<YTN Radio, Hot Issue> “The National Pension in Crisis... What Are the Issues and Solutions?” — Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, and Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, Dankook University, February 15, 2013, 8:50 p.m.

<Friday Special Economy Hot Issue>
“The National Pension in Crisis... What Are the Issues and Solutions?”
- Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Population Strategy Research Institute, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs
- Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, Department of Social Welfare, Dankook University
< Part 3 >
Anchor:
As of the end of last December, the number of National Pension contributors is said to be 20 million, is it not? Beneficiaries number 3.4 million, and the fund is said to have accumulated 390 trillion won. Our National Pension has grown into one of the world’s three largest pension funds in a period so short it is unprecedented anywhere in the world. Yet the equity issue between those enrolled in the National Pension and those not enrolled, the controversy over equity between the current generation and future generations, and the suspicion and distrust surrounding how the National Pension is run: the many issues surrounding the National Pension now show little sign of dying down. Today, in the Saengsaeng Economy Friday Special, [The National Pension in Crisis: What Are the Issues and Solutions?], we will go through them one by one and talk them over with you. Listeners, if you have any questions, please send them in while we are talking, and we will take time to put your questions to our two experts and have them answered. Please do not hesitate at all to send in your questions. Let me introduce the two guests who will join us today. Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Population Strategy Research Institute of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, is with us. How do you do?
Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center, Population Strategy Research Institute, Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (hereafter Yun Suk-myung):
Yes, hello.
Anchor:
Yes. And Professor Jeong Chang-ryul of the Department of Social Welfare at Dankook University has joined us. How do you do?
Professor Jeong Chang-ryul, Department of Social Welfare, Dankook University (hereafter Jeong Chang-ryul):
Yes, hello.
Anchor:
Would the two of you also like to greet each other?
(The guests greet each other)
Anchor:
First, let us sum up where our National Pension stands today. Dr. Yun first: when we first introduced our National Pension, what did it aim for, and what was the long-term plan?
Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. Our National Pension system is very similar to the way we have developed in the economic sphere: it has gone through highly compressed growth, so there seems to be a fair amount of distrust because of the public’s expectations of the National Pension system and the not-insignificant side effects that appeared in the process of growing so fast. But I would also like to say that, if you look closely, there are things it is doing properly in its own way given our circumstances. Let me start with the history and then speak briefly about the current situation.
Anchor:
Yes. Please go ahead.
Yun Suk-myung:
Originally, our National Pension system was to be introduced around 1972 or 1973 as a system called the National Welfare Pension. Unfortunately, because of the first oil shock, which broke out around 1972, and the second oil shock, which broke out in the late 1970s, the economic situation was very bad, so the introduction was postponed. So it was first introduced in 1988. At that time the system was not introduced for everyone; it was introduced first at workplaces employing 10 or more people. Then, as the system was gradually extended, it was expanded in April 1999 to people self-employed in urban areas, and the era of a so-called pension system for the whole nation arrived. So nominally, formally, the era of pensions for the whole nation arrived, but as you know, Korea has many self-employed people, so incomes cannot be identified and there are not a few loopholes in how the system operates. Looking at enrollment now, the total number of people eligible for the National Pension is a little over 20 million. Of those, to enroll in the National Pension you first have to have income, right? And people without income, for example those whose business failed or who lost their jobs, have no income, do they?
Anchor:
That is right.
