(Seoul Economic Daily) “Change the National Pension So People Get Back What They Pay In — and Merge It with the Government Employees Pension” (March 4, 2022)
■ “Public Pension Reform” Forum
Yun Suk-myung Presents a “Sustainable Overhaul Plan”
“Convert the National Pension to a 100% Earnings-Related Pension”
Argues for In-Kind Benefit Support for Vulnerable Groups
Jung Hae-sik Puts Forward a “Supplementary Old-Age Pension Scheme”
With presidential candidates of both the ruling and opposition parties pledging “pension reform,” a view has emerged that the National Pension should be converted to a 100% earnings-related pension, as in major countries, and that pension amounts should be cut and adjusted according to economic and social variables.

Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, presents at the “Discussion on Public Pension Reform Measures” forum held on the 4th. Photo courtesy of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs
Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, gave a presentation titled “Direction for Overhauling the Pension System to Be Fiscally and Politically Sustainable (A Plan for Integrating Public Pensions)” at the “Discussion on Public Pension Reform Measures” forum held on the 4th, saying, “The National Pension benefit formula should be completely overhauled into a 100% earnings-related pension, as in major countries.” He pointed out that if contributions are raised while the current National Pension benefit formula is kept as it is, a problem arises in which middle- and higher-income earners get back even less than they paid in.
In that case, however, protection for vulnerable groups who find it hard to pay large amounts would decline. To make up for this, Research Fellow Yun proposed guaranteeing at least the absolute poverty line (30% of median income) through a selective Basic Pension and in-kind benefits such as housing allowances.
For the Basic Pension, he proposed unifying it over the long term at the same level as the National Basic Livelihood Security System, which paid about 540,000 won a month as of last year. However, he pointed out that because a larger Basic Pension benefit received without contributing weakens the incentive to join the National Pension, benefits should be divided into cash and in-kind benefits and paid differentially according to old-age income levels and individual needs. Research Fellow Yun particularly stressed the need to introduce an automatic adjustment mechanism as a means of mediating conflict. This means automatically adjusting pension benefit amounts, contribution rates, and the like to reflect economic and social variables such as the fertility rate, life expectancy, and the economic growth rate. Saying, “Introducing the mechanism right away would cause conflict in our society,” he recommended adopting Finland’s “life expectancy coefficient,” which automatically cuts pension amounts in step with increases in life expectancy.
Research Fellow Yun also proposed integrating the Government Employees Pension with the National Pension. Civil servants would receive the National Pension, which is lower than the current Government Employees Pension, but would be able to receive severance pay in return. According to Research Fellow Yun, a reform along these lines would increase the burden on the state by only 0.56 percentage points compared with now, while easing the trend of national liabilities, which worsen every year because of the Government Employees Pension. Under this structure, of civil servants’ existing 9% contribution, 4.5% would be integrated into the National Pension, and the remaining 4.5% would be paid out on a defined contribution basis, in which paid-in contributions are linked to future benefits.
Jung Hae-sik, Research Fellow at KIHASA, who gave the second presentation on the theme “Review of Measures to Introduce a Supplementary Old-Age Pension Scheme,” pointed out that as the eligibility threshold for the Basic Pension has risen, people are receiving both the National Pension and the Basic Pension. The point is that while even older people with sufficient income receive the benefit of the Basic Pension, poor older people who actually need support are left neglected. To make up for this, he proposed introducing a supplementary old-age pension scheme that would provide additional pensions and allowances to low-income older people. Research Fellow Jung said, “In 2008, at the early stage of the Basic Pension’s introduction, the eligibility threshold was a monthly income of 400,000 won for a single-person household, but this year it has risen to 1.8 million won,” adding, “It is difficult to respond to old-age poverty with a single pension scheme and a flat-rate pension benefit.”
