Skip to main content
Pension Future Forum

(SBS Radio, 2013 Decision by the 3rd National Pension Financial Estimation Committee to Raise the Contribution Rate) [Interview] Dr. Yun Suk-myung of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: “Raising National Pension Contributions Only Adds to the Burden” (July 10, 2013)

2026.11.13
(SBS Radio, 2013 Decision by the 3rd National Pension Financial Estimation Committee to Raise the Contribution Rate) [Interview] Dr. Yun Suk-myung of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: “Raising National Pension Contributions Only Adds to the Burden” (July 10, 2013)

[When Center Director Yun Suk-myung

was interviewed by SBS anchor Han Su-jin,

the 3rd National Pension Financial Estimation Committee of 2013

had already decided to raise contributions.

That was because, after a fierce debate

between those who argued for a contribution increase

and those who opposed it,

a vote was taken

and a majority of the members

voted in favor of raising contributions.

But in August 2013, after this broadcast,

a meeting of the Financial Estimation Committee was hastily convened.

The agenda was “a revote

on the contribution increase.”

Because August is the vacation season,

the revote took place while

many members were abroad.

The revote, held while many of the members

who had supported the increase were abroad,

produced a different result from before.

In other words, the result changed

to one that did not favor

raising National Pension contributions.

After this result came out,

Center Director Yun Suk-myung,

who had argued most strongly for a contribution increase

at the 3rd National Pension Financial Estimation Committee of 2013,

declared in that meeting room,

“What happened today must be put on record

so that it is sure to receive

the judgment of history,”

raising his voice.

Now that record is left on the Pension Future Forum website,

in the “Yun Suk-myung’s Columns” category,

under Interviews & Talks.

This is so that it can serve

as a Jingbirok, a chronicle of lessons,

in the history of pension reform debates.]

(SBS News:

Han Su-jin’s Current Affairs Outlook)

“Raising National Pension Contributions

Only Adds to the Burden”

▷ Han Su-jin / Host:

The National Pension System Development Committee, which deals with improving the National Pension, has proposed raising the contribution rate from the current 9% to 13–14%.

To put it simply, an employee earning 1 million won a month, half of whose contribution is paid by the company, now pays 45,000 won but would have to pay 70,000 won in the future. For someone without company support, the burden would rise from 90,000 won to 140,000 won. It may be a pension for one’s own happy retirement, but there is also no shortage of voices opposing it out of concern over the immediate economic burden. Why must National Pension contributions be raised? Is there no alternative other than an increase? We will talk with Dr. Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Hello, Director.

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: Hello.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: The National Pension System Development Committee has put forward this proposal. Why does it say contributions must be raised?

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs:

Let me say first that the government has not yet made a final decision to raise contributions.

It is a recommendation from an advisory body to the Ministry of Health and Welfare. So it still has to go through a public hearing and the National Pension Review Committee, and I do not know whether the government will ultimately accept it. And even if the government accepts it, I do not know whether the National Assembly will.

So many people seem to be looking askance, asking why, when the economy is in such bad shape, we are trying to raise contributions yet again and stir up trouble. As you know, Korea’s National Pension has the best fiscal soundness among the countries of the OECD, that is, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. So why raise contributions? This part may be a little hard to follow, but right now we have accumulated more than 400 trillion won in National Pension reserves. And even if the current system is kept as it is, an enormous 2,500 to 2,600 trillion won is expected to accumulate by 2044. The fund is ultimately expected to be depleted in 2060, and the reason is that Korea has a very unusual population structure. In France, for example, it took 120 to 130 years for the share of people aged 65 and over to go from 7% to 14% of the total population, but in Korea it takes only about 17 or 18 years. Currently there are 6.14 million people aged 65 and over, and around 2060 that number is expected to exceed at least 17 to 18 million. Because the number of pension recipients is rising that fast, even if we do not raise contributions now, the generations aged 45 and over have nothing at all to worry about, since the fund will run out only 47 years from now. But if we delay the contribution increase, will the burden on later generations, the younger generations, not become far too heavy? Experts are raising the issue from the standpoint that responding preemptively is the right attitude for those of us living in the present generation.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: For now, the size of the increase is rather large, is it not?

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: An increase to 13–14% has not been 100% decided either. The National Pension Development Committee is now meeting for the third time. The first was held in 2003, and it meets once every five years: in September 2008, and this year, 2013, for the third time. What we have used as a fiscal stabilization indicator is the concept of keeping a fund equal to about twice that year’s pension expenditure at the end of the final projection year. So in this projection, we set the horizon about 70 years out and project to 2080, and if we assume a fund of about twice expenditure accumulated at that point, that comes to about 12.9%. That seems to be why there are reports of an increase to 13 or 14%.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: Was it not actually designed that way from the start? Can it not be seen as a natural depletion?

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: At first, what we call the income replacement rate is the ratio of the pension you take home to the salary you earn during your working life, as of this year. When the scheme was first introduced in 1988, it was 70%.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: Meaning one could receive close to 70% of the salary one now receives.

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: That was when the scheme was introduced in 1988. But the scheme has since been amended gradually, so as of 2013 it is 47.5%, and it is cut by 0.5% every year until it reaches 40% in 2028. Why is this a problem? In 1988, while offering a 70% benefit rate, we started contributions at 3%. They started far too low. Then contributions were raised by 3% every five years, to 6% in 1993 and 9% in 1998, but there has been no change in contributions at all since then.