Yun Suk-myung:
If such people were forced to pay into the National Pension while they had no income, there would be enormous discontent, would there not? So what was introduced to take that into account is the contribution exemption system. So on average, of the roughly 20 million eligible, about 5 million are not paying contributions for reasons such as business failure or job loss. Another problem: the National Pension counts about 20 million as the total eligible population, but another problem raised in our society is that a considerable number of people who do not work in regular jobs, such as full-time homemakers, yet who count as part of the economically active population, are left out. For example, there are people who help out briefly at restaurants, are there not? They do work, but their income is not large, so it is hard for them to pay National Pension contributions; all such people together, including full-time homemakers, come to about 8.3 million. So under this National Pension system, those now paying contributions number about 14 or 15 million, and those not paying, though fewer than that, are of a similar number. In a way, that can be a very great difficulty in running our system. Next, when the National Pension system was first introduced in 1988, there is what is called the income replacement rate. The ratio of the National Pension amount one receives after retirement to the monthly wage one received during one’s working years is called the income replacement rate, and when we introduced it in 1988 we introduced it at 70%. Why was it introduced that way? Back then there was high growth, people had a lot of children, and the future looked rosy. Instead, as for contributions, because the people of our country tend to have a lot of distrust of government policy, there was concern that if people were made to pay a lot of contributions from the start, they would say, “Is this not the state collecting yet another tax under the name of the National Pension?”, and compliance with the system would fall sharply; so at first it started with a 3% contribution rate. But by the principle of a balance between contributions and benefits, as private insurance applies it, it should have collected contributions of 20% or more; yet it was thought that collecting high contributions from the start would provoke enormous public backlash, so it started at 3% and gradually raised it to 9%. That is one part. Another is that through two rounds of pension reform, the 1998 reform cut the income replacement rate from 70% to 60%, lowering it by 10 percentage points. And the 2007 reform lowered it by 10 percentage points to 50% in 2008 and, from 2009, is lowering it by 0.5 percentage points every year so that it falls to 40% by 2028. And what the government did in 2007, besides lowering the benefit rate, had as its background the rise in average life expectancy. Average life expectancy: even in the 1960s, which listeners may not remember well, what do you think, Anchor Kwak Su-jong, our country’s average life expectancy was?
Anchor:
About 70 for men and about 72 for women; that is what I understand.
Yun Suk-myung:
In 1960?
Anchor:
Oh, the 1960s? Back then it was probably 56 or 57 for men? And for women, a year or two more...
Yun Suk-myung:
That is right. Average life expectancy was 58. But now our average life expectancy is about 80, and within the next 10 years it looks set to reach about 85. Simply arithmetically, the period of receiving a pension has lengthened by 20 years. Should that not be reflected so that not only we but also the generations after us can benefit fairly from this system? Yet the public says, “The government made promises when it introduced the National Pension system, so why does it keep changing its word?” But I think we need to see that behind those changes lies the fact that the social and economic conditions of our times are changing a great deal. So in 2007, besides lowering the benefit rate, the government tried to raise contributions to 12.9% over the long term. But because it was argued that lowering benefits and raising the contribution burden at the same time would be too harsh, contributions could not be raised to 12.9%. That part is now becoming a latent source of fiscal instability. To receive the benefit of the National Pension, one must pay contributions for at least 10 years. For workplace-insured persons, the workplace where they work supports 50% of the contributions and they bear only 50% themselves. Self-employed people, on the other hand, have to bear 100% of the contributions themselves. What has become an issue for the National Pension amid the recent controversy over the Basic Pension is what are called voluntary contributors. Voluntary contributors are people who, although they have no income, can enroll in the pension if, taking a full-time homemaker as an example, the husband says, “I receive a pension, but it is a pity my wife cannot,” and so on, and pays the contributions for her. Such people are voluntary contributors. Voluntary contributors also pay 100% of their contributions themselves, of course. But now, with talk about the Basic Pension, although the Presidential Transition Committee’s plan has not been finalized, of whether or not to pay a Basic Pension of 200,000 won a month, and of deducting the difference if one receives the National Pension, there is quite a lot of unrest among voluntary contributors. But for voluntary contributors to decide, before the Transition Committee’s plan is even finalized, “I will leave the National Pension, I will withdraw,” seems a hasty decision. The Transition Committee will also take that into full account, so it seems best to wait and see until the final plan comes out.
Anchor:
Dr. Yun has given us a detailed overview, from the history to the current situation and the problems. Professor Jeong, would you add a little more?
Jeong Chang-ryul:
Yes. Well, you have already said so much that I will just add a few points. On the long-term picture when it was first introduced, I think it would be good for listeners to understand it this way: as in the advanced countries, it was introduced as a social institution needed in the transition from an agricultural society to an industrial society. Understand the National Pension system this way: basically, in an agricultural society the family is responsible for supporting older people, but in an industrial society a basic livelihood in old age is maintained through a public pension system run by the state. The core of the National Pension is that, as a social insurance system, it is not financed by taxes; rather, while I work, while I am economically active, I am obliged to pay part of my wage as contributions, and after retiring I receive pension benefits based on the contributions I paid. I can say that this was the basic direction when it was first designed.
