Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(JoongAng Ilbo) Lee Jae-myung, Who Said He Is “Not Confident He Can Handle Pension Reform,” Eagerly Bites at “Paying Out More Pension” [News One Shot] (January 8, 2022)

2026.11.15
(JoongAng Ilbo) Lee Jae-myung, Who Said He Is “Not Confident He Can Handle Pension Reform,” Eagerly Bites at “Paying Out More Pension” [News One Shot] (January 8, 2022)

Lee Jae-myung, the Democratic Party of Korea’s presidential candidate, holds a press conference on the “Small but Certain Happiness” public idea-submission campaign at the party’s central headquarters in Yeouido, Seoul, on the 31st of last month. News1

A Specialist Reporter’s Hunch: Pension Reform Pushed Aside, Paying Out More Pension Eagerly Embraced

The policy pledge contest between Lee Jae-myung of the Democratic Party of Korea and Yoon Suk-yeol of the People Power Party is in full swing. Candidate Lee packages his as the “Small but Certain Happiness series,” and candidate Yoon as “Seok-yeol’s Heart-Fluttering Promises.” While Yoon has been preoccupied with infighting in his own camp, Lee’s “Small but Certain Happiness” pledges have surged ahead to No. 41.

Some pledges scratch where it itches, such as health insurance coverage for contraception and abortion and easing the burden on couples struggling with infertility, but he has gone as far as absurd ones like “health insurance coverage for hair loss.” Many of them relate to low fertility and population aging, and the one that stands out is pledge No. 39: “The National Pension of seniors who work! We will return it properly without cutting it.”

People whose National Pension was cut because they have income. Graphic: Reporter Kim Young-ok yesok@joongang.co.kr

People whose National Pension was cut because they have income. Graphic: Reporter Kim Young-ok [email protected]


When people turn 62 and start receiving the National Pension, they are sometimes dumbfounded. If they work and their monthly income exceeds 2.54 million won, their pension is cut by up to half. The idea is that because they have income, they should receive less pension. The cut lasts five years. It is hard to understand why their pension, of all things, should be cut when people are working hard and earning money rather than retiring.

About 100,000 people had their pensions cut this way last year. Each lost 1.42 million won a year, close to 120,000 won a month. With the average National Pension only 540,000 won a month, and at a time when work should be encouraged if anything, it crushes the will to work. Calls for its abolition have never ceased, on the grounds that it runs counter to an aging era. It is commendable that candidate Lee spotted this problem and pledged to adjust the reduction system in stages.

Cases of pensions cut because of income. Graphic: Reporter Kim Young-ok yesok@joongang.co.kr

Cases of pensions cut because of income. Graphic: Reporter Kim Young-ok [email protected]


Of course, some argue that because the National Pension is designed to pay out far more than people paid in, it is right to cut it once income exceeds a certain amount. That argument applies to those with high monthly incomes. But of the roughly 100,000 people whose pensions were cut last year, about half exceeded the 2.54 million won threshold by less than 1 million won. In other words, their monthly income was under 3.64 million won.

The world is at war with aging. The consistent remedy is to help people work longer. Among the member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) that run contribution-based pension systems like ours, only Greece, Japan, and Spain slash pensions this way (four countries, including Denmark, are unconfirmed). The OECD, too, recommended long ago that the Korean government abolish it.

But it is hard simply to applaud candidate Lee’s pledge No. 39. Pension reform is far more urgent than abolishing the reduction. Candidate Lee has made no pension reform pledge and appears to have no intention of making one. Appearing on MBC Radio last July, he said, “I agree (on the need), but I am not confident whether I can do it within my term, or whether I can handle it.” On KBS’s Sunday Diagnosis on the 26th of last month, he said, “(Omitted) Pension reform must be done. We must debate fiercely and reach a conclusion. But at this stage, saying ‘this is how I will do it’ is itself close to self-righteousness.”

Graphic image of National Pension finances. [Data: Ministry of Health and Welfare]

Graphic image of National Pension finances. [Data: Ministry of Health and Welfare]

Candidate Lee Jae-myung’s position on pension reform. Graphic: Reporter Kim Young-ok yesok@joongang.co.kr

Candidate Lee Jae-myung’s position on pension reform. Graphic: Reporter Kim Young-ok [email protected]


Yun Suk-myung, President of the Korean Pension Association (Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs),

expressed sympathy with candidate Lee’s pledge, saying, “Pension recipients with high incomes can have their pensions reduced, but I think it is right to abolish the reduction for the rest.

The OECD also taxes pensions, and it recommends abolishing the reduction because cutting pensions on account of income is double taxation.”

President Yun said, “However, for the sake of the generation in their 20s and 30s, securing the sustainability of the pension is extremely urgent. Even if it is painful, he should first pledge pension reform for the sake of the future,” and

pointed out, “Yet it is inconsistent to say nothing about pension reform because it loses votes and to put forward only the abolition of the reduction system, which wins votes.”

Candidate Lee’s pledge No. 39 may be effective in targeting people in their 60s, a weak point for him. But I hope he realizes that people in their 20s and 30s are watching with hawk eyes to see who will carry out pension reform properly. If the current system is left as it is, the fund will be depleted in 2057 and 25% of income will have to be paid in contributions. Otherwise, people now in their 20s and 30s may not receive a pension at all.

Pension reform is the work of saving a forest that is withering and dying. What happens if you ignore the forest and save only one tree, one weed?

→ Information on candidate Lee Jae-myung https://www.joongang.co.kr/election2022/candidates/LeeJaeMyung

Shin Sung-sik, Welfare Specialist Reporter [email protected]

Copyright © JoongAng Ilbo. Unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited.

https://v.daum.net/v/20220108050039055

Related Posts