Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(Dong-A Ilbo) “Sacrifice Forced on Young Civil Servants — Pension Benefits Should Have Been Cut Further” (May 5, 2015)

2026.11.15

[A Pension Reform Where the Side Dish Outgrew the Main Course / Expert Diagnosis]
What Is Wrong with the Ruling and Opposition Parties’ Agreed Plan

“The ‘politicization of welfare,’ in which politics makes a mess of welfare, has become a reality once again.”

Criticism is pouring in that the agreement the ruling and opposition parties reached on the 3rd, trading Government Employees Pension reform for a strengthening of the National Pension, is “political collusion.” The point is that the pattern of welfare being expanded by politicians’ impulsive slogans, as with free childcare and free school meals, has been repeated. We asked pension experts how they assess this “big deal” of Government Employees Pension reform in exchange for a stronger National Pension.

○ “Government Employees Pension Will Inevitably Have to Be Revisited in Five Years”

The prevailing assessment is that the Government Employees Pension reform was carried out at the minimum level the civil service could be made to accept without revolt. Critics point out that while there will be a short-lived fiscal savings effect, it is too small to substantially reduce the state subsidy burden, which reaches 2 trillion won a year. Some even point out that while the reform succeeded in raising contributions by about 30%, limiting the pension cut to around 10% amounts to forcing sacrifice on young civil servants.

Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, said, “Rather than seeking a short-lived effect by raising the contribution rate, it should have gone the route of cutting pension benefits further in order to secure sustainability.”

Lowering the Government Employees Pension accrual rate in stages through 2035 is also cited as a problem, because lowering the accrual rate in stages over roughly 20 years from now delays the fiscal savings accordingly. Professor Kim Won-sik of the Department of Economics at Konkuk University pointed out, “When a substantial amount of tax money is poured into the Government Employees Pension every year, the schedule was set far too leisurely,” adding, “The timing of the cuts should have been brought forward as much as possible.”

Criticism is also being voiced that the contradictions other than the “pay more, receive less” part were left virtually untouched. In particular, no reform was achieved on issues such as suspending pension payments to those re-employed after retirement, members with 33 or more years of service paying no contributions, and the overhaul of the retirement allowance. Professor Kim Jin-soo of the Department of Social Welfare at Yonsei University said, “Merely reducing the contradictions other than the pay-more-receive-less part would have had a considerable fiscal savings effect, yet they were not even discussed,” adding, “At this rate, reform will have to be discussed again within five to ten years.”

○ National Pension Contribution Increase: “Public Consent Will Be Hard to Obtain”

The prevailing assessment of linking the Government Employees Pension to the National Pension is that it was “hasty collusion.”

Won Jong-wook, Director of the Social Security Financial Projection Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, said, “When newly appointed civil servants are not even being moved into the National Pension, I do not understand why unrelated schemes were compared and dealt with at the same time,” adding, “This discussion itself was an inappropriate political decision.”

Some also point out that raising the National Pension income replacement rate from the current 40% to 50% will be difficult in practice because of public resistance. This is also why the government and the ruling party are gauging the mood, saying, “Strengthening the National Pension requires public consent first.” Professor Jeong Chang-ryul of the Department of Social Welfare at Dankook University pointed out, “Raising contributions is no different from raising taxes, and I question whether the current administration, whose policy line is welfare without tax increases, has the will and the capacity to raise them,” adding, “Raising National Pension contributions, which applies to the entire population, is a more difficult problem than Government Employees Pension reform.”

There are also warnings that raising National Pension contributions could hurt the economy, because workplaces currently bear half of their employees’ contributions. Raising the National Pension income replacement rate by about 10 percentage points is highly likely to create pressure to roughly double the contribution rate (9%).

Above all, the general consensus is that an agreement to raise the National Pension income replacement rate is not a matter to be decided behind closed doors without sufficient social discussion.

Director Yun said, “Setting the National Pension income replacement rate at 40% was not a decision made in an instant; it was agreed after four years of intense discussion among stakeholders and experts, and the political sphere overturned it in just a few days,” adding, “It is not right to suddenly drag in the National Pension of 21 million people while overhauling the Government Employees Pension of 1.07 million.”

Yoon Hee-sook, head of the Fiscal and Social Policy Research Division at the Korea Development Institute (KDI), said, “Linking the Government Employees Pension reform to the National Pension is a problem in itself, but the bigger problem is that the people who linked them were people with no authority over the National Pension.”

Reporters Yoo Geun-hyeong [email protected] and Lee Se-hyeong

https://www.donga.com/news/amp/all/20150505/71069966/1

Related Posts