Anchor:
Yes. I did ask both of you beforehand, but Dr. Yun and Professor Jeong have explained the overview in considerable detail and in easy terms, so I would like to ask more detailed questions on the basis of the basics. To sum up, it seems to come to this. The history was still short. It is still inadequate. In the process, because the various statistics and plans for the future were made with a rather rosy outlook, there were parts where the changes in the population structure and the various problems that could arise in the transition to an industrial society could not be considered in advance. I think that would be the same for any system. The problem is that revisions and amendments will inevitably come in that process, and there are a great many stakeholders involved in those revisions and amendments. First there are men and women. Then there are those who work and those who do not. And there is today’s younger generation and today’s older generation. Many people seem to have doubts about these differences, the differences between those who benefit, between those who receive benefits; and in the end... on top of that, the announcements coming from the government say it will be depleted by 2060 or in 47 years, and the year of depletion comes out differently each time, does it not? Some research reports say 2060, some 2040, some 2050; I suppose that is because the processes all differ. Let me mention for reference that we set up this time hoping you could help explain these matters to the public, and while listening I would like to put a question to Dr. Yun. You say the benefit was cut from 70% to 50% and will fall to 40% by 2028; this means 70% of the benefit level one paid for, that is, the level one was supposed to receive or was receiving, is that right?
Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. That also needs a little more explanation. The National Pension system has the character of a so-called low-contribution, high-benefit structure. It is a system in which you receive a lot compared with what you paid in, right? So when calculating benefits I do use the income replacement rate, but the National Pension system needs two additional explanations. The Government Employees, Private School Teachers, and Military Pensions are 100% earnings-related pensions. The pension amount is calculated in direct proportion to one’s earnings during one’s working years, whereas in the National Pension 50% is calculated in proportion to one’s own earnings and 50% in proportion to the average earnings of all National Pension contributors. So there is an element of helping relatively low earners a little through the redistribution of income between high and low earners within the same generation. That is intragenerational income redistribution; and there is also the fact that we pay low contributions, is there not? That is the part that passes the burden on to later generations. And so we now have what is called an earnings ceiling. If, for example, someone’s monthly earnings are 7 million won, the National Pension system does not levy contributions on the 5 million or 7 million; contributions are capped at 3.89 million won. So in the case of high earners, their actual earnings are not reflected. There are two complaints about this. Those who are near retirement and favorable to the National Pension, who feel the system is good because their retirement is near, say, “Even now, I will raise the earnings ceiling to 7 or 8 million, pay more contributions, and receive a larger pension.” What is impossible, well, not impossible but difficult, about this is that the system is structured so that people receive more than they paid in, so the more the ceiling is raised, the harder it is for the National Pension’s finances. Fiscal instability... And another thing: among the general public, groups like the Taxpayers Association are now making arguments that do not hold up. I do not know why there are so many such people, but they criticize, “Is it consistent with social equity that even people with a monthly income of 50 million won are capped at 3.89 million won and pay only that much in pension contributions? Is this not wrong?” and they ask whether the effective contribution rate is not far too low; but this needs additional explanation. Some people unsettle the public by calling the National Pension a quasi-tax, but it is not a quasi-tax; one pays contributions for the purpose of preparing for one’s own old age, is that not so? From that perspective, if one pays contributions for 10 years or more, one receives a pension amount in proportion to that. So in our current National Pension system, 50% is proportional to what one paid in and 50% is relative to the average earnings of all contributors, but unless that foundation is shaken, the higher the earnings ceiling is raised, the larger the pension amount high earners receive. So, so that high earners do not take much of the stable National Pension income whose payment the state guarantees, the ceiling is fixed and they pay less; and there seem to be many complaints about that part, asking why National Pension contributions are not made to be paid in large amounts, the way taxes are.
Anchor:
It sounds like they are asking why it is not proportional.
Yun Suk-myung:
On that part, I think there is a point we need to rethink and understand precisely.
