(KBS Radio) [KBS Empathy Debate] “The State of Preparation for Old Age and the Tasks for Strengthening Old-Age Income Security” (February 15, 2017)
![(KBS Radio) [KBS Empathy Debate] “The State of Preparation for Old Age and the Tasks for Strengthening Old-Age Income Security” (February 15, 2017)](/uploads/editor/2026/11/010d6e65087b45b38dc2e9543e122d66-3503374_F6R.jpg)
Panel (in Korean alphabetical order) ▒
Kim Dong-yeop, Director: Mirae Asset Retirement Research Center
Kim Yong-ha, Professor: Department of IT Finance and Management, Soonchunhyang University
Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow: Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs
Jeong Chang-ryul, Professor: Department of Social Welfare, Dankook University
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Hello, everyone. This is Baek Un-gi of KBS <Empathy Debate>. Quite a few of our regular <Empathy Debate> listeners are advanced in years. Today, <Empathy Debate> will debate preparation for old age. Our society is aging truly rapidly, but it is a fact that preparation for old age falls woefully short. They call this the age of living to 100, and to reach old age with no provision at all and then live to 100 would be dreadful even to imagine. Today on KBS <Empathy Debate>, we have invited experts to consider the problems with the current old-age income security system and what can be done about them. Issues worth the name! Debate worth the name! KBS <Empathy Debate> begins now!
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Today on KBS <Empathy Debate>, we will diagnose where the National Pension, retirement pension, and personal pension schemes stand now, and think together about what solutions are needed to strengthen the old-age income security system.
We invite our listeners to take an active part. We have many experts with us today, so those of you with questions, please join in by phone or text message.
Let me introduce today’s panelists. Center Director Kim Dong-yeop of the Mirae Asset Retirement Research Center is here with us. Hello.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes, hello.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Good to have you here.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes, good to be here.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
A retirement research center must be one of the institutions attracting the most interest these days?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
These days, a large share of the people who do business with financial institutions are older people, and many are also preparing for retirement, so we get a great many related inquiries.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Is it not the richest part of Mirae Asset, by any chance?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Not really. It is a place that gets a lot of interest, though.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Well, we look forward to hearing a lot of good insights from you today.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes, certainly.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
We also have Professor Kim Yong-ha of the Department of IT Finance and Management at Soonchunhyang University. Hello.
□ Kim Yong-ha
Yes, hello.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Have you been well?
□ Kim Yong-ha
Yes.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Good to see you. We also have Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs. Hello.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Hello.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
How long has it been since we last met?
□ Yun Suk-myung
About a month now,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, I think it has been about a month. Good to see you.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Last time I left my scarf behind, and thank you for finding it for me.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. How have you been in this cold weather?
□ Yun Suk-myung
I have been well.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, and Professor Jeong Chang-ryul of the Department of Social Welfare at Dankook University has joined us. Hello.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, hello.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, thank you for coming. Shall the four of you greet one another before we begin?
□ Panel
Good to see you.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
For a long life to be a blessing, one must be amply prepared for old age. Old age met without preparation is a disaster. How well prepared for old age are our citizens? Before the debate, let us first listen to the voices of citizens.
(Citizen interviews)
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, “I did not know time would pass so quickly”—many people worry, but I am not sure how well prepared they are. The citizens’ voices were uniform: anxiety about old age is great, but they are not preparing properly—we heard voices in which one could feel that kind of regret. In fact, Koreans’ average life expectancy is 82.1 years, about ten years longer than 20 years ago, but for a long life to be a blessing, one must be correspondingly well prepared. There are also quite a few cases of people who were middle class when they were young but fall into poverty as they enter old age. Center Director Kim Dong-yeop of the Mirae Asset Retirement Research Center, you must come across such situations often—are there in fact quite a few cases of people falling from the middle class into poverty as they grow older?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Not that many cases have been reported in Korea yet, but there are many people with a very strong latent anxiety about what is called old-age bankruptcy. It also came up in the interviews just now. What it amounts to is this: there are the costs of maintaining the most basic standard of living, right? If, for example, a pension paid for life covered those costs, that anxiety would be considerably less, but because lifetime income falls short of basic living expenses, people have to draw the shortfall from somewhere else. Then a lot of people seem to worry, “What if the source I am drawing from runs out first?” So while the immediate shortfall is a problem, I think the anxiety that there will be a shortfall in the future may actually be the bigger problem.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
When people make inquiries to the retirement research center or ask out of interest, what is the biggest topic?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Usually, when it comes to pensions, people have paid a lot in, and they wonder a great deal about how to receive them.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
How best to receive them.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes—how should I receive my National Pension, how should I receive my severance pay so that I get more and pay less tax, what is the best way to receive my personal pension. In other words, people are far more interested in receiving than in paying.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That makes sense. I hope you will tell us about those things as we go on. Professor Kim Yong-ha, you are at a university now—how long do you have left until the retirement age?
□ Kim Yong-ha
I think I have about nine years left.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That is quite a while. I suppose you are not yet taking it very seriously.
□ Kim Yong-ha
Even so, I am worried.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
How are you preparing?
□ Kim Yong-ha
First of all, I have been paying contributions very steadily into the public pension run by the state. Then, some of the personal pensions I took out in a small way from the mid-1990s have matured, and I have also been taking out additional new ones. In that way, I am simply trying to put every bit of money I can toward preparing for the future.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
If you of all people are worried, Professor, what are other people to do?
□ Kim Yong-ha
In any case, though I do not know how things will finally turn out, doing as much as I can gives me peace of mind about the future. It is also something that lets me feel reassured.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Professor, how serious do you diagnose the problem of insufficient old-age income in our society to be at present?
□ Kim Yong-ha
This is something I feel after about 30 years of research on pensions: there is not a single person who does not worry about old age. Those with high incomes worry in their own way about how far they can maintain their standard of living, and those with somewhat lower incomes worry in their own way that they will still need at least some minimum income. Those already retired who could not prepare worry about how they will make a living, and those in their 40s and 50s approaching retirement worry in their own way that they are not yet sufficiently prepared and need to prepare more. People in their 20s and 30s, too, worry about what will become of the National Pension later, and whether they will really be all right in old age. So I think there is no one, in any age group or any income bracket, who does not worry about old age.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung, I understand you wrote your doctoral dissertation on pension issues.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, I wrote about the public pension system of the United States. I wrote about the public pension system and our country’s current health insurance system. The systems are slightly different, though.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
How long ago was that?
□ Yun Suk-myung
I wrote my dissertation in 1997,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
So that was 20 years ago.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Back then, when I said I was writing a doctoral dissertation on pensions, people around me asked whether I could make a living from pensions after going back to Korea—I think it was a time when pension systems were that unfamiliar. But as our population has aged rapidly, the older population has grown a great deal, and preparation for old age, and the need for it, have come to the fore across the board, so now quite a few of the friends who majored in money and banking or international finance back then tell me that I chose my field well.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Now there must be many who envy you.
□ Yun Suk-myung
I do not know about envy, but at any rate I make a living.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Anyway, it seems you had foresight. Now, Dr. Yun, the baby-boom generation was generally seen as entering old age as of 2016, last year, was it not?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. Our baby-boom generation consists of three groups, and the baby-boom generation we usually refer to is the first baby-boom generation, born between 1955 and 1963; the number of people varies slightly depending on the estimate, but it comes to about 7.3 million. Although the official retirement age in our labor market has been extended to 60, people leave their main jobs even before 50, and roughly around 55, so I think we should see the first baby-boom generation as now leaving their main jobs in the labor market in earnest.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. So in the end, we are now gradually entering a super-aged society, are we not? In fact, to some extent we have already entered it.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes, next year we enter an aged society. As I recall, we are expected to enter a super-aged society, in which those aged 65 and over exceed 20% of the total, in 2026. In countries like France, the transition took about 130 years, but for us it is about 18 years, or 15 at the earliest. Because the older population is surging over such an extremely short period—whereas in other countries people had enough time to prepare for old age by watching from youth how older people lived—here older people struggle in their own way, and those who will become old before long have no real mentors in life either, so neither prepares properly for old age, and there seems to be a great deal of anxiety on that score.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That would be a problem. So there is no one to teach you and no one to learn from.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Because of this peculiar situation, in which, in such a short time, the fathers’ generation and the children’s generation must grapple with preparing for old age at the same time, many citizens seem to be heavily exposed to anxiety about old age.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
We are considering how inadequately people are prepared for old age. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, I would like to ask you about this. The number of older people living alone is increasing, is it not? According to a Statistics Korea survey, households of older people living alone account for 32.9% of all older-person households—roughly one in three. Is this not also something worth worrying about?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, that is right. Looking at past data, in 1981 the share of older people in Korea living with their children was 80.3%. And as recently as 1990, the share of what we commonly call older people living alone was only about 8.3%, so the current figure can be seen as very high by comparison. Of course, among them are cases of people living alone who receive support from financially capable children, but on the whole, the tendency to depend on family in old age can be seen as steadily weakening.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, one could say dependence has weakened, and in fact, more and more people are unwilling to live together.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, of course. Culturally, too, the very idea that one naturally lives with one’s parents, or lives with them for a certain period, has weakened a great deal today.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Just now, Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung pointed out that because aging has progressed so suddenly and rapidly, there is also the aspect that we have entered the age of aging without properly learning how. One of the reasons the number of older people living alone is increasing is, in a way, aging—people often talk about the sandwich generation—the previous generation was supported by their children, was it not? But these people are not cared for by their children, and though they themselves supported their parents, they are now alone; such cases have increased, have they not?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, that is right. Academically, this is often described as the process of transition from an agrarian society to an industrial society. In an agrarian society, there was a system in which I naturally supported my parents and my children would support me in old age, but with the move to an industrial society, that pattern of transferring old-age income within the family can be seen as having weakened greatly.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. In any case, the situation is this serious, yet many citizens are not properly preparing for old age. Statistics Korea, the Financial Supervisory Service, and the Bank of Korea released the results of last year’s 2016 Survey of Household Finances and Living Conditions, and according to it, one in five households responded that they were not preparing for old age. A survey by the National Assembly Budget Office also found that citizens’ level of preparation for old age is poor overall, and that people are less prepared for old age particularly among the baby-boom generation aged 50 and over, and the lower their levels of education and income. Professor Kim Yong-ha, why do you think people overall are not preparing, or cannot prepare, for old age?
