(Nocut News) Pension Reform: “How Dire Must It Be” vs. “Branding Us as Tax Thieves” (September 19, 2014)
<Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs>
- 53 trillion won in taxes will go into the Government Employees Pension over 10 years
- The 54-year-old Government Employees Pension has many stakeholders, making reform difficult
- Raising it from 14% to 20% over 10 years through 2026 would make it the same as the National Pension in 2016
- From 2016, new civil servants to bear contributions in the same way as under the National Pension
- Introduce even an automatic adjustment mechanism that cuts pensions automatically when capacity declines, as Finland and others have
<Lee Chung-jae, Chairman, Korean Government Employees’ Union>
- Serious anxiety and turmoil in the civil service, to the point of an early-retirement rush
- Great anger at civil servants being branded tax thieves and shameless criminals
- Trust in the promise that pensions would compensate for low pay and disadvantages has also collapsed
- Closed-door discussions, held without consulting civil servants; unacceptable
- Pay and severance must be discussed together from a lifetime-income perspective

[CBS Radio “Current Affairs Jockey with Jung Kwan-yong”]
■ Broadcast: FM 98.1 (18:00–20:00)
■ Air date: Thursday, September 18, 2014, 7:00 p.m.
■ Host: Jung Kwan-yong (Professor, Hallym University of Graduate Studies)
■ Guests: Yun Suk-myung (Research Fellow, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs), Lee Chung-jae (Chairman, Korean Government Employees’ Union)
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> This afternoon a closed-door meeting of the ruling party, the government, and the presidential office was held at the presidential office. It was a discussion of the direction of Government Employees Pension reform. The plan is to finalize a pension reform plan along the lines of paying more and receiving less after a debate on the 22nd, but the government employees’ union is strongly opposed. We will connect with a pension expert and with the Korean Government Employees’ Union to hear each side, for and against. Let us first hear the voices of both sides on the direction of Government Employees Pension reform. We connect with Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, who argues that Government Employees Pension reform is necessary. Dr. Yun, hello?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Hello.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Compared with the National Pension, the Government Employees Pension is currently one where you pay in a little and receive a lot, right?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> There is the aspect of paying in a little and receiving a lot, yes.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> I see.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Because the income ceiling applied to the pension is about twice that of the National Pension, there is a very large difference not only in the simple benefit-to-contribution ratio, that is, the ratio of what you pay in to what you receive, but also in absolute amounts.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> So because the Government Employees Pension cannot cover it on its own, tax money keeps being put in, is that not so?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Yes, that is right. Looking at the current situation, the figures differ slightly depending on the statistics. The cumulative deficit subsidy to date comes out differently, at around 9.8 trillion won or 12.2 trillion won, but in any case no small amount has already gone in. Last year the deficit subsidy was 2 trillion won, and this year about 2.5 trillion won is expected; if it stayed at this level, one could argue it could somehow be carried on as it is. But if things go on as they are, the cumulative deficit over the next 10 years is expected to be around 53 trillion won.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Oh dear.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> And from 2020 onward, the deficit every year, annually, mind you, is expected to exceed 7 trillion won.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> So it cannot be left untouched. Voices have long said it must also be reformed for the sake of equity with the National Pension, so why has it not been reformed until now?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Well... in any country it is not easy to reform a pension system like that. Our National Pension was introduced in 1988, and through two reforms up to 2007 it carried out a very, very strong reform that cuts benefits by about 43% by 2028. People abroad have even said that it was a truly remarkable reform. The background to that reform was that Korea’s population is aging faster than anywhere else in the world. The Government Employees Pension, by contrast, was introduced in 1960, so the scheme is about 54 years old and has more problems, but because it has been around so long, it has accumulated that many stakeholders. There are many beneficiaries, and people who know the advantages of the Government Employees Pension well are not very pleased about touching the scheme, so...
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> So they resist strongly?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> I am not sure how I should put it...
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> So in any case it has not been fixed, is what you are saying.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Yes.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> This time it must be done: the government is showing strong will, and the Saenuri Party is showing strong will as well. And the Korean Pension Association has now put out a draft, right?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> It has not put out the draft yet. It is scheduled to be announced on the 22nd, but its main framework has been disclosed through some media outlets. So I think the general content can be grasped to some extent.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> So the basic policy is to increase what you pay in and reduce what you receive, is it not? Could you tell us a little about the content?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> I am not sure I should go into this much detail right now, but since some of it has been made public, I will speak within that scope.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Yes.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> At present, civil servants themselves pay a 7% contribution and the state pays 7%, for a 14% contribution in total. What is reported is that a reform will raise this by 6 percentage points to 20% over the next 10 years through 2026. That is not to say civil servants alone bear the entire 6-percentage-point increase.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> 3%...
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Half of it is borne by the state. And that concerns those who have already become civil servants; then there are those who will become civil servants in the future, right?
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Right.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> So this year is 2014, and if we carry out a reform we need to prepare legislative measures and the like, so if the law is finally passed by the National Assembly next year, we could probably implement this new law from 2016. From 2016, for newly entering civil servants, the contribution, as with the National Pension... right now, what the civil servant pays and what the state bears add up to 14%, right?
