Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(Hankook Ilbo) Empty National Coffers, Even the Bill for the Nuclear Phase-Out — and a Social Insurance Hike Boomerang, Too (May 26, 2021)

2026.11.14

Backlash of electricity rate hikes from closing, canceling or halting seven reactors; fiscal deficits of 409 trillion won in five years — twice the previous administrations’ ten-year total
A national debt ratio above 60% only a matter of time, mounting pressure for tax increases; National Pension reform, having missed its golden opportunity, driven into a “dead end” in 2023

■ Four Years of the Moon Administration — Three Policy Bombs Set to Fall on the Next Administration

May 24, 2017, right after the Moon Jae-in administration took office. The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy was giving its work briefing to the State Affairs Planning Advisory Committee. It was a meeting at which members of the committee’s Economy 2 subcommittee and senior ministry officials (excluding the minister and vice ministers) discussed national policy tasks. The issue at stake was, above all, the nuclear phase-out policy. The ministry reported on the procedures, legal provisions and estimated damages involved in carrying out the pledge to phase out nuclear power, but the response it got was, “You still haven’t come to your senses.” Members of other subcommittees, including Kim Eun-kyung (later the Moon Jae-in administration’s first Minister of Environment) and Committee Member Kim Jwa-kwan (now chairman of the board of Korea Electric Power Corporation), reportedly even came in and rebuked them: “We are trying to phase out nuclear power — what is this talk of nuclear exports?” After that, the ministry’s energy and resources officials were replaced across the board, and the nuclear phase-out roadmap came out.

President Moon Jae-in marks the fourth anniversary of his inauguration on the 10th. As the public’s high expectations turn into disappointment, a lame duck (a leakage of power) has recently set in as well. The Moon Jae-in administration pushed through unreasonable policies out of self-righteousness and arrogance, without an elaborate, detailed strategy. Its ongoing policy failures are not just one or two. Soaring housing prices, the jobs shock and income-led growth were the culmination of its policy failures. It splurged money as if the national finances were a bottomless pot, increasing the tax burden on future generations. The current administration takes all the credit, while the next one will have no choice but to clean up after it. The administration ends after five years, but the aftereffects of its hasty, overspeeding policies will linger for a long time. We pick out the three policy bombs set to explode under the next administration, which takes office in a year.

Aftereffects of the Nuclear Phase-Out Set In — Legal Battles over Compensation Worth Trillions of Won

The next administration will inherit the bill for the nuclear phase-out. Shin Hanul Units 3 and 4 were put on hold just before construction began, and Cheonji Units 1 and 2 and Daejin Units 1 and 2 were scrapped. Wolseong Unit 1 was permanently shut down at the end of 2019, throwing away the 700 billion won spent on its full overhaul. Local governments struck by the bolt from the blue of the nuclear phase-out are crying out. North Gyeongsang Province plans to claim damages as soon as it finishes assessing the scale of its losses. Statutory support funds of at least 5 trillion won and lost local tax revenue are the direct losses. Add socioeconomic losses such as reduced employment and restrictions on property rights, and the damage snowballs. Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power must also bear sunk costs of at least 1 trillion won, including the cost of manufacturing the main equipment for Shin Hanul Units 3 and 4 and land compensation for the Cheonji plant. “Ten years of nuclear phase-out would completely destroy the nuclear industry’s ecosystem and even block the path to nuclear exports,” stressed Professor Kim Myung-hyun of the Department of Nuclear Engineering at Kyung Hee University. “The next administration must not hesitate and must immediately resume construction, starting with Shin Hanul Units 3 and 4.”

Raising electricity rates is effectively the only road left. On top of the nuclear phase-out comes the decarbonization policy, making matters worse. The generation costs of liquefied natural gas (LNG) and solar power, which replace nuclear and coal, are two to three times those of nuclear power. Korea Electric Power Corporation has already introduced a “fuel-cost-linked electricity rate system.” Social confusion and conflict are also expected each time an aging reactor reaches the end of its life, over whether to close it or keep using it. Under the next administration, reactors reaching the end of their design life will total six, starting with Kori Unit 2 in 2023.

