(YTN Radio) Has Government Employees Pension Reform Reached the Home Stretch? (April 29, 2015)

Has Government Employees Pension Reform Reached the Home Stretch?
-Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs
[YTN Radio “Choi Young-il’s News! Head-On”]
■ Broadcast: FM 94.5 (18:10–20:00)
■ Air date: Wednesday, April 29, 2015, 6:00 p.m.
■ Host: Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs
◇Anchor Choi Young-il, current affairs commentator (hereafter Choi Young-il):
Government Employees Pension reform began last September. But it seems there is still a long way to go. In the political sphere, the position that an agreement has almost been reached keeps being repeated. Yet some point out that a reform plan at the level now being reported cannot be called reform. He is a pension expert. We will talk in detail with Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Research Fellow Yun, are you with us?
◆Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (hereafter Yun Suk-myung): Yes. Hello.
◇Choi Young-il: Yes, hello. It is already the ninth month since this Government Employees Pension reform began. Should we see it as having been expected from the start that it would not be easy?
◆Yun Suk-myung: Yes. We could foresee that possibility from the start of the discussions. We have already reformed the Government Employees Pension three times, with great difficulty each time, and even after the reforms there was much controversy over their strength, was there not? This time, too, on the need for and urgency of Government Employees Pension reform, the gap in views between the government and ruling party pushing the reform, the opposition party expressing some opposition against it, and the civil-servant stakeholders is so wide that producing a reform plan—an agreed plan—does not look easy.
◇Choi Young-il: To the public, this will look like a truly chaotic fight. The word coming out of the political sphere is that it seems to have reached the home stretch, that 99% agreement has been reached—such positions keep being repeated. Turned around, one could see this as dragging the issue out without a decision. That criticism is being raised. How do you see it?
◆Yun Suk-myung: Making a decision itself does not seem difficult to me. Why does one side claim that 99% agreement has been reached while the other says agreement has not yet got that far? The point seems to be how strong to set the agreement. For now, discussions are under way at the National Assembly level and in the working-level body. There, it seems views have converged to some extent. It seems they have at least agreed on a certain range—how high to set the contribution burden and how high to set the benefit accrual rate. But the government, watching this, takes the position that the level of agreement under discussion is too weak—asking why we would have come this far through so much controversy just to do that much—and calls for a stronger reform. So it seems there is one last hurdle left in reaching an agreement.
◇Choi Young-il: As you said, the plan now converging—as far as has been settled—I heard the latest is that the civil-servant contribution rate and the government contribution rate have been set at 9.5% each, about 19% in total. And then the accrual rate that civil servants receive—probably the most sensitive point for the government employees’ union—goes from the current 1.9% either to the 1.7% the government and ruling party insist on or to the 1.79% the civil-servant groups insist on. I hear that this choice remains. How should we view it?
◆Yun Suk-myung: General listeners will see that the difference between 1.7% and 1.79% is only 0.09%, and think, is that not a small difference? But looking at the positions on Government Employees Pension reform, the government and ruling party’s position is that for there to be a genuine reform effect, the so-called accrual rate—the 1.7 or 1.79 we mentioned—needs to be cut more. Conversely, the opposition party and civil-servant groups say, we may bear somewhat more in contributions, but at least do not cut the accrual rate, or if you must, cut it the least. There is this decisive difference of opinion. So even at the last moment there is a gap of about 0.09 percentage points. It may not seem a big gap, but even this one difference amounts to about 1.5 percentage points when converted into contributions—that is how big a difference the accrual rate makes. So much discussion is needed on this, and although reform is urgent, for a reasonably meaningful reform, it seems to us as well that the accrual rate must be touched to an appropriate level. So it seems the government and ruling party cannot easily agree.
◇Choi Young-il: You said the government employees’ union is adamant that it can accept paying more but wants the accrual rate kept as it is, or cut to a minimum, and so the 1.79% plan came out. Now it is only 0.09. Even if we see it as about 0.1, the difference looks slight, but in fact the conflict is big. But originally, I recall, the Saenuri Party put forward a plan to set the civil-servant contribution rate at 10% and lower the accrual rate to 1.25%. The government’s baseline plan was 1.5%, so compared with then, the gap has narrowed considerably, has it not?
