(KBS News) How to Strengthen the Basic Pension? Heated Debate over Eligibility and Benefit Levels (May 20, 2015)
Lee Jong-kul, floor leader of the New Politics Democratic Union, has proposed strengthening the Basic Pension in exchange for not insisting on stipulating a 50% nominal income replacement rate for the National Pension, as a breakthrough in the ruling and opposition parties’ negotiations on Government Employees Pension reform, but pension experts are divided over the specific methodology.
One side argues that eligibility for the Basic Pension should be expanded to solve the overall problem of old-age poverty.
The other side takes the view that, given the extreme income inequality within the older population compared with other age groups, the Basic Pension should move toward narrowing eligibility further, focusing on low-income older people who are far worse off, while paying them larger amounts.
With the ruling party reacting negatively to floor leader Lee’s proposal, its chances of being realized are slim, but the split shows that even if it were put on the negotiating table between the ruling and opposition parties, reaching a conclusion in the consultation process would not be easy.
After twists and turns, including controversy over a retreat from its campaign pledge, the Park Geun-hye administration has been implementing the Basic Pension since July 25 last year, expanding the former Basic Old-Age Pension.
Financed by national taxes, it pays older people aged 65 and over in the bottom 70% by income a monthly Basic Pension of at least 100,000 won and up to 200,000 won, reducing the amount the longer their National Pension contribution period.
Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs,
is regarded as a leading expert advocating changing the Basic Pension scheme to narrow eligibility to vulnerable older people while raising benefit amounts so that it can contribute to substantially alleviating their poverty.
At a seminar of the “National Competitiveness Enhancement Forum” held at the National Assembly Members’ Office Building on the 18th, Research Fellow Yun
argued, “We should gradually reduce the current 70% eligibility for the Basic Pension while giving more to low-income people to lower the elderly poverty rate.”
According to Research Fellow Yun,
the degree of income inequality within the population aged 65 and over is becoming far greater than in the population as a whole. In particular, since 2008, when the Basic Old-Age Pension, the predecessor of the Basic Pension, was introduced, income inequality within the group of older people aged 65 and over has worsened.
This suggests that the tax-financed Basic Old-Age Pension was not effective in lowering Korea’s elderly poverty rate (48.6% as of 2011), said to be the highest among the member countries of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), Research Fellow Yun explained.
Given this reality, Yun said,
if the Basic Pension scheme is to be improved, more benefits should go to low-income older people so as to maximize the effect of alleviating old-age poverty relative to the cost invested.
By contrast, the group of experts advocating a stronger Basic Pension argues for expanding the Basic Pension on a universal basis.
That is, eligibility, now tied to the bottom 70% by income among those aged 65 and over, should be broadened further, and, moreover, benefit amounts should be raised across the board rather than paid on a differentiated basis linked to the National Pension contribution period.
The view is that, given the current state of old-age poverty in Korea, the Basic Pension should in the long run become a Basic Pension worthy of the name, received by every older person.
Oh Gun-ho, co-chair of the steering committee of Welfare State I Make,
proposed that “a plan is needed to raise benefit adequacy by increasing the Basic Pension on a universal basis.”
To this end, Oh
said, “Let us extend eligibility for the Basic Pension, which is currently paid only to the bottom 70% by income, to all older people, and raise the Basic Pension benefit of 150,000–200,000 won to close the coverage gaps.”
Professor Kim Won-sup of Korea University also
said, “I believe it is desirable to broaden the coverage of the Basic Pension and raise the benefit amounts.”
