(Yeongnam Ilbo) “If It Goes Like This, the Government Employees Pension Will Have to Be Reformed Again Within a Few Years” (May 3, 2015)
Experts react to the Government Employees Pension Act amendment…
“Abruptly dragging in the National Pension was inappropriate”
Pension experts reacted negatively on the 3rd to the Government Employees Pension reform plan that passed the plenary meeting of the National Assembly’s Special Committee on Government Employees Pension Reform, criticizing both its direction and its strength.
On the strength of the reform, criticism was raised that “at this rate, reform discussions will have to start again before long,” and some voices also pointed out that “the first button of structural reform has been fastened wrong,” saying the cut in the pension accrual rate is small and the period over which it is cut is long.
Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (KIHASA), pointed out on the 3rd, “It was decided to have people pay 30% more in contributions and receive 10% less in pension benefits, but rather than raising the contribution rate for a short-lived effect, it should have gone the way of cutting benefits more for sustainability to be secured,” adding, “Even if the burden was raised a little, benefits should have been cut much more.”
Yun went on to criticize, “Deciding to cut the benefit accrual rate by 0.2 percentage points over 20 years, and to raise the pensionable age gradually to 65 over 10 years, also has the problem of letting certain age groups slip past the reform,” adding, “In the 2009 Government Employees Pension reform, too, the pensions of those with 10 or more years of service were not cut, and this time as well, those from their mid-40s to their 50s will benefit compared with other age groups.”
Kim Jin-soo, Dean of the Graduate School of Social Welfare at Yonsei University, likewise expressed a negative view: “It is regrettable that the reform part seems to have retreated at the last minute. At this rate, (reform discussions) will have to be held again within five to ten years.”
Professor Kim pointed out, “On the fiscal side, apart from the part about ‘receiving more and giving less,’ it is as if virtually nothing was touched,” adding, “Nothing was done about the way pensions are paid even to those who, after retiring, work at affiliated agencies, about contributions by those with more than 30 years of service, or about the retirement allowance.”
Kim Dong-won, Visiting Professor (Department of Economics) at Korea University, criticized it sharply: “The Government Employees Pension is the first structural reform, and if the first button is fastened wrong like this, the remaining structural reforms cannot possibly go properly.”
Kim pointed out, “With the current reform plan, even if reform is carried out, it will not substantially help the state’s finances,” adding, “I understand that pension payments cannot be cut much because civil servants’ backlash is fierce, but lowering the Government Employees Pension accrual rate over 20 years takes far too long.”
There was also the view that the plan, while not satisfactory, is a realistic reform plan.
Kim Jung-sik, Professor (Department of Economics) at Yonsei University, assessed, “I think it is desirable to go through a gradual adjustment period, such as lowering the accrual rate over 20 years and raising the contribution rate over five years.”
Kim added, “Lowering the pension accrual rate meets fierce resistance, while raising the contribution rate meets relatively less, so it seems the agreement was reached in this direction,” and said, “For the government, it is not a satisfactory result, but it is a compromise reached in terms of feasibility.”
Experts were particularly unanimous that raising the income replacement rate of the National Pension is “inappropriate.”
Their point is that it was not right, at a meeting to discuss the Government Employees Pension, to drag in the National Pension and even present a specific figure for adjusting its income replacement rate.
Along with the Government Employees Pension reform plan, the ruling and opposition parties agreed, in the name of strengthening public pensions, to raise the National Pension’s nominal income replacement rate (the ratio of the pension paid to average income) from the current 40% to 50%.
Research Fellow Yun of KIHASA criticized, “Setting the National Pension’s income replacement rate at 40% was not a decision of a moment but an agreement reached after four years of intense discussion among stakeholders, experts, and members of the National Assembly,” adding, “When told to fix the pension of 1.07 million civil servants, suddenly dragging in the National Pension of 21 million people is inappropriate.”
Professor Kim Dong-won of Korea University also said, “Raising the National Pension’s nominal income replacement rate is a measure that does not help the state’s finances,” and Professor Kim Jung-sik of Yonsei University likewise criticized, “Merely diverting the money left over into raising the National Pension’s nominal income replacement rate will not solve the National Pension’s fiscal problems.” Yonhap News
Yeongnam Ilbo (www.yeongnam.com), unauthorized reproduction, collection, and redistribution prohibited
https://m.yeongnam.com/view.php?key=20150503.990011944130377