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Yes.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> But for the National Pension, all of that combined is 9%.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Right.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> What National Pension members pay and what employers pay comes to 9%, and for new civil servants it would likewise be 9%, meaning the civil servant’s own share would be lowered to 4.5%, so that new entrants are, for now, put on the same footing as ordinary citizens. That seems to be the main framework.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> The same treatment. Those who newly become civil servants will now be treated the same as the public, right?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Well... even so, the National Pension has an income redistribution function, and the Government Employees Pension is an earnings-related pension, so there are some differences. But in broad terms, you can see it as aligning the benefit-and-contribution structure for now.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> I see. So for those who are already civil servants, they will pay somewhat more through 2026 and receive somewhat less, and civil servants describe it this way: “This makes it even less than the National Pension; this is not a pension but simply a savings account.” Do you think that is an apt description? What do you think?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Well, for serving civil servants, from 2016 there is something called the “accrual rate,” and the plan is to take the current 1.9 to 1.35 from... over 10 years through 2026, about 2.25, adjusting it by 0.01 percentage points every year. And then it gets complicated.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> It is complicated.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> For new civil servants, the plan is to lower the accrual rate to 1% annually through 2028, as with the National Pension, and on this point there have been many serious objections in the press, asking whether this is not just a savings account. The Government Employees Pension is a big problem now, but there was a great deal of controversy over the National Pension as well, was there not? When it was reformed in 2007, the reason it was called a half-baked reform was that, although the benefit rate was lowered, the original plan had been to raise the contribution rate to 12.9% by 2018. But that could not be done.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> That is right.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> What that means is that even if the benefit structure is aligned with the National Pension, the current National Pension is a scheme that has to collect a contribution of about 13% for the books to balance. In other words, it is a scheme that still gives an advantage of about 4 percentage points. So it can be seen as a scheme whose rate of return is so high that it still cannot be compared with private-sector financial products.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> And another item that has been reported: there are people who have already retired and are receiving pensions, right?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Yes.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> For them, the amounts they receive will not be cut, but increases will be limited, and they will be required to pay a fiscal stabilization contribution of up to 3%. Could this not, in a way, give rise to constitutional controversy as a kind of retroactive application?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Whenever this sort of thing comes up, talk of unconstitutionality comes up too. I think we should first consider how dire things must be for such a measure to be contemplated at all. I think it shows just how bad the Government Employees Pension’s finances are right now. And if we ask whether we would be the first to do this, Germany runs its civil-service pension scheme very generously. But because of population aging and so on, the period of receiving pensions has lengthened and things have become difficult, so in its 2004 reform Germany already began collecting part of the pension from beneficiaries in this way, as a form of sharing the pain. Already.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> So there is a precedent.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Yes. So since such a strong reform plan is coming out in Korea, I think the approach is that it would be inequitable for retirees alone to be left out of it.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> I see. Dr. Yun, do you think that, with the content currently being discussed, it is worth trying for now, or that even this falls far short?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> I am not in a position to tell you 100% about the final plan, but other countries, such as Germany, Japan, Sweden, and Finland, go beyond this: if average life expectancy rises more than expected in the future and the economy moves further toward low growth, national finances and pension finances are bound to become strained, are they not?
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Of course.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Over that, there is political controversy; every pension reform causes very deep national division, does it not?
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Yes.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> To block that at the source, they introduced what is called an automatic adjustment mechanism. Without the political sphere or anyone else intervening, when people live longer and the period of receiving pensions lengthens, and when economic growth falls and capacity declines, a scheme automatically cuts pensions. They have introduced it already.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Oh, really?
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Countries such as Germany, Japan, Sweden, Finland, Norway, and Austria have already introduced it. So we too must go that far for it to be a proper reform, but in any case, we will have to wait and see.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Let us stop here. Thank you.
◆ Yun Suk-myung> Thank you.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> That was Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Next, you are also co-representative of the Joint Struggle Headquarters to stop the “deterioration of public pensions,” are you not? We connect with Lee Chung-jae, Chairman of the Korean Government Employees’ Union. Chairman Lee, are you there?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Yes, hello.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> First, regarding the plan under discussion, though nothing has been finalized yet, how do you see it?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> First of all, there is serious anxiety and turmoil among our civil servants, to the point of an early-retirement rush. And there is great anger at civil servants being branded tax thieves and shameless criminals. In particular, trust has collapsed even in the state’s promise that it would compensate civil servants with pensions if they endured low pay and various disadvantages while in service. Also, a president, for example, pays not a single won in pension contributions and now receives about 200 million won as a pension. National Assembly members in effect receive about 1.2 million won as a pension. I want to point out that those very leaders do not share in such pain. As for this amendment, first, it was discussed behind closed doors and was not discussed at all with civil servants, the stakeholders, so we cannot even know its exact content. In conclusion, it is a plan that does not reflect the special nature of the Government Employees Pension at all, and it is also a far more disadvantageous plan in terms of equity with the National Pension. And because it is a draft built on the basis of malicious distortions of fact, we can never accept it. Also, for reference, people need to know what kind of organization the Pension Association is.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> What kind of organization is it?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Most of its board members and institutional members are chaebol insurers, securities firms, and the like.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Aha!
