(Kyunghyang Shinmun) Government Employees Pension Reform Adrift: “Serving Civil Servants Must Also Share the Pain for Fiscal Stability” (October 15, 2014)
Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at KIHASA
In an interview with the Kyunghyang Shinmun on the 15th, Yun Suk-myung, Research Fellow at the Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs (pictured), called for a “more for the lower, less for the upper” style of Government Employees Pension reform and said that a burden needs to be placed on serving civil servants as well.
He also suggested that the Government Employees Pension needs to be simplified so that it can be compared with the National Pension.
![[Government Employees Pension Reform Adrift] “Serving Civil Servants Must Also Share the Pain for Fiscal Stability”](https://img.khan.co.kr/news/2014/10/15/l_2014101601002370900187681.webp)
As the reason reform is urgent, Research Fellow Yun cited socioeconomic conditions that have changed greatly since the scheme was introduced in 1960. Average life expectancy, which was 52 at the time, has risen to 81, and when a male civil servant dies, a survivor’s pension (70% of the amount he received while alive) is paid to his female spouse, who has a longer life expectancy, so that the period of receiving the pension reaches 35 to 40 years. As of the end of last year, the Government Employees Pension had 1.07 million members, with an average length of service of 17 years and 6 months. With socioeconomic conditions having changed and the number of beneficiaries steadily rising, if the scheme is not reformed the deficit will keep widening, and the cumulative deficit subsidy over the next 10 years is estimated to reach 53 trillion won.
Research Fellow Yun also pointed out the limits of the Korean Pension Association’s reform plan released on the 21st of last month, saying, “Even if the Association’s plan is implemented as is, the government’s deficit subsidy in 2020 will be 3.8 trillion won a year, so it is not a plan that puts the emphasis on fiscal stabilization.” On the direction of Government Employees Pension reform, Research Fellow Yun said, “To heighten the fiscal stabilization effect, serving employees also need to take part wisely in sharing the pain.” He said, “With an earnings-related pension, in which you get back as much as you pay in, the pain that lower-ranking employees with small salaries must bear is greater,” adding, “A change in the system will be painful for everyone, but considering that the purpose of public pensions is to secure livelihoods in old age, the reform should follow the ‘more for the lower, less for the upper’ approach.”
Research Fellow Yun said that the Government Employees Pension should be simplified into a scheme comparable with the National Pension, and that the “income redistribution” function of the National Pension should be appropriately introduced into the Government Employees Pension as well. He said, however, that integrating it with the National Pension would not be easy in practice. That is because if the Government Employees Pension deficit were covered with the National Pension fund, a backlash from National Pension members would be inevitable, and if new civil servants were moved into the National Pension, the Government Employees Pension’s finances could deteriorate further.