For reference, in 2007 the National Assembly put to a vote a plan to raise contributions to 12.9% by 2018, but, unfortunately from our standpoint, it was voted down by a single vote. So the discussion of a contribution increase did not come out of nowhere; it is an issue that has been discussed since previous administrations.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: “The jinxed 10%.” I have heard that phrase too. So there were views that it must keep rising into double digits, but this never came to pass. And you are saying it started out far too low at the beginning. But honestly, the amount people pay has grown somewhat, and you said the benefit rate they get back will be just 40%. Would that not be hard to accept as it stands?

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: But this is truly not a simple problem. You have to think about the menu: if you compare a jajangmyeon menu with a steak menu, there is a difference in cost, is there not?

From the public’s standpoint, many criticize this as nothing more than pocket money. Baby boomers born between 1955 and 1963 joined the pension in 1988, and even as benefit levels come down, they look set to secure a benefit rate of 55% or more, since they started at 70%. The problem is the younger generations joining from now on: they start at 47.5%, are cut to 40%, and contributions keep rising, so many feel that they alone are losing out. But even so, for us to raise again the benefit rate we lowered with such difficulty—

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: But at 40%, will this really help with security in old age? Is it not exactly right to call it pocket money?

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: This needs to be approached from two angles. As recently as 1960, average life expectancy was 58. Now it has risen to 70 to 80, and young women look set to live to 90. So although the benefit rate that replaces income has come down to 40%, if we lengthen the contribution period through measures such as extending the retirement age, pension amounts can grow. Another point: the ceiling on income counted for the National Pension is currently set at 3.98 million won, that is, 20,000 won below 4 million won. If the basis for calculating contributions were raised substantially, pension amounts could become somewhat larger even at the same 40% income replacement rate. I think approaching it that way would be desirable. That is my view.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: Looking at the opposing views as well: if the amount people pay into the National Pension rises like this, low-income people, who are already struggling just to get by, will increasingly drop out, and some say that will in turn widen pension coverage gaps and shake the very purpose of the pension.

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: That is a valid point. Currently a little over 20 million people are required to pay National Pension contributions, and of them, on average about 5 million are unable to pay, because of business failure, unemployment, and the burden of contributions. We are well aware of the many critics who ask whether we are out of our minds: people already cannot pay because contributions are burdensome, so if contributions are raised further, low-income people will leave en masse and the National Pension will be left half-empty. The government, too, is acutely aware of this problem and since the second half of last year has been running a contribution support program for low-income people. It is called Durunuri Social Insurance. Currently, for workers at workplaces with fewer than 10 employees earning 1.3 million won or less a month, the government subsidizes 50% of contributions. We cannot subsidize contributions for everyone in the future, but it seems necessary to gradually expand eligibility and ease the burden of contributions. In particular, there are workers in special forms of employment, are there not? Freelance broadcast writers at broadcasting companies and home-study tutors pay 100% of their contributions themselves, and here too we need to look closely at ways to ease the contribution burden.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: There is also this argument: European countries supposedly pay out that year’s contributions as pensions right away. They say those countries do not pile up nearly 400 trillion won the way we do.

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: That is right. Many of the advanced welfare states we know have run their pension systems on a pay-as-you-go (PAYG) basis. In other words, they collected the pension spending needed in a given year through that year’s taxes or contributions. When population growth and economic growth were high, that system was not much of a burden. But in the advanced Western countries, too, as the older population grows rapidly and economic growth slows while fertility falls, running the system this way has become extremely costly, so many countries are carrying out pension reform. Germany, too, is a country that has typically run its pension system on a PAYG basis, but Chancellor Schröder took sweeping measures to cut pension amounts by 40% over 30 years. Of course, that cost him power, but in that way many advanced countries, in light of population aging, are tending to shift away from pay-as-you-go toward building up a fund, as we do.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: But even now, I understand a considerable share of the National Pension is invested in stocks and bonds. As the fund grows, will our National Pension Fund not also swing whenever the stock market swings? Can the fund really be managed well?

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs:

Many people seem to think that way too. They seem to think we are trying to cover losses from mismanaging the National Pension Fund by raising contributions, but on that point, if the public looks at places like the National Pension Service website, they will see that of the 400 trillion won, 180 trillion won is money made through good fund management. So although there has been criticism of various kinds, our National Pension Fund is known as the best-run fund, so far, among all the pension funds in the world, and going forward, too, it will need to be run well while being made transparent so that you can all look into it properly.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: Let me ask just one more thing. There are also many who say, then reform the Government Employees Pension and the Military Pension first, are there not? Both have run deficits of more than 1 trillion won, and I hear they are being covered by taxes.

▶ Dr. Yun Suk-myung / Director, Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs: Every time a discussion of overhauling the National Pension comes up, there is a very loud chorus of complaints: why pick on the National Pension, of all things? Fix the government employees’ and military pensions first.

But the Government Employees Pension has also been reformed twice. For civil servants hired from 2009 onward, pension amounts have been cut substantially. Where criticism runs high, though, is that for existing civil servants the reform was indeed less stringent than for new hires. There is no small amount of criticism on this. What I would like to say is that almost everyone agrees the Government Employees Pension is not sustainable, unless they are simply being obstinate. So only if the Government Employees Pension takes fiscal stabilization measures commensurate with the efforts made in the National Pension will the public understand, I think. So rather than taking sides, it would be good to fix each system in turn.

▷ Han Su-jin / Host: Yes. I see. We have been talking with Center Director Yun Suk-myung of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Thank you. 


Source: SBS News


Original link: https://news.sbs.co.kr/news/endPage.do?news_id=N1001876324&plink=COPYPASTE&cooper=SBSNEWSMOBEND

(Another link to the same item)

https://mnews.sbs.co.kr/news/endPage.do?newsId=N1001876324

Attachments

Related Posts