◆ Lee Chung-jae> It is an organization that has consistently argued for measures to boost private pensions in place of public pensions. Until now these people have made the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension deteriorate. And it is an organization that sells off the old age of citizens and civil servants to chaebol insurers.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> I see. But in reality, you do admit that huge deficits are now occurring and government funds are being put in, do you not?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Yes, that is so.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> And you admit that about 53 trillion won more will have to go in over the next 10 years or so?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Yes.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Then it does need to be fixed, does it not?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> I think you can look at it this way. No country calls it a deficit just because government funds are put into pensions; Korea alone does so. I want to say that this should be approached from the standpoint of social security, for which the state naturally bears responsibility, and Korea’s government share is the lowest, at 12.6%. Even nearby Japan is at 28%, the United States at 35%, and Germany and France at over 50 or 60%.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> The share of total pension spending borne by the government?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Yes, that is right. So the public should not agree with this logic. Because the Basic Pension is also funded entirely by taxes. It is a deficit too, if you look at it that way.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Of course, that one is.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> It means the government can simply stop paying by saying it has no money. The National Pension will also be depleted in 30 or 40 years. If the government then says it will not take fiscal measures, the result will be that the public cannot receive their pensions. And the expert just now said this and that, but there has been far too much distortion of fact all along. Nearby Japan, for example, is one of the OECD countries with the lowest income replacement rates. In Korean terms, its basic pension for a married couple combined comes to about 1.4 to 1.5 million won. That is more than five times Korea’s. On top of that, people there receive about 1.5 million won from the national pension and about 1.9 million from the government employees pension, and of course a lot of tax money goes in. Moreover, if the government wants to reduce tax inputs into the Government Employees Pension, it should resolve the various disadvantages civil servants face. And it is only normal to discuss bringing pay and severance in line with reality together, from a lifetime-income perspective.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> You said that despite low pay and disadvantages, civil servants have so far been compensated through the Government Employees Pension.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Yes.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> In the current situation, civil servants’ pay is not really that low. It was low in the past, of course, but it has risen considerably, so is it not clearly true that ordinary citizens see the Government Employees Pension as giving civil servants alone too many privileges?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> People seem to think all civil servants serve until the retirement age of 60, but in reality the average retirement age of civil servants is 50. I hope people would also look at the reality that they retire after about 23 years of service.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Yes.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> People say civil servants’ pay has been brought largely in line with reality, but in the past it was compared against public enterprises and companies with 300 or more employees. Now, compared with companies with 100 or more employees, civil servants’ pay has in fact fallen considerably, to 77%.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Is that so?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> And civil servants’ retirement allowance is now at most 39%. Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung, for one, has kept lying until now that it is 60%. Also, civil servants are not covered at all by industrial accident insurance or the Basic Pension. None of these issues are being discussed at all, and if the aim is to match the benefit-to-contribution ratio with the National Pension, then currently serving civil servants should pay contributions on the same basis; ordinary citizens now pay 4.5%, right?
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Right.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Making us pay 10%, 2.2 times as much, is also somewhat problematic in terms of equity.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> How, then, will the government employees’ union respond going forward? The government and the ruling party say they will push ahead with reform with very strong will.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Korea will become an aged society in 2018 and a super-aged society in 2026. The elderly poverty rate is 45%, more than three times the OECD average and the highest in the world, and the retirement age is 71. We think there needs to be a discussion, at the national level as well, about what an adequate old-age income should be across public pensions as a whole, that is, the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension. And we plan to develop policy alternatives on that and inform the public. So we believe the most important thing is to lay the foundation for people to secure their old-age income with their own pensions. But that does not mean we can just sit still, does it?
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Yes.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> So in November, we will first voice civil servants’ views through a “General Uprising Rally of One Million Civil Servants.” In particular, we cannot but pass judgment on this Park Geun-hye administration, which only raises taxes on ordinary people and cuts taxes for the rich, and, with the 5 million members of civil servants’ families, on the chaebol insurers that sell off the public’s old age, linking all of this together.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> Compared with the National Pension, you do admit that the Government Employees Pension is currently better than the National Pension, do you not?
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Let me explain: as I said earlier, it is larger because it includes the special nature of our Government Employees Pension, deferred wages for low pay, the severance component, and the fact that we are not covered by the Basic Pension, industrial accident insurance, and so on while in service. After the 2010 amendment, for new entrants, the income replacement rate is in effect 39.9%. So it has in fact fallen to roughly the National Pension’s level. If we apply the average of 23 years of service, it is only about 30%. So these things really should be transparently...
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> I see.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> I hope they will be made known to the public objectively.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> I see. The public will hear both sides and judge for themselves. Thank you.
◆ Lee Chung-jae> Yes, thank you.
◇ Jung Kwan-yong> That was Lee Chung-jae, Chairman of the Korean Government Employees’ Union.