□ Kim Yong-ha
First, preparing for old age is a matter for the future, whereas making a living now is a problem of the present. In fact, the economy is tough right now, but first there is today’s food and shelter, and in Korea’s case, an even bigger problem than one’s own living is children’s education, and once you have educated your children, you have to get them married, and by the time you have married them off, you are already old. By then you are no longer in a position to prepare. So basically, because people are preoccupied with getting by in the present, they end up unable to prepare sufficiently for the future—that is how I see it.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, Professor Kim Yong-ha has analyzed that people are too busy making ends meet to prepare properly. Is there perhaps another analysis?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
The cause you mentioned seems to be the biggest. If you just live with whatever comes your way, children’s education, marriage, and the like come first, and it is hard enough just to handle those. So preparing for old age is quite difficult, and that requires some support at the national or institutional level. But the reason the current baby-boom generation and older generations are somewhat anxious or unprepared seems to be related to when Korea’s three-tier pension system took hold.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
The three-tier pension system.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes. The National Pension lays down the first tier as the base, and it was introduced in 1988. Next, the retirement pension is the second tier, and it was introduced in December 2005. Then pension savings were introduced in 2001, and even counting the old personal pension introduced before that, it goes back only to 1994.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That is what is called the three tiers.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes. So many of those who have already retired do not benefit from these three tiers of pensions, and many have at most the National Pension—just one pension. It must have been rather difficult to cover all their living expenses with that alone. In particular, because most of these pension systems are structured so that contributions are paid in proportion to income, as was mentioned earlier, the higher one’s education and income levels, the better prepared one is, whereas conversely, those with lower education or, for example, lower incomes end up in a more vulnerable position—that also seems to emerge as another problem.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul and Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung, is there anything you would add to this analysis?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Basically, there is a serious lack of awareness of the need to prepare for old age, and this is commonly called myopia.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Myopia.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. So everyone thinks that when they become old, they will not live very long, and that they will not be very ill. But when people actually grow old, they live much longer than they expected, and they are often ill. That is why, as was said earlier, people tend to focus only on current spending needs and the like, and fail to look ahead to how long their old age will last or how it will unfold.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Because life expectancy in our country has risen over a very short period, many people seem to feel at some point, “I did not know I would live this long.” There is a saying that a well-prepared old age is a blessing, but an unprepared old age is a disaster, is there not? In that context, as the Center Director mentioned earlier, it is true that on the surface we introduced the National Pension scheme in 1988, but at that time it was introduced mainly for people working at relatively stable workplaces employing ten or more people. It was only in April 1999 that the scheme was introduced for the general public. Some may say that April 1999 was already some 18 years ago, but with a pension system like the National Pension, you have to be enrolled for at least ten years to receive a pension. Those who were already in their 50s at the time had little opportunity to enroll, and even if they enrolled, their contribution periods were short, so their pension amounts were small—there is that institutional aspect of our system. Another is a problem of public attitudes: in the past, it was an open secret in our country that you made money by doing the opposite of government policy, was it not? Then one day, out of the blue, people were told to pay contributions for a pension system they had never heard of, the National Pension. Many people, those working at stable workplaces, simply paid because it was deducted from their pay. But people who had to pay voluntarily, such as the self-employed, thought, “Is this not just the government collecting taxes under the name of the National Pension because it cannot collect taxes?” With so much distrust, they did not pay their contributions. So those who need old-age income the most were unable to prepare, and that seems to have become a very big problem now.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Hearing that point, I find myself nodding a lot. As a result, we have ended up facing old age truly unprepared. Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, has any survey come out regarding, say, adequate living expenses or minimum living expenses in old age?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Many institutions conduct surveys, but the most frequently referenced are the data surveyed jointly by the National Pension Research Institute and the National Pension. Among them, looking at the data from last year’s survey, there is something called minimum living expenses. Minimum living expenses are the cost of maintaining the most basic standard of living in old age without any particular illness, and according to the survey, for a married couple living together, it is about 1.74 million won a month?
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
1.74 million won.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes, and the survey says an individual needs about 1.04 million won a month. This is strictly the minimum living expenses; for households living a somewhat better, fairly ordinary life, there is a statistic called adequate living expenses, which comes to around 2.37 million won for a couple and about 1.45 million won for an individual. But when I go out into the field to counsel people, I ask a lot, and until recently—just two or three years ago—the most common answer was 2 million won.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That one could live on 2 million won.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes, but these days quite a lot of people seem to say about 3 million won. So there is a slight gap from these figures, but ordinary people seem mostly to answer somewhere between 2.5 million and 3 million.
□ Yun Suk-myung
If I may add something,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung.
□ Yun Suk-myung
As a research project commissioned by the Ministry of Health and Welfare, I surveyed 3,000 households over three years—I carried out this project three times. It is a 2012 report, and as the Center Director mentioned, it was around 2013; a few years have passed, but because incomes have stagnated lately, there does not seem to be much difference. So, on a household basis, that is, for a couple, people paying National Pension contributions seem to see minimum living expenses as about 1.9 million won, and adequate living expenses as about 2.9 million won. So there are slight differences depending on the survey period, but in general, about 2 million won, and 3 million won, is the usual,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That survey seems to strike a little closer to home?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Because this is a survey of 3,000 households nationwide that we conducted three years in a row, I think it is fairly reliable.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, so when you meet people and ask them face to face, they say they had about 3 million won in mind, is that not so?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Homemakers usually say about that much.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, then the survey results Dr. Yun Suk-myung mentioned seem close to that.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Lately people seem to give somewhat higher figures. Just two or three years ago, many people said about 2.5 million, or 2 million, but these days they say a bit more.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
But these amounts, too, ultimately assume good health, do they not?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
That is right. They assume a normal level of medical spending in a healthy situation.
□ Kim Yong-ha
But what we need to consider somewhat carefully is,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Professor Kim Yong-ha.
□ Kim Yong-ha
Yes. In fact, figures like 3 million or 2 million are based on middle- and upper-middle-income earners. Among ordinary people, many in their 40s and 50s, even while working, do not earn 2 million won a month on average.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, that is right.
□ Kim Yong-ha
And a considerable number of people who are struggling earn only 1.5 million or 2 million won now, so putting expected old-age income at 2.5 or 3 million is speaking by the standard of the upper-middle income bracket; ordinary people cannot even dream of that. They usually think that if they had even about 1 million to 1.5 million, then in old age—it would certainly not be ample—they could at least live a minimal life. So because this differs considerably by income bracket, it is something we have to talk about very carefully and cautiously when explaining it.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, should we see the uses of the amounts in these survey results as including, for example, if a couple lives together, housing costs such as monthly rent, housing maintenance fees, and expenses for family occasions—all of that?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, that is right. Naturally, it can be seen as the sum of all the basic items.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
What should we see as taking up the largest share in old-age living?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
They are the basics we all know so well. Housing, food, clothing, and shelter are the most basic, and there can also be transportation costs. And the item that varies the most but is extremely important for older people is medical expenses; that can be considered a very important item.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Medical expenses. Yes, while we are thinking about preparing for old age, a KBS breaking news report has just come in. According to intelligence sources, Kim Jong-nam, the half-brother of North Korea’s Kim Jong-un, has been killed. Kim Jong-un’s half-brother Kim Jong-nam has been killed. Yes, that was a breaking news report.
