(Joseilbo) Those Receiving 200,000 Won from the National Pension to Get an Extra 50,000–150,000 Won in Basic Pension — Joseilbo | Courtesy of Yonhap News (February 3, 2013)
Bottom 70% by income: 130,000–150,000 won; top 30% by income: 50,000–100,000 won under review
Transition Committee’s provisional Basic Pension improvement plan — “Ending equity disputes and keeping the campaign pledge”
Older people aged 65 and over who receive the National Pension and the Basic Old-Age Pension will receive a fixed additional amount each month, compared with before, through the introduction of the Basic Pension.
It was drawn up as an alternative to resolve two problems arising as the “Park Geun-hye administration” introduces the Basic Pension: double receipt of benefits, and the equity problem of reverse discrimination against those who have faithfully paid into the National Pension.
Under the principle of providing pension benefits to everyone over 65, older people in the top 30% by income, who did not receive the Basic Old-Age Pension, are also expected to receive an additional pension of 100,000 won or less.
According to the Presidential Transition Committee and the Ministry of Health and Welfare, among others, on the 3rd, the Transition Committee has drawn up a provisional plan for introducing the Basic Pension along these lines and is reportedly going to include it in the core national agenda it will announce soon.
The provisional plan divides older people aged 65 and over into four groups and differentiates the Basic Pension among them.
The criteria for the groups are whether a person is enrolled in the National Pension and the income distribution used to determine eligibility for the Basic Old-Age Pension.
The first group, the most vulnerable to “old-age poverty” (not enrolled in the National Pension, bottom 70% by income), will receive as its monthly Basic Pension twice the flat-rate component (the A value) of the National Pension benefit at the median-income level.
Someone who received 97,000 won in Basic Old-Age Pension as of this year would see the amount rise to a Basic Pension of 200,000 won from now on. The first group currently numbers about 3 million people.
For the second group (enrolled in the National Pension, bottom 70% by income), which had been caught up in the double-receipt controversy as well as in equity disputes in comparison with the first group, the Basic Pension formula is somewhat complicated.
One official told Yonhap News by phone, “We will apply the principle of adding at least a little ‘plus alpha’ to the existing amount (National Pension benefit + Basic Old-Age Pension benefit).”
“There will absolutely be no cut in National Pension benefits,” the official added. “We are working out a specific formula.”
As with the first group, these people will keep their National Pension benefits and receive an additional twice the A value, the effect of conversion to the Basic Pension.
In this case, to reduce the scope for double receipt, a fixed amount reflecting income, assets, and the contribution period will be deducted. Depending on the formula, a deduction of 50,000–70,000 won a month at current levels is being floated as the most likely.
In this way, compared with before the introduction of the Basic Pension, the amount actually received after its introduction will rise by 30,000–50,000 won a month. The second group falling into this category numbers about 1 million people.
Another Transition Committee official explained, “If you paid your National Pension contributions faithfully, it is only fair that you receive more than those who did not pay contributions, even after it is integrated into the Basic Pension.”
Consider the case of someone who, under the existing system, receives a total of 300,000 won: 200,000 won from the National Pension (the A value of 100,000 won plus the B value of 100,000 won, the earnings-related component) and 100,000 won from the Basic Old-Age Pension.
Under the provisional improvement plan, 200,000 won, corresponding to the expansion of the Basic Old-Age Pension, is added to the A value of 100,000 won; after 50,000–70,000 won is deducted, the B value of 100,000 won is added on top, bringing the amount received to 330,000–350,000 won.
The third group (about 1 million people), in the top 30% by income and enrolled in the National Pension, will also receive more than their existing National Pension benefits. An additional 50,000–100,000 won a month is reportedly under consideration.
How much the last group (1 million people), in the top 30% by income and not enrolled in the National Pension, will receive is undecided for now.
Many argue that since these people have high income and assets and did not pay National Pension contributions either, it is only right to give them the least or nothing at all.
However, this is countered by the view that the principle of letting every older person receive pension benefits should apply, and some also question the effectiveness of an amount of less than 50,000 won a month.
In principle, the amount exceeding the National Pension A value is to be financed from the government budget, and the rest from individually accumulated contributions. This could make the fiscal burden heavier in the future.
Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs,
said, “No system can exist that gives ample pensions even to those who did not pay pension contributions without passing the burden on to later generations,”
advising that “in the process of fleshing out the policy, these values will have to be properly balanced.”
ⓒ Courtesy of Yonhap News; unauthorized reproduction and redistribution prohibited
