(Maeil Business Newspaper) “The National Pension Should Be Integrated with the Government Employees Pension” (March 4, 2022)
With the integration of the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension having been raised among presidential candidates, the same argument has now come from a policy research institute as well.
Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, made a presentation to this effect on the 4th at the “Forum for Preparing Public Pension Reform Measures” hosted by KIHASA. Research Fellow Yun’s argument is that the National Pension should be combined and operated together with the special occupational pensions, such as the Government Employees Pension, the Private School Teachers Pension, and the Military Pension.
He stressed that it must not stop at simply merging the individual pension schemes. He said that the benefit levels and other features of each pension should be equalized, and that severance pay should be paid at the level paid in the private sector.
In his presentation that day, Research Fellow Yun said, “The 2015 overhaul of the Government Employees Pension widened the gap in contribution rates between the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension to twofold, making integration of the two pensions difficult,”
adding, “I propose Japanese-style integration.” Japan fully integrated its National Pension and Government Employees Pension in 2015. It also unified the two pensions’ contribution rates and income replacement rates (pension accrual rates).
Calls to integrate the National Pension and the Government Employees Pension have been raised steadily. Criticism of “a lack of equity” has continued to be raised, given that Government Employees Pension payments are far larger than those of the National Pension.
In fact, as of 2019, the average monthly benefit per National Pension beneficiary was only 370,000 won, whereas the average monthly pension per retired civil servant reached 2.4 million won.
Accordingly, Sim Sang-jung, the Justice Party’s presidential candidate, and Ahn Cheol-soo, leader of the People’s Party, have also made the integration of public pensions a campaign pledge.
At the forum that day, there was also an argument that the National Pension should be changed into an “earnings-related pension” like those of advanced Western countries. National Pension benefits currently consist of a flat-rate component and an earnings-related component, and the argument is that this should be converted to a fully earnings-related method.
The current scheme has a “more for the lower, less for the upper” structure, in which the lower one’s income, the higher one’s National Pension income replacement rate. If a fully earnings-related method is introduced, every member’s income replacement rate becomes the same.
There was also an argument that the flat-rate component of the National Pension should be integrated with the Basic Pension. The Basic Pension is paid to older people in the bottom 70% by income. Lee Yong-ha, Invited Research Fellow at KIHASA, explained, “The flat-rate component of the National Pension should be combined with the Basic Pension to move toward a ‘universal Basic Pension’ system,” adding, “That way, every generation can be guaranteed a minimum income.” Research Fellow Lee believes that once a “two-tier structure” of a universal Basic Pension and an earnings-related pension is in place, both the alleviation of old-age poverty and the fiscal sustainability of the National Pension will be secured.
In addition, the need to introduce a supplementary pension scheme for low-income older people was also raised. Jung Hae-sik, Research Fellow at KIHASA, stressed the need for supplementary pension payments, saying, “The National Pension should be set as the central pillar of old-age income security, while its shortcomings are supplemented.”
[Reporter Lee Hee-jo]
[ⓒ Maeil Business & mk.co.kr, Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited]