Anchor:
Professor Jeong Chang-ryul.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
One of the hardest things to explain to ordinary people about the National Pension system is this, because many people think of it as savings. As Dr. Yun also said, someone earning about 1 million won and someone earning about 4 million won pay four times as much in contributions, but the actual benefits differ by only about a factor of two. The reason is that the National Pension system fundamentally pursues the value of social adequacy. And you also mentioned 50 million won; the National Pension, as a social insurance system, is basically not meant to serve as a means of accumulating wealth. It is an investment to the extent of being able to live adequately in society. Raising the earnings ceiling for high earners so that they receive more is actually something of a contradiction under the current benefit formula: since the system is designed so that no one loses out unless they die early, that problem exists, and so it has been argued that even the formula must be touched. But in fact, if the pension debate goes as far as that, I cannot imagine where it will end, so when I go to debates and the like I try not to talk about going that far.
Anchor:
I see. A listener has just sent us a text message, and it is exactly that point. This is listener number 5062: “If salaried workers are forced to enroll, should the state not guarantee it? What happens if it goes bankrupt? Does the state guarantee it?” So there is considerable misunderstanding, is there not? The debate has now gone as far as cutting the amounts received by high-income earners from the National Pension; in Part 4 we will also go over the Basic Pension, which is now in the news. See you shortly in Part 4.
< Part 4 >
Anchor:
You are with the Saengsaeng Economy Friday Special, [The National Pension in Crisis: What Are the Issues and Solutions?].
I said this earlier: I told Dr. Yun Suk-myung and Professor Jeong Chang-ryul that this National Pension issue seems to be a harder issue than unifying North and South.
Because, in what we in economics call a matrix, men and women, those who work and those who cannot, the future and current generations, and then men and women again, all sorts of issues are mixed together, and I wonder how it can be solved.
Citizens, you must be frustrated. We asked you. Shall we have a listen?
Citizen 1:
I am paying into the National Pension, and I intend to keep paying into it. It is not that I have no worries, but I think one should invest at least that much for old age.
Citizen 2:
I do not pay into the National Pension. I used to pay in, but I am out of work and have no money, so I cannot. Even if I want to pay in, I cannot be sure I can. There is no way to earn money when you are old...
Citizen 3:
I am not paying into the National Pension. You cannot trust it, can you? I see that a lot of older people do draw it and use it. But I think that my children, or people my age, will not be able to get anything back. Even on a tight budget I pay in, but I am not confident I will really get it back later.
Citizen 4:
When I was working for a company I paid into the National Pension for about 15 years, and when I tried to withdraw 5 million won as a lump sum, they would not give it to me. Now I run my own business, and I do not pay into the National Pension. Even if you pay in for ages, you get 200,000 or 300,000 won. So they might as well abolish the National Pension altogether; for us it is of no use at all.
Citizen 5:
People are going around saying you cannot even get back the money you paid in. Is that not exactly the big problem? I think the government needs something like an explanation that clearly guarantees it. It would be really good if the authorities would give notice so that people can know in detail exactly how much they will get back if they pay how much.
Anchor:
Listening to these citizen clips just now, the older gentleman who spoke last said he wished notice would be given that a definite guarantee can be received, did he not? What do you think? Shall I ask Professor Jeong first? The National Pension... a member of the National Assembly once said it should be written into law, that the government should take responsibility and guarantee it. How does it stand? Right now... does the government take responsibility?
Jeong Chang-ryul:
I find it a little ironic that such a law is even proposed. First of all, the content itself, what exactly it would guarantee...
Anchor:
They are asking for at least 40%. Since they will pay 9%...
Jeong Chang-ryul:
No, the law already provides for paying that. What confuses the public a little is what Dr. Yun said earlier: it was said 70% would be paid, then 50%, then 40%. So it is not that “back then they said they would pay 70%, and now they pay only 40%”; up to the period for which 70% was promised, payment is still made according to the 70% formula.
Anchor:
Those people are paid the way it is being done now.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
And for the period during which 50% was promised, it is paid according to that period, and in the current situation, where it is changing to 40%, it is paid at that level. Yet most people think that because the 70% was changed to 40%, the promise to pay 70% has been scrapped and everything they paid in the past will also be counted at 40%; so they ask for a guarantee because the government keeps lying. I think this stems from a bit of a misunderstanding.
Anchor:
What do you think, Dr. Yun? Does what Professor Jeong just said mean that the government definitely guarantees the National Pension even if it is depleted? At least 40%...
Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. Now, candidate Moon Jae-in made the payment guarantee a pledge in his presidential election platform, and from my standpoint that was very worrying. Because unless the state collapses, unless the state falls apart in our socioeconomic era, the National Pension will be paid. But the reason the policy authorities are a little hesitant about writing the benefit payment guarantee 100% into law is this: the moment a benefit payment clause is inserted, the National Pension system has to be changed as our social and economic conditions change, yet if the state has guaranteed everything and then says it will change it, the government will again have nothing to say. Because of that, a 100% payment guarantee cannot be written into law; apart from that, unless the state collapses, the National Pension payment is guaranteed. It is precisely because the government intends to pay that it is trying to lower benefit levels and raise contributions despite the opposition of many stakeholders, is it not? So that not only we but also the generations after us can fully benefit from this system...
Anchor:
Briefly: as Professor Jeong just told us, those who were set to receive 70% in the past receive 70%, 50% is 50%, and 40% is 40%; but if this were written into law, many citizens could protest, “Why am I not given 70%? Why am I cut to 50%?”, and it would be written into law in a way that could even lead to constitutional complaints; it could be interpreted that way physically. Is that what you mean?
Yun Suk-myung:
Yes, that is right.
Then please talk about the second issue, stability. Dr. Yun.
Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. Well, the results of the 2nd financial projection came out in 2008. According to that projection, the fund is expected to be depleted in 2060, and the results of the 3rd projection will be announced next month, in March. Many people think, “I hear the fund will run dry in 2060,” but there are two views on this. Those of us who argue for fiscal stability argue that later generations will live in a far harder environment than we do, because with low fertility, few children are born while the number of older people surges, so the burden on future generations grows; and to lighten their burden, too, we should raise contributions and strengthen the National Pension fund. Others, however, say, “Many OECD member countries pay pensions by collecting taxes even without a fund, so why wear out the public trying to stabilize the finances?” What I want to say is that two extreme views coexist among us. In 2060, the OECD... we are a member of the OECD, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, are we not? Among the member countries of that organization, few have built up a fund like ours so that it will not run dry for such a long period. Nevertheless, the people who worry most about the National Pension fund are in our country, and I see that as a good spirit. Because we have to push the fund depletion date back further in the future, too, to reduce the burden on later generations, do we not? Italy and Greece, which did not do that, have now boarded an express train, have they not? To national bankruptcy... We will not do that; we intend to go the way of paying our own money and receiving our own pensions without placing a large burden on later generations. So since there is still a sufficient period of 47 years left, if appropriate measures are taken in the meantime, I think the National Pension system itself will become sound and there will be no problem paying benefits.
Anchor:
Professor Jeong, if economic growth, say, with the North and South Korean economies producing synergy, went back to 10% growth, you mean 2060 could become 2080?
Yun Suk-myung:
That could be, yes.
.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
It could be. So, regarding financial projections, Dr. Yun studied public finance and is far more of an expert than I am, but I think they have a large element of stoking a sense of crisis. They fix the fertility rate and fix the contribution rate and talk that way, but if, for example, depletion is expected in 2053 or in 2060, will the government really just sit still in 2020, 2030, or 2040? It will raise contributions or take various other measures. Yet the talk goes as if the contribution rate were fixed forever at a low level, so that depletion would be a disaster and no one would receive anything once it is depleted. Of course I also think making the finances sound is very important. I also clearly oppose irresponsibly using the National Pension fund for things like the Basic Pension; I am just balancing it out a bit. What is a little different from the advanced countries is that Korea now has about 3 million older people in poverty. With almost half of older people in poverty, is it really right to keep building up the fund and the like while watching elderly poverty with our eyes open? Just stability, running the fund stably, while half of older people are in elderly poverty and the elderly poverty rate is more than three times the OECD average: to say that is simply how those people lived... You mentioned compressed growth earlier; during the compressed growth from an agricultural society to an industrial society, today’s older people can be seen as those who lived assuming, naturally, that their children would provide for their old age, and then saw that system collapse. So, well, I am not sure. The finances are important and old-age income security is important, but they must be balanced; I think the discussion these days tends to lean too much to one side.