Let us continue. Professor Kim Yong-ha, the money needed in old age comes to a minimum of 1.9 million won and an adequate 2.9 million won or so, but not that many people are preparing other old-age provisions besides the National Pension, are they?
□ Kim Yong-ha
Yes, that is right. In fact, the National Pension is less something people prepared than something compulsory: because its contributions are social insurance, people pay them compulsorily, so in a sense it happens without their knowing, whether they want it or not. Beyond that, the old-age preparation people can choose for themselves is personal pensions or retirement pensions, but to join a retirement pension, normally you have to be at a workplace with five or more employees (recently severance pay has come to apply to workplaces with one or more employees as well), and only when such a workplace is covered can you join a retirement pension. And most of the people, a large share of them, cannot even do that. What is more important, people who joined a retirement pension also have the capacity to join a personal pension, but usually people who find it hard to join a retirement pension do not have the capacity to join a personal pension either. As a result, while some income groups can prepare to some extent on all three tiers, the National Pension, retirement pensions, and personal pensions, among the self-employed, those who have their own National Pension plus a personal pension are relatively well off, and many cannot even manage a personal pension; statistics show that they make up as much as two-thirds overall.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, that is actually the case, is it not? Not many people have other provisions besides the National Pension, do they?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
I looked at data from a survey of the baby-boom generation, and households in which the head of household has only the National Pension are about 41%,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
41%.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
About that much. Then there are those where the spouse has only the National Pension and the head of household has none. That is about 2.3%, so together you can take it that about 43% or 44% have only a first-tier pension.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung, will this level of provision be enough?
□ Yun Suk-myung
The biggest problem is that as neoliberalism has become rampant in our society and very free trade has taken place worldwide, the problem that has emerged, income polarization, income polarization during the working years, is very serious, is it not? What we also need to look at with great interest is this: there is a tendency to approach things through averages, and here too, it seems we need to be very careful with averages. Our Center Director did not emphasize this point earlier, but just like our income polarization during the working years, polarization in old-age preparation is also very serious. People who have worked at stable, decent workplaces are now preparing for old age at a considerable level (it would be hard to go so far as to say their preparation is overflowing), and since the tax credit ceiling for personal pensions and retirement pensions combined is about 7 million won a year, some people contribute up to that much, whereas most people at the middle-class level and above contribute maybe about 2.5 million won, if that, within the 7 million won tax credit limit. That is including retirement pensions. What this implies is that while a small group within Korea’s entire economically active population prepares very well for old age, as the middle class shrinks, the share of the income people earn that they can spend as disposable income keeps shrinking, so although retirement pensions are paid in by employers, the amount paid into personal pensions seems to keep falling. So while it is important for us to look at this in terms of averages, it seems necessary to approach separately the weakening old-age preparation of the shrinking middle class and the near-total inability of the vulnerable groups below the middle class to prepare for old age, the National Pension included.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, so we need to think about the National Pension’s income replacement rate, but first, please explain the concept of what the income replacement rate is.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
The income replacement rate can be described as measuring how much a person receives from the pension relative to the average income he or she basically earned while economically active.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. But in the case of the National Pension, the income replacement rate comes to 40% when you have paid in for a full 40 years without missing a single payment, does it not?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. To be precise, the 40% income replacement rate for 40 years of contributions actually applies to those contributing from 2028, and at present it is somewhat higher than that, but in any case, it is true that it is heading toward that figure in the long term.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. So going forward, if someone joins the National Pension at 20 and pays contributions without interruption until 59, the income replacement rate cannot but fall further, can it?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, that is right. Because the National Pension is proportional to the contribution period, contributing for a long time is very important. In the current labor market, the age of entry into the workforce is getting later and later, employment is becoming more unstable, and early retirement is becoming widespread, and because of these problems, the likelihood that the working period, the National Pension contribution period, will become shorter is quite high. So, as we will have a chance to discuss later, rather than solving this with the pension system alone, how to steer the labor market situation so as to lengthen the contribution period is also a very important topic.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Dr. Yun Suk-myung.
□ Yun Suk-myung
I think I need to add a supplementary remark. There may be a point that listeners could misunderstand. Anchor Baek Un-gi, did you not join KBS before 1988?
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That is right.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Then if I explain the income replacement rate using Anchor Baek Un-gi as the example,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I am very curious.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. The National Pension system was introduced in 1988 for workplaces with 10 or more employees, so you joined the National Pension then. From 1988 to 1998, you were covered not by a 40% income replacement rate but by 70%.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, it was like that then.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Then from 1999 to 2007, you were covered by 60%. In 2008 you were covered by 50%, in 2009 by 49.5%, and so on, falling 0.5 percentage points every year, so until you retire, Anchor Baek Un-gi, you are guaranteed an income replacement rate of at least 43% however low it goes, and if we take the average over your entire period of National Pension contributions, in my view your income replacement rate would come to about 60%.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Is it that much?
□ Yun Suk-myung
So relatively older people do not need to worry about a low income replacement rate in that respect, but instead there seems to be the problem that their contribution periods are relatively short. And for the young people who will join in the future, it falls to 40% in 2028. For them, unless they can lengthen the contribution period considerably, the pension amount could become so small that it is truly hard to make a living. So, as Professor Jeong said, the absolute figure of the income replacement rate matters, but going forward, they say it is the era of living to 100, do they not? It seems we should approach it by replacing that with a correspondingly long period of working, and with a correspondingly long period of paying National Pension contributions over that time.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
But why does the income replacement rate keep falling?
□ Yun Suk-myung
When we introduced the income replacement rate originally at 70%, back then we did not live long, so if people received the pension from age 60, we thought they would receive it for about seven or eight years and then stop; that was at the time the system was first introduced. But we live very long now, do we not? Now people receive the National Pension from 61, and from next year from 62, and these people usually receive the pension for 15 to nearly 20 years. And when the beneficiary dies, the spouse then receives 60%. So each person receives it for anywhere from 20 years on average to at least 25 years or more; the pension system was designed on the expectation that people would receive it for seven or eight years, and because that much more money goes out, and because people said they could not pay more in contributions since their incomes were no longer rising, the pension reform was carried out in the direction of lowering the income replacement rate people receive.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
But Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, there are calls now to readjust this National Pension income replacement rate, are there not?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. There is that view as well.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Why is that?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Well, it is exactly as Dr. Yun said. Compared with people who joined from the 1980s, the income replacement rate of those entering the labor market in the future is expected to be too low, so there are voices asking whether National Pension benefits for them should not be increased somewhat.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, from the standpoint of the old-age income security function of public pensions, do you consider the National Pension’s current income replacement rate adequate?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
We need to consider various things. If you want to give a lot, you have to collect a lot, right? Income has to grow for there to be room to raise the income replacement rate somewhat, and I do think about that, but what I think about is that to raise the income replacement rate in substance, it seems necessary to eliminate many of the coverage gaps in the National Pension. For example, as was said earlier, people who work at a company and do things properly have the National Pension, a retirement pension, everything, but those who cannot, for example young people who have not yet found a job, or full-time homemakers, or those who retired early and have no income, cannot pay even if they want to, so no matter whether the income replacement rate is 40% or 50%, the benefit goes out in proportion to income only if contributions are paid, does it not? So it seems to be the moment to consider a variety of ways to close those coverage gaps, for example giving some recognition for military service, or recognizing more time for childbirth as part of the contribution period. A variety of such systems should be considered.
□ Yun Suk-myung
All of that involves tax money, and I am speaking a lot, but I think I need to interrupt. First, the contribution period of the National Pension is very important: we said it falls to 40% in 2028, did we not? But 40% is the income replacement rate when you have contributed for 40 years. And in the labor market, it is rare for someone to work at one workplace for 40 years, is it not?
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
It is not common.
□ Yun Suk-myung
So if someone works for about 20 years and pays contributions for only 20 years, the income replacement rate falls not to 40% but to 20%. Because this is a very big problem, there is now talk of reforming the labor market so that people can stay at work longer and thereby lengthen the contribution period. Another important point is this: Anchor Baek Un-gi, since you work at KBS, you must be a high earner, but the income the National Pension recognizes is only about 4.4 million won a month. If, for example, that were recognized up to about 7 million or 8 million won, then even at the same 40% income replacement rate, the pension amount could double. One of the reasons it cannot be raised is that, although many people are dissatisfied with the National Pension, it is a system in which people receive more than they paid in, so raising the ceiling that way would worsen pension finances accordingly. So if we adjust contributions appropriately and raise the income on which pensions are calculated somewhat further, to about 5.5 million won compared with now, then even with the same income replacement rate, pension amounts increase a great deal. It seems necessary for many of our citizens to understand this and to make efforts to build a consensus on overhauling the pension system.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Using my case so much makes it easy to understand, but please stop mentioning it. Every time you do, I get nervous. Professor Kim Yong-ha, Center Director Kim Dong-yeop spoke of coverage gaps in the National Pension; what measures do you think are needed to reduce them?
