(Maeil Shinmun) Yoo Seung-min: “Moon’s Answer to National Pension Depletion Is Increasing the Number of Contributors? A Fraud on the Public” (July 18, 2021)

Yoo Seung-min and Moon Jae-in. Yonhap News

Former Representative Yoo Seung-min’s Facebook
Former Representative Yoo Seung-min, an opposition presidential contender, set out his position on the 18th on National Pension reform for the younger generation.
Concerns about the depletion of the National Pension have been raised steadily, and the outlook is widespread that those in their 20s, 30s, and 40s who are now paying into the National Pension will not actually receive their pensions properly.
In this connection, at around 2:02 p.m. that day, former Representative Yoo posted on his Facebook a piece titled “I Will Surely Carry Out National Pension Reform So That the 2040 Generation Can Also Receive Pensions.”
He also attached a YouTube video showing the scene from a TV debate in the last presidential election in which he clashed with then-candidate Moon Jae-in over the National Pension.
▶In the post, former Representative Yoo cited Professor Lee Chang-su, the incoming President of the Korean Pension Association, and Dr. Yun Suk-myung, its current President, as having said, “The current pension system keeps shifting the burden onto later generations. At some point, a revolt of future generations will break out,” and “Our population structure is the worst in the world, yet pension reform is moving the slowest,” and asserted that “the National Pension is headed for a scheduled bankruptcy.”
He went on: “According to one opinion poll, trust in the National Pension among the 2040 generation was 10% for those in their 20s, 15.2% for those in their 30s, and 19.6% for those in their 40s,” adding that “the younger people are, the more their trust has hit rock bottom.”
He noted that “the biggest reason for distrust, at 62.2%, was anxiety that they will not receive pensions in old age because of fund depletion,” and added that “according to the government’s announcement, the National Pension will start running deficits every year from 2042, and the fund will be fully depleted in 2057.”
Former Representative Yoo, however, pointed out that “even this projection that the fund will be depleted in 2057 is in fact far too ‘rosy,’” criticizing that “this projection assumes a total fertility rate of 1.24, and the mere fact that the fertility rate already plunged to 0.84 last year shows how complacent the government’s outlook is.”
▶Former Representative Yoo then went on the attack against President Moon Jae-in, pointing out that “while the time bomb of National Pension bankruptcy ticks ever closer, administrations that change every five years have all washed their hands of it and done nothing but pass the bomb around. President Moon Jae-in in particular pledged as a candidate that he would ‘let people receive larger pensions without raising contributions.’”
He took aim, saying, “At the time, in a TV debate, I asked, ‘How on earth can you raise the income replacement rate to 50% without raising contributions? The fund will be depleted in the 2050s—with what money will you solve that? If you do not raise contributions, do you mean you will ultimately fill the gap with taxes?’ Candidate Moon Jae-in replied, ‘Are there not various ways? In many countries, does the state not directly allocate budget funds for the national pension? The most fundamental way is to increase the number of National Pension contributors,’” and asked, “What was the result of this populism? It was a fraud on the public. With the total fertility rate falling, how on earth can the number of pension contributors be increased?”
He further pointed out that “in 2018 President Moon Jae-in kicked away the pension reform plan the Ministry of Health and Welfare had drawn up. The reason was that ‘I will not carry out a pension reform the public does not want,’” expressing concern that “because of bad politics, reform has gone missing, and only the second hand of the time bomb keeps moving toward the end.”
▶Former Representative Yoo stressed: “We must now stop passing the bomb around. For the future of young people, the time bomb that is the National Pension must be reformed. We must be able to say confidently to the 2040 generation, ‘Rest assured—we will reform it so that you can receive pensions 30 or 40 years from now,’” adding, “This is the ‘duty of adults’ in our time. The one-sided sacrifice of the 2040 generation must no longer be forced.”
Former Representative Yoo then made the following pledges on National Pension reform.
1. I will carry out pension reform to delay the point of depletion as long as possible, so that young people are never left paying in only to receive no pension later because the National Pension has been depleted.
2. By honoring the benefits promised before the time of reform and not applying the changes retroactively, I will seek the public’s consent to pension reform and remove any risk of unconstitutionality from retroactive application.
3. I will disclose the entire process and content of the pension reform discussions transparently to the public to win their trust and support.
4. For the elderly poor who may face hardship because of pension reform, the state will take responsibility for their old age through Fair Income (a negative income tax + a social safety net).
He also stressed that he already has experience in pushing pension reform: “In 2015, as floor leader of the Saenuri Party, I stood at the very front and led the Government Employees Pension reform, persuaded the then-opposition Democratic Party, and in the end achieved the reform. Although it was a half-reform, it was a reform that saved 37 trillion won of taxpayers’ money over 30 years and 333 trillion won over 70 years.”
Former Representative Yoo went on to criticize: “Do not be stirred up any longer by populism that promises to hand out money. If we do not elect a president in this election who will carry out pension reform, today’s young generation and our descendants have no hope,” adding, “The Moon Jae-in administration has already shown vividly what happens when you elect a candidate who has never thought seriously about the economy or welfare. The result of the stubborn insistence on beating things down no matter what was crazy housing prices and crazy jeonse and monthly rents, and the result of turning away from pension reform is the depletion of the pension.”
He added: “Even if it is painful right now, I will surely achieve the pension reform that is absolutely necessary for the bright future of our young people. When everyone else was making sweet promises to hand out money, there were dissenting voices asking whether a candidate who needs votes in a presidential election really has to put out such an unpopular pledge,” and “It may look foolish, but I thought of politics as a vocation. I thought that, at the very least, we must prevent our young people from paying in only to receive no pension later.”
He concluded the post: “It is for the very same reason that I oppose a basic income and universal disaster relief payments, which squander the national treasury recklessly and in the end only increase the debts of future generations,” adding, “I hope you will choose reform for a healthy and hopeful future for the community that is the Republic of Korea.”