The Nation’s Coffers Drained by a Fiscal Addiction — A Drag on Running the Country

The National Fiscal Strategy Meeting chaired by President Moon on May 16, 2019. When Deputy Prime Minister for Economic Affairs Hong Nam-ki reported that the national debt ratio would be kept in the low 40% range relative to gross domestic product (GDP), President Moon asked, “What is the basis for 40%?” and ordered that the nation’s coffers be thrown open. Just over four years earlier, it was Moon Jae-in, then leader of the New Politics Democratic Union, who had criticized that “the nation’s coffers have run dry in just three years of the Park Geun-hye administration, which will hand national debt amounting to 40% of GDP to the public and the next administration.”

The next administration is set to climb onto a mountain of debt of not the “40%” President Moon put forward as opposition leader, but “60%.” Fiscal management will be in emergency mode from its very first year. In the three years from 2018, when the Moon Jae-in administration’s first budget took effect, through last year, the cumulative fiscal deficit came to 177 trillion won. On top of that, according to the National Fiscal Management Plan the government released last September, deficits of 109 trillion won and 123 trillion won will arise this year and next, respectively. The five-year cumulative fiscal deficit of 409 trillion won is close to double the combined total of the Lee Myung-bak administration (98.8 trillion won) and the Park Geun-hye administration (129.8 trillion won). The poor fiscal stamina left by the current administration will clearly hold back the next administration’s running of state affairs.

With the sound-finance stance upheld by every previous administration collapsing, the speed at which the nation’s debt is growing is truly dizzying. National debt in the narrow sense (central plus local government debt, D1) will surge from 660 trillion won in 2017, when the Moon Jae-in administration took office, to 965 trillion won this year. Over the same period, the national debt ratio will jump from 36% to 48.2%. The next administration will start out in the “era of 1,000 trillion won of the nation’s debt and a 50% national debt ratio.”

According to the National Debt Management Plan the government released last October, the national debt ratio will leap to 51.4% in 2022, when the next administration takes office, and to 58.7% in 2024. For the next administration, exceeding the 60% national debt ratio set by the European Union (EU)’s fiscal rule is only a matter of time.

Professor Ok Dong-seok of the Department of Economics at Incheon National University said

that “depleted fiscal stamina will seriously hinder the recovery of growth momentum in the post-COVID era,”

voicing concern that “the next administration is likely to suffer from fears of a sovereign credit rating downgrade and pressure for tax increases.”

On the broad measure of national liabilities, which also counts public enterprise debt and accrued pension liabilities, the national liabilities ratio easily tops 100%.

Holes in Health and Employment Insurance — National Pension Reform a Political Detonator

The once-healthy health and employment insurance funds are on the verge of collapse. The health insurance fund, which had posted surpluses throughout, turned to deficit in 2018, when “Moon Jae-in Care” got fully under way. Barring extraordinary measures, it faces the risk of “going bust” under the next administration. The employment insurance fund is barely holding out this year amid a surge in the unemployed. The current administration is pushing for an “era of employment insurance for all citizens,” including the self-employed, by 2025, fueling concerns about fund depletion and contribution increases. Once social insurance funds are depleted, the only options are to fill the gap with taxpayers’ money or to raise contributions. Measures for the fiscal stabilization of social insurance fall entirely to the next administration.

The Moon Jae-in administration showed not the slightest hesitation in spending the public funds built up by previous administrations, yet it did not move a single step forward on National Pension reform, which future generations indispensably need.

When the Ministry of Health and Welfare reported a draft reform based on the 4th long-term National Pension financial projection in 2018, the presidential office ordered a complete reconsideration, saying it “does not match the public’s expectations.”

The reform plan the government prepared anew also fizzled out, pushed aside by the presidential campaign pledge of “pay the same, receive more.”

The longer reform is put off, the heavier the public’s burden becomes.

To keep receiving the National Pension as now while maintaining fiscal sustainability, the contribution rate must be raised from the current 9% to 18%.

If reform is put off for five years, unfunded pension liabilities pile up further by an amount equal to five years’ worth of total contributions.

Unfunded liabilities reached 1,500 trillion won last year.

Yun Suk-myung, President of the Korean Pension Association,

warned that “the golden opportunity for National Pension reform has already been missed,”

and that “now, a normal rate increase at a level the public can bear will not come anywhere close to being enough.”

For the next administration, the task of National Pension reform is nothing short of a political detonator.

The 5th National Pension financial projection falls due in 2023, one year before the next general election, for the 22nd National Assembly.

Having carried out a financial projection that brings forward the date of fund depletion, it will also be hard to put off reform yet again.

The administration may even have to stake its fate on it.

https://m.koreatimes.com/article/1364309

Related Posts