Anchor:
Dr. Yun,
Yun Suk-myung:
On most pension issues I agree 100% with Professor Jeong, but on this point the gap seems to widen a little. Now, the analogy used by Professor Kim Young-min of Chung-Ang University, who is not here, is: “Gold is piled high in the outhouse while the elders in the main room are starving; is this any way to behave?” People say that a lot, do they not?
Anchor:
That is right.
Yun Suk-myung:
At first hearing it sounds right. But the problem is this: our National Pension reserve fund now has about 400 trillion won piled up, but the reason it is piled up is that there are many paying in and few receiving; once the number of people receiving grows in earnest, we have still set aside 30% or 40% too little compared with the money we will have to pay. To give a stark example, comparing with around 2060, the older population will triple from now, right? But as the fertility rate falls, the economically active population shrinks. If we do not handle this properly, the burden on later generations will become very large, will it not? Taking that into account as well, I sympathize with the thrust of what Professor Jeong said. As for whether we will leave the current generation of older people as they are: on this, the National Pension reserves must not be touched, because that money has a label on it. People are paying in now to prepare for their own old age. So I think the poverty problem of the current generation must be solved with the capacity and strength of our generation. On that part, even if it is painful, I think we need to actively help those of the current generation who are exposed to old-age poverty, for example by paying more in taxes.
Anchor:
I have no disagreement on that either. Let us do it this way. Listening to the two of you, we need to change somewhat the value system by which we perceive the National Pension, and at its root is whether to view it as savings or as genuine insurance. Earlier, the expression “the government gives” was used, but it is not something given; it is a right one is naturally entitled to receive, is it not? So, in connection with whether it is a measure of welfare, there is the abolition argument: rather than suffer such headaches, just divide it all up 1/n, hand it out, and abolish it. If you two could speak to a solution to that, by way of conclusion... and when you have finished, I will read out the questions listeners have sent in.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
On the National Pension, I know the Taxpayers Association and others are saying this, and of course there is something very worrying about it, but I think it is necessary in the sense of raising an alarm for the next administration to get this properly established. What I find quite ironic is that health insurance, unlike the National Pension... in health insurance, if my income is very high, the earnings ceiling is very high, so among high earners there are quite a few who pay more than 4 million won in contributions not a year but a month. Such people have no way to get it back if they do not go to the hospital, right?
Anchor:
That is right.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
If they do not go to the hospital, it all just disappears,
Anchor:
That is right.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
And yet few people say they will not pay health insurance contributions. With the National Pension, on the other hand, as I said earlier, under the current benefit formula not a single person loses out, right? Unless they die early... And yet, although it is actuarially an enormous gain, people all try not to pay.
Anchor:
They say you pay 100% and get back 40%...
Jeong Chang-ryul:
Far more than that; you receive far more than you paid in. For reference, in the case of retirement pensions, people pay 8.3% and the expected income replacement rate is said to be about 10 to 15%. Compared with that, the National Pension has a far stronger income security function.
Anchor:
Yes, so it seems.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
The reason is that with the health insurance system, when you pay contributions, you benefit, your parents benefit, and your children benefit, and you see that with your own eyes. The National Pension is not like that. Because it is a funded scheme, until now few people who paid contributions have received sufficient benefits. But in about 10 more years, as the system matures further and stabilizes, once there are people around receiving 800,000 won, 1 million won, or 1.5 million won, and people realize, “Wow, because my parents enrolled in the National Pension, their children can live comfortably too,” then, just as people came to trust health insurance, I think we can expect everyone to recognize that the National Pension is also a truly important system in our lives.
Anchor:
Now, Dr. Yun Suk-myung.