□ Kim Yong-ha
Coverage gaps in the National Pension arise, first of all, in the labor market. Basically, if you have a job, you join the National Pension, but if you have no job, a situation arises in which you basically cannot join the National Pension. And even if you join the National Pension, you need to contribute fully, but in fact, if you cannot keep working fully along the way, there may be many cases where you fall short of about 30 years. In particular, this appears along gender lines. For example, the difference between men and women: whereas men mostly contribute almost their whole lives, with a long period in which they can contribute to the National Pension, women usually leave their jobs when they marry or give birth, and as a result they stop contributing to the National Pension, and so a gap in income security arises between men and women. In the past, there was a time when, on a household basis, it was enough for, say, just one of the two, one spouse of a married couple, to join the National Pension. For example, it was 70% earlier, was it not? Back then, even if only one of the two worked, the couple could make a living in old age, but now that it is falling to 40%, it can no longer work that way, and times have changed so that both spouses need to join. So if in the past the concept was one pension per household, now it is a system of one pension per person, and the government is steering toward that concept. Contributors, too, must not think, “My husband is enrolled in the National Pension, so I do not need to join.” The wife, for her part, should join the National Pension through voluntary enrollment or in various other forms, and in this way coverage gaps should be closed. Even so, for low-income people, however hard they try, it does not work. In that respect, in old age, Korea has a system called the Basic Pension. So when people turn 65, if their pension is too small or nonexistent, a system guaranteeing a minimum income was created in 2008, and it supplements that somewhat. But to fill out the contribution period further, as I mentioned earlier, we already have systems such as the childbirth credit and the military service credit, recognizing about one year of the military service period as contribution period, and, when people give birth, extending the number of contribution years by one, two, or three years depending on the number of children.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Shall we hear Professor Jeong Chang-ryul’s opinion on adjusting the National Pension income replacement rate and on what measures are needed to reduce coverage gaps in the National Pension?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. Basically, I have the same view, so I do not think I have anything in particular to add, but the National Pension is a really difficult problem. In the case of the National Pension, there is continuing concern that because the income replacement rate has fallen so low, it will become difficult to live on the National Pension alone in the future. On the other hand, the National Pension is criticized as a pocket-money pension, but in fact the current structure is one in which people on average receive close to twice what they paid in, so without an agreement on raising contributions, raising benefits is in fact quite difficult fiscally; all of these aspects have to be considered, and when the government makes policy, measures such as adjusting the income replacement rate could be considered on the premise that it can, for instance, make a persuasive case to the public for raising contributions.
□ Yun Suk-myung
If I may,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Dr. Yun Suk-myung, please help us out.
□ Yun Suk-myung
After a very fierce debate from 2014, we reformed the Government Employees Pension to some extent in 2015, and what was said a lot at the time, what government employee contributors said, was that it was not that they received a lot, but that the National Pension had been cut too much, so instead of saying the Government Employees Pension pays a lot, we should raise the National Pension again and bring public pensions to an equalization toward the middle; this once became a social agenda. So the idea was to raise the National Pension income replacement rate back to 50%, but as Professor Jeong said, this is not a simple matter. Because this could not simply be resolved, the Special Committee on Strengthening Public Pensions and Alleviating Old-Age Poverty was set up in the National Assembly in the second half of 2015. I say this because I served on that committee: looking at it objectively, many stakeholders easily say that since it was cut too much, it should be raised back to 50%. But even with the current 40%, reached in 2028, contributions must be raised to about 13% for us to sustain this system. If the income replacement rate were raised back to 50%, contributions would have to rise to 17.5% in the long term. In practice, not many people can pay contributions like that, can they? So receiving matters, but we also have to consider the burden, and within that limited framework, it seems we need to think about how we will secure old-age income so as to actually live stably in old age.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. You are listening to KBS <Empathy Debate>. Today’s debate topic is measures for preparing for old age.
Let me introduce today’s panel. We are joined by Center Director Kim Dong-yeop of the Mirae Asset Retirement Research Center, Professor Kim Yong-ha of the Department of IT Finance and Management at Soonchunhyang University, Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, and Professor Jeong Chang-ryul of the Department of Social Welfare at Dankook University.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Let me read some of the text messages our listeners have sent, and then we will continue the debate.
The listener with the mobile phone number ending in 9958: “I have three children. Between sending them to school and paying for their studies, we are so busy making ends meet that we have no room to prepare for old age.” Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, there are many people like this, are there not?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Most people are like that.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. As you said earlier, it would be different if they worked at a company and the company compulsorily enrolled them in a pension and deducted it, but among those who have to do it on their own, it seems there are many who fail to make such provisions and later face real hardship.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
People usually ought to think about these things a lot in their 30s and 40s, but because they are busy making a living, in practice they cannot. But among recent statistics related to the National Pension, an interesting one is this: there used to be a system called the lump-sum refund, under which you could withdraw it all at once as a lump sum when you left your job, before 1999. There was a news article reporting that last year the number of people who had taken that money and are now paying it back, as old age approaches, was the largest ever, and there are also reports that full-time homemakers voluntarily enrolling in the National Pension are increasing a lot among people in their 50s. So when you see more people who could not prepare in advance scrambling to take care of it as retirement approaches, you can sense their desperation.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Can you pay it back and receive it as a pension again?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes, that is possible. Before 1999, the lump-sum refund system allowed people, at the time they left their jobs, to receive at one time the pension amount they had accumulated, and at the time people were pleased because money came in right away, but now, preparing for retirement as they approach it, they see that others have pensions while they have none, or that even if they have one it falls short; so when you see the growing number of people who pay back what they received then, with interest added, to increase their pensions somewhat, it seems that for people now in their 50s, the determination to secure old-age income somehow is rather desperate.
□ Yun Suk-myung
To help temporarily with the baby-boom generation’s insufficient old-age preparation, the government also has a measure that allows people who, around the time of retirement, near age 60, think their National Pension contribution period is insufficient, to pay five years’ worth of National Pension contributions at once as a lump sum, so those with some means could use that system to secure a stable old-age income.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Let me continue reading the text messages. This is listener Kim Yun-hak, who sent an opinion via KONG. “You are having a very good debate. I am a 69-year-old woman. I receive about 500,000 won from the National Pension. I have no old-age income to speak of besides the National Pension, but because my National Pension benefit is considered large, I cannot receive the Basic Pension either. As you get older, medicine costs a lot too, and life is hard. Even though I have four children, they are all struggling to get by, so it is hard to get help from them either. Improving the public pension system is urgent.”
The listener with the number ending in 9236: “I think the reason old-age preparation is insufficient is distrust of the National Pension. In the course of selling personal pensions, insurance companies often compare benefit amounts and say that National Pension benefits are small. How do they compare when you look at the income replacement rate?” Who would like to answer this? Center Director Kim Dong-yeop.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
In the past, there seem to have been cases where some financial companies marketed that way, but in fact it has changed a lot nowadays. That is because you cannot cover your old-age living expenses with the National Pension alone, and you cannot cover them by paying into a personal pension alone either. So nowadays the explanation seems to be largely along the lines of combining them well to build the living expenses you need, presenting them not as substitutes but as complements.
□ Yun Suk-myung
I am sorry to keep speaking, but because this is a matter of the private perspective versus the public perspective, I keep speaking up: part of the reason vague distrust of the National Pension arose was that when personal pensions were first introduced in 1994, insurance agents went door to door planting a vague distrust, saying the National Pension’s finances were unstable so people would not get it later. Now, those who run retirement pensions and personal pensions do not say that; they argue that we should move to a multi-tiered income security system. But what I really want to point out now about pension amounts, and make clear to listeners, is that the pension amounts mentioned here for the National Pension are in real value. So, for example, if 1 million won is paid now, that 1 million won is not a nominal 1 million won but 1 million won in real value, so 20 years from now, depending on the rate of inflation, it could become 2 million won; that is the kind of amount it is. Because this has not been properly explained, there is a lot of distrust, with people asking why the National Pension is only pocket money, only small change, but listeners should properly understand this point. I will say this categorically: the National Pension offers a higher rate of return than any financial product that exists in Korea.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Is that so?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Professor Kim Yong-ha, can we trust what Dr. Yun Suk-myung says?
