(KBS 1TV) [Economic Inside] National Pension Reworked So That Those Who Die Early Do Not ‘Lose Out’ (June 19, 2019)
![(KBS 1TV) [Economic Inside] National Pension Reworked So That Those Who Die Early Do Not ‘Lose Out’ (June 19, 2019)](/uploads/editor/2026/11/1fd4bcc8d7cc4b96b72b87e36a1d0e1c-Screenshot_20261115_194905_Samsung-Browser.jpg)
Under the current National Pension, if someone receiving an old-age pension dies early, it is passed on as a survivors’ pension, but if there are no survivors, the pension simply lapses.
To ensure that people do not end up receiving no pension benefits despite having paid substantial contributions, the introduction of a minimum pension payment guarantee is being pursued.
We look at what it involves with Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs.
Let us start with the survivors’ pension.
The scope of survivors is a little different under the National Pension, is it not?
The National Pension Act sets out the scope and order of priority of the survivors entitled to receive a survivors’ pension.
They are the spouse, children (under 25 or with a disability grade of 2 or higher), parents (aged 62 or older <born 1957–60> or with a disability grade of 2 or higher), grandchildren (under 19 or with a disability grade of 2 or higher), and grandparents (aged 62 or older <born 1957–60> or with a disability grade of 2 or higher), and the first in priority is the spouse.
First, let us look at the survivors’ pension.
When a husband and wife are both receiving the National Pension and one of them passes away first, at present the survivor has to choose, right?
If the survivor chooses the survivors’ pension of the deceased spouse (40–60% of the basic pension the deceased spouse had been receiving), they receive only the survivors’ pension.
They cannot receive a single won of the old-age pension they paid into themselves. 1+1 becomes 1.
If they choose their own old-age pension instead, they can receive the old-age pension plus an additional 30% of the survivors’ pension.
Until December 2016, this overlapping payment rate for the survivors’ pension was 20%; it was then raised to 30%.
In effect, 1+1 becomes 1.3.
Why was it designed this way?
The National Pension, run by the state, is a form of social insurance.
In other words, it is an insurance scheme that covers all members of our society.
The operating principle of the National Pension as a social insurance scheme is that the state makes enrollment compulsory in order to prevent situations in which income disappears in old age, or in which survivors are left without income and struggle to make a living when someone dies suddenly in the prime of working life.
Unlike private insurance, it covers all members of society, and it responds collectively both to cases where some individuals live very long and to cases where others die early.
Because the benefits that those who died early would have received are not confined to their family members but extend to all National Pension participants—because those benefits are provided to all the insured—there can be complaints from the family’s point of view that they are not receiving the share they are rightfully owed.
In short, social insurance such as the National Pension does not confine its benefits to the family but distributes them fairly among all the insured, and so it places limits on the payment of survivors’ pensions.
Among National Pension participants there are not yet many high-benefit recipients, but the provisions limiting survivors’ pension payments were also set up partly to prevent excessive pension payments.
Do other countries also adjust overlapping benefits?
Many countries adjust overlapping benefits, but many of them operate it somewhat differently from us.
The country most similar to Korea is the United States, where a person receives only the larger of the two.
France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Canada, and others pay both benefits together and cut part of the survivors’ pension only when the total exceeds a set ceiling.
This takes into account the fact that both the old-age pension and the survivors’ pension may be small.
Switzerland is again a little different.
There, the person chooses whichever of the two pensions is larger and is paid an additional 20% of the old-age pension.
Because survivors’ pensions come not only from the public pension but also from retirement pensions, the likelihood of facing economic hardship is small.
These figures are from a few years ago, but the ceiling, at 2,340 Swiss francs (about 2.71 million won), is also fairly generous.
There have been continual calls to raise the overlapping payment rate for the survivors’ pension.
What do you think about this, Dr. Yun?
I have been proposing a somewhat different alternative.
Raising the payment rate a little may be meaningful, but what really matters is the amount paid.
Because even now the National Pension system pays out about twice what people paid in, there are no small concerns about its long-term fiscal stability.
As a result, the restrictions on survivors’ pension payments have also gained a certain degree of justification.
Taking all these aspects into account, raising the survivors’ pension payment rate a little could be one alternative, but I think it is also worth actively considering not applying the overlapping benefit adjustment at all (until a couple’s combined pensions fall below 50% of median income, the OECD poverty line).
In addition, for the sake of equity, I would also like to propose differentiating the survivors’ pension payment by income band for couples whose combined pension amounts are at or above median income.
I think one could consider, for example, paying a 50% survivors’ pension to those between 50% and 75% of median income, and a 40% survivors’ pension to those between 75% and 100%.
And in cases like this, where there is no one even to receive a survivors’ pension, the pension entitlement itself has disappeared, has it not?
Currently, once a person completes the minimum contribution period of 10 years under the National Pension, they can receive an old-age pension until they die.
However, if a person dies early while receiving an old-age pension, the pension can be passed on as a survivors’ pension if there are “survivors as defined in the National Pension Act,” but if there are no such survivors, the pension entitlement disappears.
In the process, there are cases where the pension amounts received are smaller than the contributions paid.
According to data from the National Pension Service, from 2014 to May 2017, 4,363 old-age pension recipients died within one year, and among those who died within one year, 813 were counted as cases in which the entitlement lapsed because the remaining family members were not eligible for a survivors’ pension.
It is said that a “minimum pension payment guarantee” is being pursued so that people do not fail to receive proper pension benefits because of an early death despite having paid substantial contributions.
What does it involve?
This is included in the Fourth National Pension Comprehensive Operation Plan that the Ministry of Health and Welfare submitted to the National Assembly.
It was decided to pursue the introduction of a “minimum pension payment guarantee” so that people do not fail to receive proper pension benefits because they die early despite having paid contributions.
Under it, if the old-age pension a recipient received before dying is less than the lump-sum death benefit that would have been paid had they died while still insured, the difference between the lump-sum death benefit and the old-age pension already received is paid to those eligible to claim the lump-sum death benefit (a spouse, children, parents, grandchildren, grandparents, siblings, and collateral relatives up to the fourth degree of kinship who are not survivors under the National Pension Act).
The lump-sum death benefit refers to an amount of about four times the insured person’s average monthly income over the contribution period, paid to those eligible to claim it.