Yun Suk-myung:
Yes. On the National Pension, as Professor Jeong says, the generation in their 20s and 30s and the generation in their 50s and 60s seem completely different. When young, people say, “Why is the state meddling with me? I do not need it; I will handle everything well myself,” but once they get older, even just past their mid-40s, when they start to worry about old age, their position changes completely: “I will pay more National Pension contributions, so please let me.” So on this point it would be good for young people, too, to understand the system better. Next, on the perspective of whether it is savings, social insurance, or a measure of welfare: some may think differently from me, but I believe it should first be recognized as having a strong savings character. In European countries it is said to rest on social solidarity, but do they not say that a tangerine that crosses the sea becomes a trifoliate orange? I do not mean that our pension system becomes something bad like a trifoliate orange, but that we must carry the concept of the system in a way that fits the country’s social and cultural environment; in that respect, what the people of our country think, first, is that it is old-age savings; second, whether they can get back what they paid in; and third, whether it is acceptable for those who paid in diligently to lose out compared with those who did not. They are very sensitive about these three parts. Only if we take the National Pension system in a direction where these three are firmly upheld will public participation be very high. Next, the Taxpayers Association’s abolition argument: I am sorry to say this while we are on air, but I really think they are saying things that deceive the world and delude the people. They are greatly misrepresenting the facts, using very provocative and emotional language toward a public that does not understand the National Pension system well. We all need to respond to that properly.
Anchor:
Yes. Let me ask just one thing briefly, since we do not have much time left... a Basic Pension of 200,000 won, the new administration’s promise... what do you think? Briefly...
Yun Suk-myung:
The Basic Pension was proposed to solve the problem of high old-age poverty and the high elderly suicide rate. First of all, as for alleviating old-age poverty, well, relatively speaking, not all older people are in that situation; income gaps are widest among older people, right? I think it would be better to take it toward an appropriate policy mix, under which low-income older people can receive real benefits and no great burden falls on later generations, rather than paying it across the board.
Anchor:
Listeners are sending in so many text messages that I will read them out, and please answer one of them. Number 7738: “Could it not be optional instead of mandatory? I understand that the government worries about the people’s old age, but I think old age is strictly an individual responsibility. The house-poor seem to be in the same vein. Honestly, I do not want to do it.” Number 9233: “Does the National Pension have an early withdrawal feature? There are people who suffer financial hardship even before their pension begins...” Number 3687: “Is it not a feast for the National Pension Service’s employees? The Service has far too many employees. And people leave public office, then work at the Service and receive pensions; it should all be returned, even now.” Number 2268: “Are National Pension contributions paid equally by the worker and the employer, and is the actual amount paid so far the sum of the two? How does someone who has not completed 10 years receive it?” And number 1740: “A pension is a pension and a tax is a tax. If even pensions emphasize only the wealth-redistribution function, like taxes, the resistance could be great.” Number 6720: “I just listened, but 50, 70, what does that mean...” I think listening to the program again on replay would help with that. “Should we not get back 100% plus interest?” That is what they said, and there are so many questions coming in after that; would you answer some of them? Among them...
Jeong Chang-ryul:
Yes. As for “plus interest,” I would like to say the rate is enormously high. As for what happens if one does not complete 10 years, that is a very practical matter: for example, people who were economically active for four or five years and then continue as homemakers can, if they enroll voluntarily and complete 10 years, acquire a pension entitlement.
Yun Suk-myung:
If someone has not completed 10 years by the time they turn 60, the contributions for the part they did not complete are returned as a lump-sum refund, with market interest added. People ask why it is not returned sooner; it is tied up so that they can prepare for old age. On optional versus mandatory: when people are young, they think they can move the whole world, right?
Anchor:
That is right.
Yun Suk-myung:
The reason 170 countries abroad, too, run public pension systems is that, when people are left alone... if our pension system had also been introduced back in the 1960s, would the elderly poverty rate be this high? When young, people think they can do it all, but in the sense that preparation for old age happens only when it is somewhat compulsory, I think making it mandatory is right. Well, I have spoken about early withdrawal, and as for the “public-sector feast,” there is a lot of misunderstanding there rather than fact.
Anchor:
There is some exaggeration too. Yes. We invited the two of you today and heard what you had to say, but I will have to ask our staff to do this one more time. There is more to cover later, and listeners are very interested as well. I am sorry to ask, but please do come back again sometime, both of you.
Yun Suk-myung:
Yes, thank you.
Jeong Chang-ryul:
Yes, certainly.
Anchor:
Yes, we will count on it.
That was Yun Suk-myung, Director of the Pension Research Center at the Population Strategy Research Institute of the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs, and Professor Jeong Chang-ryul of the Department of Social Welfare at Dankook University.
[Copyright (c) YTN radio. Unauthorized reproduction, redistribution, and use as AI data prohibited.]
https://m.radio.ytn.co.kr/interview_view.php?id=23293&s_mcd=0206