□ Kim Yong-ha
Well, the fact is that, especially now that we are in an era of low interest rates—in the past, in the era of high interest rates, there was a time when people could expect that if they deposited a lump sum and drew it as a pension through a bank or a securities firm, they would receive a lot. But now that interest rates are as low as 2%, talk that “pensions are the only way to survive” and “a pension is as good as a dutiful son” already seems to be circulating naturally among ordinary people.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. The listener with the number ending in 8824: “I think I paid into the National Pension diligently, but my pension amount is in the 400,000-won range. The National Pension is all I have, and I am really worried about my old age.”
The listener with the number ending in 8968: “I think it would be good to provide education on preparing for old age from childhood. When I was young, life in retirement seemed far off, but having experienced it, I found it was not so. If people build habits of planned spending and a sensible lifestyle from childhood, I think they could prepare for old age early on.”
The listener with the number ending in 1053: “The welfare plan for older people must be readjusted. I think it would be good to drastically cut unnecessary elderly welfare items and pay monthly living expenses to older people aged 65 and over.”
The listener with the number ending in 1283: “I wish the government would pay National Pension contributions on people’s behalf, limited to those who are struggling.”
The listener with the number ending in 4516: “Old-age income security is an important issue, but I oppose the argument that the government must step in. There are also many people who steadily save even in difficult circumstances to prepare for old age.”
Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung, I would like to hear your opinion on this point: that it would be good if the government paid National Pension contributions on behalf of people who are struggling.
□ Yun Suk-myung
That is already being done. People say this because they do not know about it. We have what is called the Durunuri Social Insurance, so for the National Pension and
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
What social insurance?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Durunuri Social Insurance. Durunuri means that the whole nation should enjoy the benefits of a good system together, which is why it is named the Durunuri Social Insurance. And right now, when a person whose monthly income is, I believe, 1.45 million won or less works at a workplace with fewer than 10 employees, the state is already subsidizing 50% of the contributions they have to pay. That is the Durunuri Social Insurance, but what is regrettable here is that it supports only workplace-based insured persons, that is, only people who work for a company—and there are many people among us who are struggling, are there not? People such as parcel delivery drivers and home-study tutors, for example, work for CJ Korea Express—the company name is Korea Express—but they have to pay 100% of the contributions themselves, so although they need to prepare for old age, they are unable to pay contributions. Then there are the people who really run street stalls; some street vendors earn a lot of money, but most of them are struggling, are they not? If they too want to pay National Pension contributions, they have to pay 100% themselves, and right now we are not helping them. So what we keep working toward is to say that the government should subsidize 50% of contributions for those struggling workers in special types of employment and for truly low-income self-employed people, and members of the National Assembly are in fact now pushing such bills.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. I hope that helps the listener with the number ending in 1283.
Let me introduce just one more. Listener Kim Chang-ju: “Instead of investing the National Pension elsewhere, what about building public housing and leasing it to older people on a long-term basis? Then I think the problem of elderly poverty could be solved without raising the National Pension’s income replacement rate. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, please give us your opinion.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, that is something that has come up a lot. But this too is a really difficult matter. The National Pension Fund—today’s debate is not on the fund, but I recall that we also held a debate on the fund on our program before—the National Pension Fund now holds more than 500 trillion won, and there has been a lot of talk that buying stocks and bonds with it is itself already at saturation, so it would be good to invest it in social areas, that is, to make social investments such as housing, hospitals, or long-term care facilities for older people. That is partly valid, but as things stand socially—looking at Samsung and the like, too—the rules on investing the National Pension have been made very strict, and adjusting them is a really difficult problem, so how far such social investment can go is also a difficult subject that requires a great deal of discussion, in my view.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Let us continue the debate. We have been talking about the National Pension, and earlier you mentioned the three-tier pension, did you not? The National Pension, retirement pensions, and personal pensions. And there is continuing talk that we must build a multi-tiered security system by linking these public pensions and private pensions. I would like to hear your position on this. Professor Kim Yong-ha, would you speak first?
□ Kim Yong-ha
Well, as I said earlier, most people already agree that, because the benefit level of the National Pension scheme keeps falling, the National Pension alone will not be enough. So the general consensus is that, to supplement it, the shortfall in the income replacement rate must be filled with private pensions—retirement pensions or personal pensions. However, small-scale self-employed people and the self-employed in general find it difficult to join a retirement pension in the first place. So they need to supplement with personal pensions. And for ordinary wage workers, it is generally thought that if they prepare by composing the National Pension, retirement pension, and personal pension roughly in a 3-to-3-to-3 ratio, they can have a somewhat more stable old age. That is, the 40% income replacement rate of the National Pension we mentioned earlier is based on a 40-year contribution period, so with 30 years of contributions it is only 30%. And since that too is 30% of lifetime income, in practice it is only about 20–25% of income just before retirement. So, in the end, to secure about 50–60% of pre-retirement income, if people prepare about 20% from the National Pension, 20% from the retirement pension, and 20% from a personal pension, they can have about 60% of their pre-retirement income in old age, and at that level they could live without a sharp drop in their standard of living even after retiring—that is what we explain in theory, but the reality is that not that many people can actually do this.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Dr. Yun Suk-myung, what is the situation abroad, in the advanced countries?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. Advanced countries also differ by country; we can divide welfare states into about three types. According to Esping-Andersen’s classification, the countries with the “life with evenings” we often mention, countries like Sweden, are called the Northern European or Scandinavian type; another is called the Continental European type; and another the Anglo-American type—so there are three welfare-state types. Among them, the countries often talked about as advanced countries where older people live very stable lives in old age, the countries where public pensions usually play a large role, are the Scandinavian type and, although it is changing somewhat now, the Continental European model. Then which type do we belong to? Our pension system has not been in place for long, but because we have been heavily influenced by the United States, we fall on the Anglo-American side, and in Britain and the United States—especially in Britain—what has a big influence on old-age income security is that private pension schemes play a very large role, especially for the middle-income and higher classes. As a result, it seems difficult for us to set our direction, our coordinates. On one side there is the argument that we should strengthen public pensions beyond what they are now to make old-age income solid, while, as Professor Kim Yong-ha said, there are also people who argue for going 3-to-3-to-3, making the shares of the National Pension, retirement pension, and personal pension similar. If I may state my position: what international organizations recommend in many cases is that securing about 70% of working-life income as sources of old-age income allows a stable life, so on that view it seems good for public pensions to account for about 40% of that 70% and for retirement pensions and personal pensions to account for 30%. The problem is that, although 8.3% a month is now paid into retirement pensions as contributions, they are managed at such low interest rates that a proper income replacement rate does not come out of them. I think the Center Director should explain this part a little.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. I would like to hear about it.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
If you look at the background to our country’s introduction of the retirement pension scheme, we originally had a statutory severance pay system, right? It is a system under which the law requires that workers who have worked for a year or more be given, for example, about one month’s wages as severance pay, but it had a problem with entitlement—that is, workers could not collect it if the company went bankrupt—and because people withdrew it as a lump sum and spent it, it could not be used as a pension, so the scheme introduced to address this was the retirement pension scheme, introduced in December 2005. Under it, for each year of service, the company is required to give the worker at least one-twelfth of a year’s wages. Then, although it differs somewhat by scheme, in some cases the company manages it, and in some cases the worker manages it directly. Earlier you talked about returns and about interest rates in relation to the replacement rate; the type the company manages is called DB, for “Defined benefit,” that is, the defined benefit type, and in this case the company manages it, right? For the person in charge, the burden is very heavy. There are problems such as the person in charge having to take responsibility if mismanagement causes losses, and so it is managed very conservatively. In addition, there is an annual accounting close, and in the process of measuring losses on a yearly basis it is not easy to make long-term investments and the like, so most of it is invested in safe assets and it is being managed mainly in deposits, but as interest rates have fallen, those returns are not great. Then, in the case called DC, which the worker manages, the worker can invest the money in equity funds or bond funds, or in deposits and savings, but because investment culture is still so immature, the share of deposits and savings is quite high from the workers’ side, and interest rates have fallen. It has been only a few years since investing in equity funds and the like was opened up. In the past, workers could invest in what are called balanced bond funds, which put about 40% or less into stocks. But in practice, recently most of the assets under management have been managed with a domestic focus. Yet there is the problem of the domestic stock market being stuck in a box range. Then there are also problems such as being managed against the overall index and not being able to invest in a variety of funds, and as a result returns are somewhat poor. And the evaluation criteria are far too short-term—three months, six months, one year. As a result, it is not easy either for the people managing it or for the companies managing it.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, do you also acknowledge the need to strengthen the function of private pensions?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. But I would like to give a little background. I agree that we have no choice but to move to a multi-tiered security system, but I want to talk about the context. If you look at the situation in the advanced countries, after World War II poverty among older people was the biggest social problem, and for that reason they designed very generous pension systems. Then, after doing this for about 40 or 50 years, elderly poverty was no longer a major social problem; instead welfare was strengthened for other problems—family problems, single-parent family problems, and the like—and with the attitude, “Then should the state not scale back its role in income security for older people and leave the rest for individuals to take care of themselves or for companies to handle?” the direction has been to shrink public pensions somewhat and increase individual responsibility. In Korea’s case, though, it would be problematic to leap to the logic, “Western countries are cutting public pensions too, so Korea must cut them as well.” If the discussion goes along the lines that, because additional coverage from the National Pension will be difficult in Korea from now on, retirement pensions must partly take over and supplement that role, then I believe moving to a multi-tiered old-age income security system is a very desirable direction.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
