third parties rather than by civil servants, the stakeholders themselves. One cannot expect the cat to bell its own neck. Professor Seok Jae-eun of Hallym University (Department of Social Welfare) stressed, “It is true that the public-private committees for Government Employees Pension reform have so far concentrated on fending off the logic of reform,” adding, “What is needed now is a committee whose composition can check the influence of bureaucrats.”
<Special Reporting Team>
▽Team Leader Ha Jong-dae, Deputy Managing Editor
▽Lee Jin, International News Editor; Reporters Lee Seong-ho (Society), Yoo Geun-hyung (Policy and Society), Lee Won-ju (Economy), Kim Kyung-je and Byun Young-wook (Photo)
▽International News Desk Correspondents Park Hyung-jun, Jeon Seung-hoon, and Shin Seok-ho
▽Newsroom Manager Kim Ah-yeon
▽ Advisers (in Korean alphabetical order)
Professor Kim Yong-ha, Soonchunhyang University
Professor Park Jung-soo, Ewha Womans University
Bae Jun-ho, Dean of the Graduate School, Hanshin University
Professor Seok Jae-eun, Hallym University
Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (KIHASA)
https://www.donga.com/news/Society/article/all/20140120/60268475/1