◆Yun Suk-myung: The gap has narrowed. In the original Saenuri Party plan, the civil-servant contribution rate of 10% and the government contribution rate of 10% together made a burden of 20%. What is being discussed now is 9.5% each, so 19 percentage points—only a 1% difference in the contribution rate. But the accrual rate has gone up from 1.25% to 1.5% and now 1.7% or more, has it not? There is a difference there. What the Saenuri Party originally proposed came with a supplementary clause: in exchange for lowering it to 1.25, severance pay, which is only 39% of the private sector’s, would be raised to 100%. But what is being discussed now proceeds on the assumption that severance pay will be kept, as now, at only 39% of the private sector’s. On that basis, the government said it would present 1.5%, up from 1.25%, as its last line of defense, calling it the government’s baseline proposal, did it not? Yet even from there, setting it at 1.7 means a rise of 0.2 percentage points, and under the union’s plan 0.29 percentage points, does it not? So one can say the fiscal instability factors have grown by that much. Another point is that, depending on what rate is applied in converting into pensions the part of severance pay that is smaller than in the private sector, the fiscal instability factors could grow even larger. Taking all of this together, since it has risen by at least 0.2 percentage points even compared with the 1.5 percentage points the government originally set as its last line of defense, judging objectively, one can assess that the strength of fiscal stabilization has become too weak.
◇Choi Young-il: Yes. That is exactly the point you just raised. Was not the most fundamental reason for undertaking Government Employees Pension reform, in the end, largely fiscal savings? Then how far do you think the accrual rate must come down for fiscal savings to appear?
◆Yun Suk-myung: Yes. We have reformed the Government Employees Pension three times so far, and each time we raised contributions a little while cutting the accrual rate minimally. In that case there is a short-term fiscal saving, but unless the accrual rate is substantially touched, the long-term fiscal saving falls off sharply. Since there is no experience to draw on in Korea’s case, there is much controversy, is there not? So, to take foreign cases as examples: because we now have the severance pay component, another 0.2 percentage points must be added to the accrual rate we are talking about before it can be compared with other countries. Germany has no severance pay, so its accrual rate, including severance pay, is about 1.79%. If we set ours at 1.7, adding 0.1 brings it to 1.9 or more. So it is higher even than Germany, which is considered very generous worldwide. Next, Japan’s accrual rate is currently 1.57%. But in the most optimistic scenario it falls to 1.28, and in a pessimistic scenario like ours it falls to 1.05. Seeing this, even if we hold it at 1.5, it is hard to be optimistic about the future of our Government Employees Pension finances. From that perspective, as I see it, it must come down to at least about 1.6 before we can judge that fiscal soundness has been secured to some extent from a long-term perspective.
◇Choi Young-il: I see. Since we are talking only in numbers, listeners may find this quite difficult. In any case, we are watching with regret to see whether a final agreement will be reached on the last point, the accrual rate, or whether talks will collapse. The opposition party says that if an agreement among the parties concerned proves difficult, the National Assembly could decide the accrual rate and contribution rate. Briefly—is this possible?
◆Yun Suk-myung: It does not seem impossible to reach an agreement. But in the present case, listeners will be very confused about the accrual rate, which is why I explained it in concrete terms. If you place great emphasis on agreement, the strength may end up weak, may it not? So while reaching an agreement quickly is important, because we are carrying out reform after a great deal of controversy, it seems necessary to reach an agreement while reforming to the extent of lowering the accrual rate to some degree—to a level the public can understand—even if it is more painful.
◇Choi Young-il: I see. Thank you for speaking with us today.
◆Yun Suk-myung: Thank you.
◇Choi Young-il: That was Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
[Copyright (c) YTN. Unauthorized reproduction, redistribution, and use as AI data prohibited.]
https://m.ytn.co.kr/news_view.php?s_mcd=0101&key=201504292108260666&pos=#return