But Dr. Yun Suk-myung, we introduced the retirement pension in 2005, right?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
But the enrollment rate is not very high, is it?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. With the retirement pension—when people used to receive severance pay, once there is money, as the saying goes, seeing is wanting, so they spend it elsewhere, do they not? They spend it on their children’s weddings and on buying them homes, and then they cannot sustain their life in old age, so the government decided this could not go on, and there were also recommendations from international organizations, so the scheme that converted it into a pension so that people cannot take it as a lump sum and spend it all at once is the retirement pension scheme. As for why the enrollment rate is low: you have to work at a stable workplace to receive severance pay, and you have to receive severance pay to convert it into a retirement pension, so inherently the enrollment rate cannot help but be very low. To solve this problem, the government, despite many difficulties, has made it mandatory for newly established workplaces to introduce a retirement pension, and it seems the share of retirement pension enrollees has increased a lot compared with before. But what I was trying to say earlier is this: as Professor Jeong said, because the National Pension falls short, we must make the National Pension solid while building retirement pensions and personal pensions on top of it—that is something everyone can agree on—but one thing I want to make clear to the listeners is that there are a great many misunderstandings about the National Pension right now. Because the National Pension takes a beating for no reason. Though that is because other political issues are mixed up in it. But what I really want to say is that the current National Pension contribution rate is 9%. And the National Pension’s income replacement rate is now 46%, is it not? Of course, the retirement pension is different, since its income replacement rate is based not on the lifetime average but on income just before retirement, but while the National Pension guarantees an income replacement rate of 46% with a 9% contribution, the retirement pension’s income replacement rate barely reaches 20% even with an 8.3% contribution. Nevertheless, it is the National Pension alone that keeps taking a beating. I think our citizens need to understand this point properly. That is what I wanted to say earlier.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Does anyone have a different view? Yes. Professor Kim Yong-ha, the Ministry of Employment and Labor said it would expand eligibility for the individual-type retirement pension from July this year, did it not? How do you assess this measure?
□ Kim Yong-ha
It is a very desirable measure. That is because, until now, our retirement pension has been something people join as a group. For example, if you work at a company A, the employees of company A join the same plan, at the same financial institution—one financial institution—so when a person leaves, they join again at the financial institution used by their next workplace, and so rather than continuing their enrollment each time they join, they may cancel midway or settle up, and as a result there was the problem that retirement pensions did not keep accumulating. So rather than that approach, now, if everyone joins individually with their own personal account, even if they change jobs the personal account they joined carries over with them and they can keep accumulating, so in that respect there is the advantage that the contribution period can keep getting longer. So for retirement pensions and for the National Pension alike, the key to a pension is long-term enrollment. In the past, long tenure was possible, but now long tenure is no longer possible, so there could be many cases in which retirement pensions fail to serve as pensions in that respect; if this individual-type retirement pension scheme becomes somewhat more active and stable, the likelihood that more pension savings can be accumulated through such retirement pensions can be said to rise.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Center Director Kim Dong-yeop.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Let me add to what I said earlier. The retirement pension scheme, in a way, has its deepest roots in statutory severance pay. That is, its foundation is depositing that severance pay with a financial institution and collecting it later, and there are two kinds of individual-type retirement pension. People change jobs often, right? There are cases where people take the severance pay they received each time they changed jobs and spend it right away, so it does not become old-age income. So the first purpose is to put it into an individual retirement pension account—called IRP for short—and enroll with the aim of drawing a pension later; in a way, if people put in all the severance pay they received while moving between several companies and draw it as a pension after age 55, it can become old-age income, so that is one advantage. Another, second purpose is that many people who felt the severance pay the company contributes was not enough also enrolled in the individual-type retirement pension in order to save more. To encourage this, as mentioned earlier, a tax credit is given up to a limit of about 7 million won, but the problem was that, among workers, only those enrolled in a retirement pension can currently join. So even among workers, those not enrolled in a retirement pension cannot. On top of that, the self-employed cannot either, and as these problems kept being pointed out, from July 26 this year the self-employed can join, and people not enrolled in a retirement pension can also join, save more, and receive a tax credit; in that this path has been opened, it seems to be a very substantial improvement in terms of equity.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Since you have brought it up, I would like to hear a bit more explanation. A considerable number of our citizens do not really understand the retirement pension scheme. You mentioned IRP, the individual-type retirement pension, and I hear that retirement pensions also come in a defined benefit type and a defined contribution type—how do they differ?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Every time this question comes up, I find it really awkward. There are just so many of them. Let me explain briefly: among the retirement pension schemes, the one most similar to severance pay is the defined benefit type, called DB for short, and you can think of it as exactly the same as the existing severance pay system. There are just two differences. The first is that this money is not kept inside the company but deposited with a financial institution, so that even if the company goes bankrupt or has such a problem, the entitlement is guaranteed to some extent—that is what differs. If you ask how someone enrolled in a retirement pension receives the benefit, they receive an amount calculated in exactly the same way as the existing severance pay. But since the company manages it, the management could go wrong, right? Then the company makes up the shortfall. If there is something left over—if the management goes well and there is some surplus return—the company takes that too; that structure is the defined benefit type, so you can think of the method of calculating severance pay as the same. In contrast, there is something called the DC type, which is called the defined contribution type, but because that is too difficult, I just describe it as the worker-managed type,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
The worker-managed type.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
It is much easier to understand, right? Each time a year passes, the company puts the severance pay that has accrued—we talked earlier about 8.3%, one-twelfth—about one month’s wages for a year of service, into a virtual account in the worker’s name. Then the worker chooses for themselves how to manage the money that has come in. They can buy deposits, they can buy funds, they can buy insurance—that is their own choice. Over time, then, even people who joined on the same day and left on the same day can end up with different amounts depending on management performance; that scheme is called the defined contribution type. So if returns are poor, the individual must bear the responsibility, and if returns are good and they receive more, the individual takes that too—that structure is what you can think of as the defined contribution type. So broadly there are two main types: the defined benefit type, or company-managed type, and the defined contribution type, or worker-managed type—you can think of it as about these two—and as a supplement, you can refer to what I explained earlier about the individual-type retirement pension.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Now that I have heard the explanation, I understand. Then, Dr. Yun Suk-myung, the most important thing is which one is best.
□ Yun Suk-myung
From the worker’s standpoint, the defined benefit type is better. What the Center Director described is the defined benefit type and defined contribution type on the retirement pension side, so there is a slight difference in nuance from public pensions such as the National Pension. Let me explain the defined benefit type and the defined contribution type once more from the standpoint of public pensions. The defined benefit type, as when we talk about an income replacement rate of 46%, regardless of how much one pays in contributions—by law 9% is now paid, so that is settled—determines in advance roughly what level of benefit will be paid. The defined contribution type, on the other hand, fixes only the contributions paid in and pays the pension amount according to the returns earned by investing in the market. So if the capital markets are very bad, returns fall sharply. So from the insured’s standpoint, it goes without saying. The defined benefit type is 100% superior and very good. But to maintain the defined benefit type, the government carries the factors of fiscal instability forward by having future generations bear part of the burden and by taking responsibility itself, but the private sector cannot do that, so there is a tendency to keep trying to shift to the defined contribution type.
□ Kim Yong-ha
Well, actually, as I see it—you said the defined benefit type is better, but each individual’s situation is different. For example, if a company has large step increases in pay, there is a big wage gap between starting pay and pay at retirement, and one works at a workplace with a high rate of wage growth, DB may be advantageous, but
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
The defined benefit type.
□ Kim Yong-ha
Yes, the defined benefit type may be advantageous, but in cases such as contracting on an annual-salary basis, or where wages barely differ between starting pay and final pay, DC may be more advantageous. In the end, it is a contest between whether the rate of wage growth or the interest rate is higher. And depending on the period, in a period of high interest rates DC is advantageous, and when wage growth is high, DB is advantageous. So, uniformly—our ordinary workers prefer DB, but in fact DB is not necessarily better.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
If I may add something,
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Since the two of you have split in your views, the listeners are probably curious too, so if Center Director Kim Dong-yeop and Professor Jeong Chang-ryul could also share your views, it would help our listeners.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
I agree with what was just said, but if you ask why people have lately been stressing the importance of the defined contribution type a little more, it is this. For example, the number of workplaces that have introduced a wage peak system is growing. The problem that arises is that, under the defined benefit type, severance pay is calculated by multiplying the salary just before retirement by the number of years of service. But once a wage peak system is introduced, the years of service may increase, yet the salary in the final year falls, so severance pay goes down. Workers can end up working longer and receiving less severance pay, so in such cases, even a company with a defined benefit type scheme should, it seems to me, also introduce the defined contribution type and give workers the option to switch. You also mentioned annual salary systems. Under an annual salary system, pay goes up and down according to performance, right? A company has to retain good people, and if it pays a talented employee a large salary in a given year, what does that employee start thinking about? The employee’s severance pay goes up, because that year’s salary is high. But if there is no guarantee that the employee will get that much again the following year, the employee may feel the urge to cash out the severance pay. Because of these various problems, as pay systems become more flexible, there are also many who argue for introducing the DC scheme.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Please explain it well so that our listeners can judge for themselves. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. DB or DC: this is a way of determining benefits, but it is also a question of who will bear the risk. Under the defined benefit type, that risk is shifted onto the company. Under the defined contribution type, the worker who made the investment decision has to bear that risk. But it is genuinely difficult for an individual to make investment decisions. So I agree with everything Professor Kim Yong-ha said. Preferences can certainly differ depending on how fast wages rise, but because the problems that arise from bearing all of that risk under the defined contribution type are considerable, I believe that in general the defined benefit type is by far the better choice for workers.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. You are listening to KBS <Empathy Debate>.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
We continue with KBS <Empathy Debate>. We have looked at how retirement pensions might be improved, and we have also considered what would help raise returns. Dr. Yun Suk-myung, you mentioned the three-tier pension earlier. Let us look at the situation of another component, personal pensions. Enrollment in personal pensions is also rather low at the moment, is it not?
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. Put simply, personal pensions, too, are directly tied to the problem of income polarization, as I said earlier. The combined annual ceiling on the tax credit for retirement pensions and personal pensions together is about 7 million won. Those who fill that 7 million won are mostly high earners, and the overall average amount paid in usually hovers around 2.5 million won, as I mentioned earlier. So a fairly large problem arises depending on income bracket. As for personal pensions, the government is pursuing a variety of policies to promote them. Led by the Ministry of Economy and Finance, it has drawn up promotion measures and is working hard to attract subscribers. Of course, because we are in such a low-interest-rate era, asset managers cannot earn high returns on personal pensions. It would be good if I spoke on this after our Center Director does. But the problem in our society now is this: the government in its own way, and individuals, because they lack sources of old-age income, are trying to supplement the National Pension with retirement and personal pensions to secure an adequate income, yet what they pay in hardly grows relative to the principal. Part of that is unavoidable given low interest rates, but one thing I really want to say, and it is a painful point, is that the financial institutions that manage personal pensions always collect their fees. Subscribers, on the other hand, sometimes end up with just their principal, or even a loss, because interest rates are low. I am not trying to condemn or criticize personal pensions, but in hard times this system has to be run in a way that shares the pain among all parties if it is to become more active.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, there are many kinds of personal pensions, are there not?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes, that is right. The reason people get confused about pensions is that there are so many types and so many different names, but
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Is that because financial institutions develop the products?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Pension products are fundamentally often created on an institutional, legal basis. Typically, some financial products give you tax support when you join. Products that offer benefits like the tax credit mentioned earlier are typified by pension savings products. Other pension products do not offer such a tax credit, but there are pension insurance products that are tax-exempt when you join. So, broadly, they can be divided into pension savings, which qualify for the tax credit, and pension insurance, which exempts the accrued returns from tax if you keep it for 10 years or more. They also differ by what they invest in. There are interest-rate-linked products that try to guarantee principal and interest as far as possible, and there are products such as variable insurance and variable annuities that invest in assets like stocks and bonds to earn higher returns. They are also divided by how the pension is paid out. If you want to receive a pension until you die, there is the lifetime annuity. If that does not suit you and you would rather set a specific period, 10 years or 20 years, and receive the principal and interest in installments, there is the fixed-term annuity. For people who want to leave the principal untouched and take only the interest, there is something like the inheritance-type annuity. So there are many types, and it is good that there is a wide range of choice to pick what suits you, but because there are so many, it does seem confusing.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Kim Yong-ha, pension products have long enrollment periods. There must be many things to keep an eye on over that time. Please give us some advice.
□ Kim Yong-ha
Above all, it is important to set a goal: how much money you will secure for your old age. Once you set that goal, you have to plan how to pay in pension contributions in line with it. And especially in Korea, paying in to the pension is important, as we said, but it is also important to choose strategically what form of pension you will receive once the payments are over: whether to take it as a lifetime annuity, or as a 10-year fixed-term annuity, or as a 20-year fixed-term annuity. In Korea, people have so far joined personal pensions almost entirely to get the tax benefits, so they have given almost no thought to what form they will receive the pension in during old age. Nobody knows how long they will live given their state of health, but even so, each person has to make their own plan. And since a married couple lives together, there is also how the couple should coordinate, and then there are pensions where, if you die while receiving them, the remainder can simply be left to your children, and others where it cannot. So, while your own knowledge of these matters is important, it is also important to design your pension with expert advice.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, some point out that because personal pension take-up is so low, the government ought to step in to raise enrollment in personal pensions. There is talk that Germany increased the number of personal pension subscribers by providing subsidies. What do you think of such an approach?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
That needs to be examined carefully; Germany is a very special case. Unlike Korea’s National Pension, Germany’s public pension itself was a purely earnings-related pension with almost no income redistribution function. In Germany, too, as public pension finances became strained, the public pension was cut back substantially, and because it was cut all at once, concerns arose that old-age income would fall. So the government introduced measures to have individuals join personal pensions, called Riester pensions, and to induce low-income people to join by giving them a certain subsidy. Comparing countries, enrollment among low-income people in that personal pension is very high, but there is a limit in that it is hard to say low-income people as a whole have benefited from the scheme. That is because it is, after all, a voluntary scheme.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Dr. Yun Suk-myung.
□ Yun Suk-myung
I feel I am speaking too much, but on the personal pension side, the private sector has been raising many arguments that, since mainly high-income people benefit, low-income people ought to benefit too, so we should introduce something like Germany’s Riester pension, in which the government subsidizes contributions. I do sympathize with that to some extent. But there is a fundamental difference between Germany and Korea. In Germany and in many of the welfare states we know of, the great majority of citizens are enrolled in a public pension, the national pension, and build up private pensions on top of it, whereas in Korea many low-income and vulnerable people are left out of that first step, the National Pension. So if the government is to subsidize contributions, in my view it should first subsidize contributions so that people can join the public pension, the National Pension. Then, if there is capacity left over, moving on to supporting vulnerable groups in private pensions as well, like Germany’s Riester pension, seems to be the right order.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
May I add just one more word?
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
As Dr. Yun said, there are limits to applying a case like Germany’s to Korea. We basically talk of a multi-tiered system, but it is not that “a multi-tiered system means low-income, middle-class, and high-income people all receive all three pensions.” In the experience of advanced countries, the principle is that low-income people benefit primarily through the public pension, through its income redistribution function, and Korea’s National Pension is designed that way to a certain extent. Germany adopted that approach of having the state subsidize personal pensions to induce low-income people to join because it is a special case, and I should say that introducing that approach in Korea does not quite fit.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. This is a field many people are very interested in, and you have sent us many text messages. Let me introduce some of them before we wrap up.
The listener with the number ending in 9924: “But tell me, would it not be enough just to save diligently without joining a personal pension?” Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, what do you think?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Saving a lot is good, of course, but if you are going to save anyway, I think it is better first to use schemes that offer tax benefits, schemes that let workers get a certain amount of what they paid in refunded.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
So a personal pension is much better than savings?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
That is right. If your goal is old-age income, being able to get 13.2% or 16.5% of the amount you saved deducted at the year-end tax settlement can be seen as far more advantageous. Especially with interest rates this low.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, Professor Kim Yong-ha.
□ Kim Yong-ha
The problem is the operating expenses. As was said earlier, whenever you join a personal pension, whether at an insurance company or an ordinary bank, you pay that financial institution a certain fee. If you stay enrolled for a long time, you can come out ahead even after the operating expenses are deducted from what you gained in tax benefits, but if you stay enrolled only briefly, you not only fail to get the tax benefits but also just pay out more in operating expenses, and that is where the problem arises. So, appropriately, the key is not to join as much personal pension as possible just because you have money right now, but to keep paying into personal pension savings at a level you can sustain, without canceling midway. Only if you do not cancel can you get the tax benefits and more than make up for the operating expenses.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, what advice would you give?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. When comparing pensions with savings, the advantage of a pension is that it is, quite literally, meant to insure against the risk of longevity. Savings cannot solve the problem of living a long time. But a pension, assuming you receive a lifetime benefit, can insure against longevity, the risk of living a long time, and that can be seen as a far greater advantage than savings.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Dr. Yun, too.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. It is the same with pensions: back in the 1990s, because interest rates were high, even those enrolled in the Government Employees Pension took a lump sum, put it in the bank, and enjoyed the high interest, did they not? Now that we have entered a low-interest-rate era and people live long, many of them feel very unhappy about it. The greatest advantage of a pension is that, although private pensions do not guarantee all of this, at least public pensions pay out every month without fail, like a salary, until death, and when the pensioner dies they continue paying part of it until the spouse dies. Because of these features, at least as a level of old-age income security, it can be seen as a good system that savings cannot compare with.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. The listener with the number ending in 1915: “During the debate it was said that the National Pension earns better returns than other financial products. That is actually what worries me. The National Pension places a burden on future generations, and with low fertility and population aging this serious, how long can the National Pension remain sustainable? Young people will probably not get the returns they expect from the National Pension; will this not lead to social conflict?” Dr. Yun Suk-myung, I think you will have to answer this one too,
□ Yun Suk-myung
I have been speaking a lot, but I say this because I am heavily involved in the financial projection: the government is not sitting idle. We introduced the pension system in 1988, but because we are aging so fast, there was concern that leaving the system as it is would place too heavy a burden on future generations, so a financial projection system was introduced to check the pension’s financial condition every five years, and next year the fourth financial projection will be carried out. At that point, I expect the government will put forward a reform plan so as not to place a heavy burden on future generations and so that the system remains sustainable. I do not think you need to worry too much.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Next is the listener with the number ending in 4874: “My spouse and I are each enrolled in the National Pension, but I heard that if one of us dies, only one pension can be received. That seems somehow unreasonable; is a reform of the system not needed?” Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, please answer this one.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Yes. This concerns the survivors’ pension. The survivors’ pension varies somewhat with the enrollment period, but when a person insured under the National Pension dies, the survivor is entitled to receive up to 60% of the amount the deceased was receiving. But if both spouses are enrolled in the National Pension, one of the two has to be chosen. For example, when one’s own old-age pension and a survivors’ pension overlap and one’s own old-age pension is larger, one can give up the survivors’ pension, right? In that case there is a small supplementary measure: about 30% of the amount given up is added on. So such complementary measures exist, and the survivors’ pension itself is, in general, rather strongly a welfare function attached to the old-age pension. It would be good to look at it with that in mind as well.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Listener Lee Jae-mun, who sent in a comment through KONG, writes, “Retirement pensions are good because you can get an income deduction at the year-end tax settlement. How about strengthening the benefits a bit more to increase their effect in preparing for old age?” Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, what do you think?
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes. Tax benefits matter in retirement pensions. Our textbooks even say that tax benefits are the engine and the brake of private pensions, so they are important, but if they are strengthened too much, well, tax benefits are, after all, a use of tax money. Because they are tax expenditures, the government also has to give full consideration to the fact that strengthening them too much actually has an adverse effect on income redistribution.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. Let me introduce just one or two more, and then we will hear closing remarks.
The listener with the number ending in 8693: “The returns on personal pensions are so low that I hesitate to join. How about introducing a scheme in which the state adds extra interest to personal pensions?” Professor Kim Yong-ha, is that possible?
□ Kim Yong-ha
Realistically, I think that would be difficult.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. The listener with the number ending in 8488: “It does not seem easy to keep a retirement pension going. These days workers often change jobs, and it is hard to carry a retirement pension over. Quite a few employers abuse retirement pensions, too. Reform of the system is needed, including stronger employer responsibility.”
The listener with the number ending in 9958: “Thank you for the good remarks and for so much useful information.”
Thank you to all the listeners who took part by text message.
Today on KBS <Empathy Debate> we have considered old-age security schemes. We have talked a great deal about pensions in particular. It is now time to wrap up. We have discussed many things, but since we have experts here, it would be helpful if you could tell us anything you feel you really must say today for a desirable old age and for old-age income security. Center Director Kim Dong-yeop, you deal with this a lot in the field; may I ask you for a few good words? One minute each, please.
□ Kim Dong-yeop
Personally, there are many dual-income couples these days, are there not? I think old-age income and pensions should also be organized on a dual-income basis. It is the same idea as the “one pension per person” mentioned earlier. Statistics say that if each spouse has all three tiers of coverage, they will have an income above basic living expenses. Of course, that will be hard. So let us prepare our pensions, too, in the spirit of each earning an income; I would like to put forward the idea of dual-income pensions.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Dual-income pensions. Yes, and today the three-tier security system came up; would it be important to mix those tiers well with one another?
□ Kim Dong-yeop
The most important part is this: there is the income that comes for life, built on the National Pension, is there not? I think each spouse needs to make an effort to make that at least cover the costs of food, clothing, and shelter, the most basic standard of living. If lifetime income reaches at least that level, I think much of the burden of life in old age can be eased. So, when setting a personal goal, it would be good to look first at what one’s most basic living expenses are and to think hard about what it would take to generate, for life, an income exceeding them.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
I see. Professor Kim Yong-ha.
□ Kim Yong-ha
One of the biggest reasons we are not preparing well for old age is investment in our children. People spend whatever money they have, and money they do not have, on their children, so in most cases they have not prepared for their own old age or for their old age as a couple.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
That is right.
□ Kim Yong-ha
So now we should take a step back. We should of course do our best for our children. But the time has come to think about our own old age, and our old age as a couple, as well. In the past, if you simply devoted everything, your children would in turn support their parents, but that is not the era we live in now. The era has come in which children must live their own lives and the couple must live its own. So I would like to say that the time has come to work hard for our children and invest in their education, but also to invest while thinking of ourselves.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes. I suspect quite a lot of listeners are nodding along, “So true, so true.” Professor Jeong Chang-ryul.
□ Jeong Chang-ryul
Yes, to put it briefly. I did not get to talk about it today, but the retirement pension is very important. In fact, its contributions are high, comparable to those of the National Pension, yet apart from the tax benefits and the like it is not well linked to old-age income. The most important reason is that Korea’s retirement pension system, although it is called a private pension, can be seen as a quasi-public scheme with a very strong public character, and yet aspects such as interim settlement, lump-sum withdrawal, and protection in the event of bankruptcy still fall short of what the scheme’s goals require. So I think that if the state plays a strong role in those areas, it can take root as a scheme that fully supports the National Pension.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, thank you. Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung, please give us your closing remarks.
□ Yun Suk-myung
Yes. They say the era of the 100-year life has arrived, do they not? This 100-year life means a second career, as they say, so the old-age period has lengthened accordingly, and people must feel a great deal of anxiety to the extent that they have not prepared properly for old age. But you can only live life once. So we have to prepare thoroughly in advance, and to prepare, the state, individuals, and businesses must cooperate well. For people who can prepare adequately for old age on their own means, the government should use appropriate schemes so that they actively enroll. Next, for people who cannot prepare for old age because their income during their working years is insufficient, the state should help them build sources of old-age income through contribution subsidies and the like. And as for businesses, I know businesses are struggling now, but to prepare old-age income, people have to stay in their jobs for a long time, do they not? So, even if it is painful, businesses too should employ workers for longer so that they can stay enrolled in pension schemes for longer. I think that moving to a system in which each party cooperates while sharing the pain would be the way to get through this difficult situation.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Yes, thank you for your remarks.
Today on KBS <Empathy Debate>, as we enter an era of population aging, we have diagnosed the problems of old-age income security schemes. Many listeners will have heard today’s debate as a subject right in front of them. As with everything, better safe than sorry, is it not? Old-age issues, and preparation for old age in particular, determine the basic quality of life, so I think preparation is all the more necessary.
My thanks to the four panelists who joined today’s debate: Center Director Kim Dong-yeop of the Mirae Asset Retirement Research Center, Professor Kim Yong-ha of the Department of IT Finance and Management at Soonchunhyang University, Research Fellow Yun Suk-myung of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, and Professor Jeong Chang-ryul of the Department of Social Welfare at Dankook University. Thank you for your hard work.
□ Panel
Thank you.
□ Baek Un-gi / Host
Our deep thanks also go to the listeners who took part via the internet and text message.
